Women's Bracket Outrage

1,825 Views | 5 Replies | Last: 3 yr ago by racerfink
Gap
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Connecticut didn't earn a #1 seed this year. And the "committee" awards Connecticut with home games all the way to the final 4. #1 seed NC State will have to go to Connecticut and beat them there to earn a trip to the Final 4.

What a joke. They will give some 1970s acceptable excuse about selling tickets that the women's game was supposed to be beyond in the name of equity and fairness.

Bottom line is that ESPN is involved in selecting the bracket and wants the predictability of Connecticut being the most relevant team so that they can schedule their non-conference games for national tv before the season instead of the riskier option of putting other programs in those national tv slots.

Too much corruption around things that are supposed to be independent and it hurts the game.
Positive Yardage
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
You understand the following, right?
1) The regional sites are selected through bid process years in advance
2) The top two seeds are protected and sent to the regional site closest to you except in instances where another conference member is ahead of you on the seed line and already assigned there.

So in this instance,
South Carolina is the overall 1, so they host and are sent to Greensboro (closest regional site)
Stanford is 2, and sent to Spokane
NC State is the third No. 1-seed and has two possibles: Bridgeport and Wichita. It's 566 miles from campus to Bridgeport, and 1200+ to Wichita, so they go to Bridgeport.

It was obvious Louisville and Baylor were 4-5 on the seed list, so they were both destined to Wichita and their jersey color determined by the Big XII title game that Baylor lost.

So now the conspiracy boils down to does UConn have a right to be 6 on the seed list, where they would be sent to Bridgeport? The other two seeds in play are Texas and Iowa.

NET rankings: UConn (4), Texas (8), Iowa (13). UConn was ranked 9 in the last committee rankings of the year. Michigan was ranked ahead of them and went 2-4. LSU was also ranked ahead of them, and lost their first game in the SEC Tounament. Iowa State was also ahead and went 2-2 down the stretch and lost to Texas three times this year as well as Baylor and LSU. They were destined for the 3-seed line. All three of UConn, Texas, and Iowa managed to win their conference tournament, so no differentiation there. So that puts UConn at 6 on the seed list.

You could argue Texas jumping UConn due to the win over Baylor, and I would be fine with that, but then Texas is the two-seed in Greensboro, because it is 600 miles closer to that than Bridgeport. So even if UConn is 7 on the seed list they are still going to Bridgeport.

It's a crappy break for NC State. But it is not a conspiracy that 'awarded' UConn anything.

Gap
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
You are caught up in process trying to find an excuse. You are trying to create equity by 1v8, 2v7, etc. but those are rules that come after the general principles. A lower seed team doesn't get home court by simple principle. Just like the NCAA moves conference teams seeding so you don't play another SEC team early.

They wouldn't do this on the men's side because people would notice.

And in fact, looking at NET, NC State would have gotten Texas as their 2 seed based on your rules. So it doesn't work anyway.
Positive Yardage
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Gap said:



They wouldn't do this on the men's side because people would notice.
Please see:
2019 4-seed Kansas in Midwest Regional at Kansas City (KU lost and didn't make it there)

And you might remember 3-seed Texas A&M playing 6-seed Lousiville in Lexington, Kentucky in 2007?
Gap
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
There was talk of "reform" after that in 2019 because it got headlines. But of course that talk is designed to just delay enough until the buzz dies.

No one cared about us in Lexington vs Louisville but us because it didn't impact them. I was there and it was ridiculous. One of my favorite Aggie memories because it was a hostile away crowd that we quite-ed.

Now which one of these situations should happen again? The people making the bracket know exactly what they are doing.
racerfink
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Things like #20 FGCU being a 12 seed (beating LSU this season), however…
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.