Mask questions

3,133 Views | 34 Replies | Last: 5 yr ago by notex
wcb
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Apologies if it's been asked, and this is assuming you believe masks work (at any level). Not being facetious here, legitimately curious.

Once you've had the vaccine, any need to continue to wear a mask?

Once you've had COVID, any need to continue to wear a mask?
Aggie95
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
depends on what science you believe...

the belief is that even once vaccinated, you might not get sick from COVID but you can still "catch" it and spread it to others that are not vaccinated or immune.

probably the same with immunity post-covid
Please tell me there's a special place in Heaven for Aggie fans! It's like we are living some sort of penance on Earth.
cjeffery20
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Aggie95 said:

depends on what science you believe...

the belief is that even once vaccinated, you might not get sick from COVID but you can still "catch" it and spread it to others that are not vaccinated or immune.

probably the same with immunity post-covid
If you're vaccinated and immune to the virus, how can you "catch" it and spread it?

That's the one thing about this virus that makes little to no sense and so many people seem to be eating it up.

What other viruses do you know of that you can be immune to/have the immunities for and still spread?
"Most likely none."

CW Griswold
How long do you want to ignore this user?
What's the point of the vaccine if you still "need" to wear a mask post-vaccination?
-
MiMi
How long do you want to ignore this user?
S
I believe it will depend on whether or not the vaccinated individual developed a protective level of immunity to the virus. It is likely that antibody titer tests will not be routinely available. It will also take some time to have a significant number of vaccinated individuals (aka herd immunity) in the population. Therefore, I suspect the recommendation will be to still take the 'usual' precautions - face masks, hand-washing, social distancing, etc. during the early phases of vaccine distribution.
amercer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think as the vaccine rolls out, masks will go away. I certainly won't wear one after getting the vaccine.

Unfortunately there are plenty of people (including on here) who will swear they had Covid because they got some sniffles last January. So I seriously doubt any place that has mask requirements right now would switch to a "don't worry about it if you already had Covid" policy.

All of this sucks, but light is at the end of the tunnel.
cone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
until there's any proof of durable sterilizing immunity, people are still going to bang on the mask drum.

but all public health typically operates at the tacit acceptance of the public. if the preference cascade goes against masking subsequent to vaccinations, it doesn't matter what the powers that be advise initially.

the thing they need to communicate is that vaccination in and of itself is going to be a 1-2 month process. you're still going to want to be careful for a while even after your second dose.
inch05
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
masks also help prevent, generally, other harmful things from entering your body...so colds/flus, etc...too.
cjeffery20
How long do you want to ignore this user?
inch05 said:

masks also help prevent, generally, other harmful things from entering your body...so colds/flus, etc...too.
Did you worry about the cold/flu or other "harmful things" to the point where you felt you needed to wear a mask everywhere you went pre-covid? Probably not.

Not going to give up my civil liberties in the long term so that people can feel safer from the cold and flu. We didn't wear masks for those viruses/illnesses pre-covid and we shouldn't wear them post-covid either.
Aggie95
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
cjeffery20 said:

Aggie95 said:

depends on what science you believe...

the belief is that even once vaccinated, you might not get sick from COVID but you can still "catch" it and spread it to others that are not vaccinated or immune.

probably the same with immunity post-covid
If you're vaccinated and immune to the virus, how can you "catch" it and spread it?

That's the one thing about this virus that makes little to no sense and so many people seem to be eating it up.

What other viruses do you know of that you can be immune to/have the immunities for and still spread?
"Most likely none."




Strep...a lot of people carry it but never have symptoms.
Please tell me there's a special place in Heaven for Aggie fans! It's like we are living some sort of penance on Earth.
AggieSarah01
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Wouldn't it be better to be exposed to things, like colds? Keep our immune systems going? I thought that antibacterial soaps and sanitizers were bad if used all the time because you need some exposure. I believe the same thing should be true about viruses.
cjeffery20
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Aggie95 said:

cjeffery20 said:

Aggie95 said:

depends on what science you believe...

the belief is that even once vaccinated, you might not get sick from COVID but you can still "catch" it and spread it to others that are not vaccinated or immune.

probably the same with immunity post-covid
If you're vaccinated and immune to the virus, how can you "catch" it and spread it?

That's the one thing about this virus that makes little to no sense and so many people seem to be eating it up.

What other viruses do you know of that you can be immune to/have the immunities for and still spread?
"Most likely none."




