France goes into 3rd national lockdown

4,802 Views | 34 Replies | Last: 4 yr ago by BBQ4Me
PJYoung
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG


Really underscores how well we are doing here because of the aggressive rollout of the vaccines.
JR Ewingford
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bahaaa its comical now.
Wildmen06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I thought Europe was the model of how to handle the virus........
TexasAggie008
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Complete embarrassment
Aggie95
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
isn't it their 4th lockdown?
Please tell me there's a special place in Heaven for Aggie fans! It's like we are living some sort of penance on Earth.
CDub06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm sure this isn't something Macron wanted to do with the election hanging out there next year. But there's no doubt it's surging there when you look at the charts and hospitalizations.

France is having a really tough time with vaccination skeptics. Overall they've got at least 1 shot in about 12% of the population. (US is at about 29% of the population with 1 shot).

The complicating factor here is that the dominant strain there is more prevalent in kids. They're not getting vaccinated there (or anywhere). Kids aren't dying, but they're becoming a more viral vector for the susceptible population. The news about the kid vaccine trials was timely when you look at that.

Regardless, they just need to get shots in arms (as do we).

Man, how demoralizing that must be.
AgResearch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

closure of all schools and day care centres for three weeks
Insanity
NASAg03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
PJYoung said:



Really underscores how well we are doing here because of the aggressive rollout of the vaccines. the insanity of lockdowns because Florida has been open since September and saw no more significant changes in cases or deaths compared to other states.
FIFY.

Amazing their citizens keep sitting back and taking it, as if there wasn't enough global proof that lockdowns and masks do nothing but increase non-covid deaths, damage children, more-significantly push the burden on the working class, and pollute the earth.
General Omar
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Why do people continue to put up with this losckdown and mask insanity. In the history of our knowledge about respiratory viruses, we have ALWAYS known that you quarantine the sick, not the healthy and masks do NOTHING to prevent the spread of respiratory viruses. Where are the true scientists?
General Omar '79
Gordo14
How long do you want to ignore this user?
NASAg03 said:

PJYoung said:



Really underscores how well we are doing here because of the aggressive rollout of the vaccines. the insanity of lockdowns because Florida has been open since September and saw no more significant changes in cases or deaths compared to other states.
FIFY.

Amazing their citizens keep sitting back and taking it, as if there wasn't enough global proof that lockdowns and masks do nothing but increase non-covid deaths, damage children, more-significantly push the burden on the working class, and pollute the earth.


It's almost like France and Florida are entirely different places with an entirely different set of variables that affect viral transmission. I went to Florida last week. Most businesses had mask mandates. Many places have lots of outdoor space. Public transportation is non existant in Florida. Many people live in single family homes. Florida has much more moderate and temperate weather. But sure everyone everywhere should just blindly look at Florida. What you think Florida actually did is more like what Brazil actually did. Feel free to brag about how brilliant their "do nothing" attitude has been. I guarantee you Macron wouldn't implement measures to mitigate COVID if he didn't have to (healthcare overload). Vaccinations and population density are key reasons why we aren't still in COVID hell like France is.
DadHammer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Haha, no.
Post removed:
by user
Who?mikejones!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
It'll work this time
NASAg03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Gordo14 said:

NASAg03 said:

PJYoung said:



Really underscores how well we are doing here because of the aggressive rollout of the vaccines. the insanity of lockdowns because Florida has been open since September and saw no more significant changes in cases or deaths compared to other states.
FIFY.

Amazing their citizens keep sitting back and taking it, as if there wasn't enough global proof that lockdowns and masks do nothing but increase non-covid deaths, damage children, more-significantly push the burden on the working class, and pollute the earth.


It's almost like France and Florida are entirely different places with an entirely different set of variables that affect viral transmission. I went to Florida last week. Most businesses had mask mandates. Many places have lots of outdoor space. Public transportation is non existant in Florida. Many people live in single family homes. Florida has much more moderate and temperate weather. But sure everyone everywhere should just blindly look at Florida. What you think Florida actually did is more like what Brazil actually did. Feel free to brag about how brilliant their "do nothing" attitude has been. I guarantee you Macron wouldn't implement measures to mitigate COVID if he didn't have to (healthcare overload). Vaccinations and population density are key reasons why we aren't still in COVID hell like France is.


