cbr said:
Ok quick question - no musical background whatsoever.
Do you learn music, then technique, then songs, and become an artist, or can you just try to learn a song at a time and become a fairly effective parrot?
If you practice diligently say 3-4 hours a week, what is a reasonable range of time frames where you might expect to become able to play a few tunes that don't sound like *****
I just picked up a guitar at ~13, my friend showed me iron man, and I was roughly able to play it/form the power chords right away. Then started learning some metallica riffs.. I don't even remember when I started actually strumming chords, but it was way later, after learning a lot of metallica and grunge riffs. I never took lessons. My mom is a music teacher, so I picked up some basic theory pretty easily/quickly. learned to read tab right away as well, but usually got frustrated with it having to look back and forth and turn pages. This was early/mid 90s, so there wasn't the slew of youtube vidoes of guys breaking down how to play songs or auto scrolling tab apps. Because of that, I mostly learned to play stuff by ear. I don't know if that is a skill you can learn though.
About 10-15 years in, I thought I plateau'd, but I definitely think I'm better now 25 years in. I was in a band playing regular weekend shows from about year 13-23, many of those a sole guitarist, so did a lot of jamming/soloing and that definitely helps, cause I'm always learning new songs (instead of just playing all the same old ones I like), and even played in a country band for a year recently which again expanded my repertoire and skill set.
As far as practicing, I think you can get pretty sufficient at playing a lot of songs within a year or so, playing a few hours a week.
But, if you just like strumming country songs, that's about as good as you'll ever get. If you are into more technical stuff like rock/metal, or even say something like dave matthews, you'll likely be a better player compared to if you just strummed eagles songs, you know what I mean? So that all depends on what you anticipate playing.