Wouldn't Thoman's first place swim be more impressive than Phelps' second place swim?
I think the most impressive swim, although not a surprise at all, was Soni in the 200 breast. She just flat out dominated the field and swam the best time in the world this year by over a second. Not sure what her taper status was for the meet, but that bodes really well for her at Pan Pac's this summer and World's next year.
http://theswimmerscircle.com/blog/2010/05/18/vanderkaay-soni-cash-in-big-at-charlotte-grand-prix/In case anyone's interested in reading about some of the more interesting story lines from the meet. Always a heck of a show put on by the folks in Charlotte.