Now do Brazil vs Peru
TAMUallen
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Third time is a charm?!
fightingfarmer09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
General Omar said:

Why do people continue to put up with this losckdown and mask insanity. In the history of our knowledge about respiratory viruses, we have ALWAYS known that you quarantine the sick, not the healthy and masks do NOTHING to prevent the spread of respiratory viruses. Where are the true scientists?


Writing grants to get government funding for various projects that they frame to involve Covid. We saw this with green energy in agriculture 10 years ago. Encourage it so you can get funding for the whole department and then laugh about how your program is paid for with dumb grants.
Dad
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Gordo14 said:

NASAg03 said:

PJYoung said:



Really underscores how well we are doing here because of the aggressive rollout of the vaccines. the insanity of lockdowns because Florida has been open since September and saw no more significant changes in cases or deaths compared to other states.
FIFY.

Amazing their citizens keep sitting back and taking it, as if there wasn't enough global proof that lockdowns and masks do nothing but increase non-covid deaths, damage children, more-significantly push the burden on the working class, and pollute the earth.


It's almost like France and Florida are entirely different places with an entirely different set of variables that affect viral transmission. I went to Florida last week. Most businesses had mask mandates. Many places have lots of outdoor space. Public transportation is non existant in Florida. Many people live in single family homes. Florida has much more moderate and temperate weather. But sure everyone everywhere should just blindly look at Florida. What you think Florida actually did is more like what Brazil actually did. Feel free to brag about how brilliant their "do nothing" attitude has been. I guarantee you Macron wouldn't implement measures to mitigate COVID if he didn't have to (healthcare overload). Vaccinations and population density are key reasons why we aren't still in COVID hell like France is.

I spent some time in Orlando not too long ago and the place had masks everywhere... especially any place run by Disney but also the rest of the town.

I felt like the place I live in Texas is 100 times more free than Orlando. I don't know about the rest of Florida.
P.U.T.U
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
You do realize the USA has done the same protocol suggested by the CDC for the past 50 years and all the sudden went against it in 2020. A year later we have evidence that is was the wrong way to go, lockdowns don't work and mask show no evidence of stopping respiratory viruses. Especially the cloth mask everyone is wearing since once they become saturated with moisture, as in your breath, they don't filter.

PJYoung
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

Daily new infections in France have doubled since February to nearly 40,000. The number of Covid-19 patients in intensive care has breached 5,000, exceeding the peak hit during a six-week-long lockdown late last year.

Bed capacity in critical care units will be increased to 10,000, Macron said.
Capitol Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Gordo14 said:

NASAg03 said:

PJYoung said:



Really underscores how well we are doing here because of the aggressive rollout of the vaccines. the insanity of lockdowns because Florida has been open since September and saw no more significant changes in cases or deaths compared to other states.
FIFY.

Amazing their citizens keep sitting back and taking it, as if there wasn't enough global proof that lockdowns and masks do nothing but increase non-covid deaths, damage children, more-significantly push the burden on the working class, and pollute the earth.


It's almost like France and Florida are entirely different places with an entirely different set of variables that affect viral transmission. I went to Florida last week. Most businesses had mask mandates. Many places have lots of outdoor space. Public transportation is non existant in Florida. Many people live in single family homes. Florida has much more moderate and temperate weather. But sure everyone everywhere should just blindly look at Florida. What you think Florida actually did is more like what Brazil actually did. Feel free to brag about how brilliant their "do nothing" attitude has been. I guarantee you Macron wouldn't implement measures to mitigate COVID if he didn't have to (healthcare overload). Vaccinations and population density are key reasons why we aren't still in COVID hell like France is.
Sure, FL isn't France (that's a compliment to FL, amiright!?!? ) but there's definitely something very wrong in France if they "have" to shut down, given what we all know about the virus. I personally do not think shut downs should have happened now and feel there should be other options available to any country's leadership than shutting down. And shutting schools down. I think there obviously are different dynamics going on in Europe vs the US. But consider that there are many here that still want a full shut down here until there is no longer a case of Covid reported. It's those very dynamics that are causing all the issues over there.

