No offense, but those are some pretty terrible arguments, BtotheRob.
Everyone has already agreed that Wolff is probably going to be on the WC squad. I think he'll be there (1) because we simply don't have any other forwards, and (2) he is second only to McBride in competition experience.
I think most of us are also aware of Wolff's record with the national team. He has finished better at times in the past, but off the top of my head I think he has 8 or 9 goals in ~45 caps. That's simply not enough production for someone to expect to be a starter on this team. And keep in mind that his recent scoring percentage is quite a bit lower than his overall numbers.
A few other points:
- Past performance (as in several years ago) doesn't mean much, especially with the talented youngsters emerging on this team. Just because he has done good things in the past doesn't mean he's the best man for the job now.
- Pointing out that he was better BEFORE surgery mostly hurts your case, as it provides an explanation for his decreased production and suggests that he may never return to his previous form.
- Club performance can get you a chance on the national team, but it's really irrelevant once you get there. If you don't produce on the national team, someone else gets a chance (or, at least, they should).
- Wolff's problems finishing are not confined to just his past few caps. He has scored exactly 3 goals since 2002 (one of which was a PK against Scotland), despite playing in a large percentage of the US matches.
- Again, regardless of Wolff's production in the decent past, he has not done much in the past couple of years. Why should anyone expect that to change in the World Cup? I certainly hope it does change, and I think Wolff is capable of being a great player up front, but I'm not holding my breath expecting anything great from him in Germany.
To me, Wolff is the embodiment of my frustrations with the USMNT over the past few years: they control the ball and move it well, even dominate games, but just can't put the ball in the back of the net.
Now we are seeing some new guys showing some creativity on the attack and actually scoring goals. Wolff does other things quite well, but scoring is the bottom line, and I think this team does accomplishes that better right now without Josh Wolff.