Michael Wacha should get it for his last 2 outings, even if playoffs don't count and even though he isn't eligible! Go Cards!

he's teammate should probably get it, but they'll ive it to the 20 year old from the AAA marlins.

jose fernandez

Puig

Wacha was not with the team enough to win it as a pitcher. Anyways the Dodger's Yasiel Puig will win going away and deservedly so. Also, playoff performances don't factor into the vote.

I know this.....come on man!


I was just giving Wacha another thread to give him props.

Jose Fernandez
Puig 2nd

Shelby Miller should be mentioned in this discussion.

[This message has been edited by NavyAg92 (edited 10/8/2013 7:01p).]

quote:

---

he's teammate should probably get it

---

I think Puig will get it, however I think Fernandez would have if he didn't get hurt. Miller would be my pick.

Puig, Fernandez and Miller... That's a pretty nice class of rookies. Add in G Cole and Wacha... Damn.

I am obviously biased as a Dodger fan, but the fact that Puig put up his numbers in meaningful games should carry some weight. The wheels were about to come off in LA before Puig came up and had the best 50 game stretch by a rookie since Joe DiMaggio.

Jose Fernandez is a great talent, but he had next to zero pressure playing in an empty stadium for a last place Marlins team.

i hate the Dodgers, but I'd go with Puig.

Puig got screwed.