Strep...a lot of people carry it but never have symptoms.
Strep is a bacterial infection. As far as I know and from the little research I've done, those who have strep with no symptoms are less likely to spread the infection.

My question was do you know of any "viruses" that you can be immune to or receive immunities for (through vaccination) but still "carry" and spread to others?
beerad12man
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
inch05 said:

masks also help prevent, generally, other harmful things from entering your body...so colds/flus, etc...too.
This sounds like a push for masks forever. No thanks. Masks suck something awful. Not worth it, and hardly even work for covid unless done properly and the right type.
beerad12man
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AggieSarah01 said:

Wouldn't it be better to be exposed to things, like colds? Keep our immune systems going? I thought that antibacterial soaps and sanitizers were bad if used all the time because you need some exposure. I believe the same thing should be true about viruses.
I would think so. I may be wrong, but logic says it's how we have developed and prospered for thousands of years. I also believe there may be something with younger people's immunities, and potentially even asian countries, in terms of previous immunity to coronaviruses that have helped with covid 19.

Trying to play god by wearing masks was never what humans were intended to evolve through.
bigtruckguy3500
How long do you want to ignore this user?
cjeffery20 said:

Aggie95 said:

cjeffery20 said:

Aggie95 said:

depends on what science you believe...

the belief is that even once vaccinated, you might not get sick from COVID but you can still "catch" it and spread it to others that are not vaccinated or immune.

probably the same with immunity post-covid
If you're vaccinated and immune to the virus, how can you "catch" it and spread it?

That's the one thing about this virus that makes little to no sense and so many people seem to be eating it up.

What other viruses do you know of that you can be immune to/have the immunities for and still spread?
"Most likely none."




Strep...a lot of people carry it but never have symptoms.
Strep is a bacterial infection. As far as I know and from the little research I've done, those who have strep with no symptoms are less likely to spread the infection.

My question was do you know of any "viruses" that you can be immune to or receive immunities for (through vaccination) but still "carry" and spread to others?


There are people that are chronic shedders of mono.

But the thing here is that, the way the vaccine studies were done, they didn't test for if you got infected. They tested for of you got symptoms and then you were tested for infection. There is no proof that they prevent you from catching it altogether, they just have demonstrated that if you got it, you did not get a symptomatic infection, and if you did, it was not severe. That was the endpoint the study was trying to evaluate.

I plan on wearing a mask after I get the vaccine because I feel like I need to set an example. I also don't want to have to pull out a vaccine card anytime I go to some store with a mask mandate.

However, once we've reached large scale vaccination levels, and the threat is reasonably low, and local mask mandates start going away, I will ditch the mask.

As much of a proponent of masks as I am, if mandates don't go away at the appropriate time I will certainly push for them to go away.
NASAg03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AggieSarah01 said:

Wouldn't it be better to be exposed to things, like colds? Keep our immune systems going? I thought that antibacterial soaps and sanitizers were bad if used all the time because you need some exposure. I believe the same thing should be true about viruses.
Exhibit A: children

Regularly exposed to coronaviruses, and seem largely resistant to covid-19.

Masks are not the solution.
NicosMachine
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Biden says he will make us wear masks for 100 days because masks are magic. Countries, states, counties, and cities with masks mandates have eradicated Covid. Their hospitals are empty. Those countries, states, counties and cities without mandates have been wiped out.
Cisgendered, heteronormative, male.
CDub06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Thank you for your absurdity and hyperbole. It adds so much to this discussion.
TexasAggie008
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
It will depend if you live in a blue state or a red state
NicosMachine
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
CDub06 said:

Thank you for your absurdity and hyperbole. It adds so much to this discussion.
If you have data showing a correlation between between deaths per 100,000 and mask mandates, please feel free to add value to the discussion.

https://rationalground.com/mask-charts/
Cisgendered, heteronormative, male.
fightingfarmer09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bigtruckguy3500 said:

cjeffery20 said:

Aggie95 said:

cjeffery20 said:

Aggie95 said:

depends on what science you believe...

the belief is that even once vaccinated, you might not get sick from COVID but you can still "catch" it and spread it to others that are not vaccinated or immune.

probably the same with immunity post-covid
If you're vaccinated and immune to the virus, how can you "catch" it and spread it?

That's the one thing about this virus that makes little to no sense and so many people seem to be eating it up.

