I wouldn't trust him handling a little league pitcher must less a Major Leaguer. I agree he is highly overrated, maybe Cincy takes the next step with a new skipper.
gonna be honest...I thought Dusty improved his reputation/legacy as a manager during his Reds' tenure.
He got the Reds to the playoffs in 2010, 2012, and 2013. Snapped a 16-year playoff drought for the franchise. Competed very well against the Cardinals with less talent and fewer resources