Property insurance is getting pretty tough in the coastal areas, and it's only going to get worse. Most all carriers are tightening up on their underwriting guidelines so unless you have a fully replaced roof newer than 15 years old, and have fully replaced the plumbing, electrical and heating in the last 30 years, you will likely be stuck with an ACV basic form policy and pay more for that then you did for a quality policy 3 years ago. This is especially true with tenant occupied property.
I would be surprised if Goosehead had options Liere does not since they are both independent and for the most part represent the same companies. Then again, I am not too well versed on smaller property markets as I am in the commercial world. My property market experience focuses on larger property schedules, strip centers, warehouse…etc. In the commercial world, we have seen a 150%+ increase in premiums for coastal property over the last couple of years. It's becoming unsustainable for a number of property/business owners.
All that so say, I wish you the best of luck. It will not be an easy task to find adequate coverage at an "affordable" premium, at least not right now.