What other viruses do you know of that you can be immune to/have the immunities for and still spread?
"Most likely none."




Strep...a lot of people carry it but never have symptoms.
Strep is a bacterial infection. As far as I know and from the little research I've done, those who have strep with no symptoms are less likely to spread the infection.

My question was do you know of any "viruses" that you can be immune to or receive immunities for (through vaccination) but still "carry" and spread to others?


There are people that are chronic shedders of mono.

But the thing here is that, the way the vaccine studies were done, they didn't test for if you got infected. They tested for of you got symptoms and then you were tested for infection. There is no proof that they prevent you from catching it altogether, they just have demonstrated that if you got it, you did not get a symptomatic infection, and if you did, it was not severe. That was the endpoint the study was trying to evaluate.

I plan on wearing a mask after I get the vaccine because I feel like I need to set an example. I also don't want to have to pull out a vaccine card anytime I go to some store with a mask mandate.

However, once we've reached large scale vaccination levels, and the threat is reasonably low, and local mask mandates start going away, I will ditch the mask.

As much of a proponent of masks as I am, if mandates don't go away at the appropriate time I will certainly push for them to go away.


This has to be sarcasm, correct?

Also, what is the appropriate time? When Dear Leader says so? Or when cases drop to levels that much of the country already is at (and has been), yet people are chastised about not wearing a mask?

Jack Boyett
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Guys, you're forgetting a very, very important point. The vaccine is only 95% effective.

Therefore vaccinated people will still be getting the virus. If masks can save even 1 life......
Aust Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Haha!
bigtruckguy3500
How long do you want to ignore this user?
No sarcasm. I will probably get the vaccine before majority of the people I'm around, and I still want everyone I'm around to continue wearing a mask so they don't spread to each other. If you don't hold any leadership positions I can see how not setting an example might not matter to you, but I've been extremely diligent in my mask wear to ensure everyone around me knows I think they're important and they should wear it.

Appropriate time is when the science supports it. Once there's adequate immunity (via vaccination or natural infection) to prevent rampant spread and once hospitalization levels drop to a very manageable level would be two big things in my mind. Add in a little bit of a buffer so we maintain momentum in the right direction and don't rebound (maybe 2 months or so).

Not sure I'm reading your last question correctly. But if someone were to travel from a high risk area to a low risk area, I would want them wearing a mask to prevent that low risk area from exploding. As such I believe until the country as a whole gets things under control, we need to be mindful of how our actions will affect others wherever we go. Another reason why I'll continue to wear a mask. Not everyone that sees me, knows me, and knows that I've already gotten a vaccine.
cone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
it would be polite to wear masks during flu season

something small we can do to save lives
The_Fox
How long do you want to ignore this user?
cone said:

it would be polite to wear masks during flu season

something small we can do to save lives
This mask BS is done. Done!
jetch17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
cone said:

it would be polite to wear masks during flu season

something small we can do to save lives
94chem
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If my vaccination could cause other people to get infected, I'd wear the mask for 10 days or so.
94chem
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The_Fox said:

cone said:

it would be polite to wear masks during flu season

something small we can do to save lives
This mask BS is done. Done!


You said this in May. You might be an enabler.
NicosMachine
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
cone said:

it would be polite to wear masks during flu season

something small we can do to save lives
Why not always? There are always potential illnesses we might spread. Why not always social distance and shut down sporting events to show how much we care?
Cisgendered, heteronormative, male.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
cone said:

it would be polite to wear masks during flu season

something small we can do to save lives



Please be a troll
Capitol Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
inch05 said:

masks also help prevent, generally, other harmful things from entering your body...so colds/flus, etc...too.


It's better to get some of those "harmful" things to enter body longterm for better immune system. Masking after Covid is actually a horrible idea.
Capitol Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
cone said:

it would be polite to wear masks during flu season

something small we can do to save lives


That's funny...
CowtownEng
How long do you want to ignore this user?
cone said:

it would be polite to wear masks during flu season

something small we can do to save lives


Lol. No.
bigtruckguy3500
How long do you want to ignore this user?
cone said:

it would be polite to wear masks during flu season

something small we can do to save lives
I think if more people just got their annual flu vaccine it would do more than continued mask wear.

Of course there are dozens of other viral and bacterial infections that could be prevented by masks, but I'm not sure if that benefit would be worth potential other drawbacks (read up on the hygiene hypothesis).
Page 1 of 2
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.