NASAg03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
General Omar said:

Why do people continue to put up with this losckdown and mask insanity. In the history of our knowledge about respiratory viruses, we have ALWAYS known that you quarantine the sick, not the healthy and masks do NOTHING to prevent the spread of respiratory viruses. Where are the true scientists?
The true scientists wrote about this 15+ years ago with advice that we aren't following. One of the men on the team that wrote this paper lead the campaign to eradicate smallpox. Read the conclusion on page 372.

http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.552.1109&rep=rep1&type=pdf

What's crazy is some of the scientists that were included in this study have changed their views and advocate for closures. I wonder what's changed?
General Omar
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Political affiliations...not the science.
General Omar '79
TexasAggie008
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Macron vs Le Pen in 2022

https://www.reuters.com/article/health-coronavirus-france-macron/macrons-waterloo-french-president-comes-under-attack-for-lockdown-u-turn-idUSL8N2LU3UV

"Underlining Macron's vulnerability, a survey this month showed he would win a runoff against Le Pen by only a few points."

They'll get their chance to weigh in soon enough...if they effectively vote pro-lockdowns, theres no helping them...
erube
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Dad said:

Gordo14 said:

NASAg03 said:

PJYoung said:



Really underscores how well we are doing here because of the aggressive rollout of the vaccines. the insanity of lockdowns because Florida has been open since September and saw no more significant changes in cases or deaths compared to other states.
FIFY.

Amazing their citizens keep sitting back and taking it, as if there wasn't enough global proof that lockdowns and masks do nothing but increase non-covid deaths, damage children, more-significantly push the burden on the working class, and pollute the earth.


It's almost like France and Florida are entirely different places with an entirely different set of variables that affect viral transmission. I went to Florida last week. Most businesses had mask mandates. Many places have lots of outdoor space. Public transportation is non existant in Florida. Many people live in single family homes. Florida has much more moderate and temperate weather. But sure everyone everywhere should just blindly look at Florida. What you think Florida actually did is more like what Brazil actually did. Feel free to brag about how brilliant their "do nothing" attitude has been. I guarantee you Macron wouldn't implement measures to mitigate COVID if he didn't have to (healthcare overload). Vaccinations and population density are key reasons why we aren't still in COVID hell like France is.

I spent some time in Orlando not too long ago and the place had masks everywhere... especially any place run by Disney but also the rest of the town.

I felt like the place I live in Texas is 100 times more free than Orlando. I don't know about the rest of Florida.


At the Orange Bowl, they were super-vigilant about mask wearing, even though it is basically outside (open roof) and it was socially distanced seating. My buddy had let his slip down passed his nose and the users had him pull his up.

We saw lots of people wearing masks walking up and down the streets in Miami Beach, too.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Agthatbuilds said:

It'll work this time
Exactly. Lockdowns haven't been shown to work anywhere, but that won't stop the scientifically/statistically/economically illiterate from trying them again.

Quote:

Lockdowns cause a great deal of harm. We have infant mortality, creeping poverty, starvation and joblessness. There have been gut-wrenching denials of service. Failures to diagnose or even treat diseases which are far more impactful than coronavirus. We are now dealing with a horrible spectre especially among the youth of psychological disorders, with the incidents of self-harm, suicide [and] suicidal ideation expanding to levels that have never been seen before.

One and a half billion children had their educations effectively terminated or at least severely disrupted and that is even true for the few children of the wealthy who were able to attend classes online. Perhaps the hardest thing for me to swallow about all of this, is that in Undergraduate epidemiology, it is a well-known finding that when you are confronted with a disease with sharp age graduation as you are with coronavirus Measures to generally suppress the spread of the disease have the effect, reliably, of shifting the disease burden onto the vulnerable who we should be protecting. They worsen, are expected to worsen and do worsen coronavirus mortality.

The one thing we know they empirically do is harm the young/drive up suicide rates, but you do you, France.
BBQ4Me
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Or maybe these measures do help.
https://news.umich.edu/strict-public-health-measures-during-holidays-likely-saved-lives-in-michigan-u-m-researchers-say/
beerad12man
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Isn't Michigan doing the worst of anyone right now? Maybe 2nd to NY?

I don't think anyone denies that locking things down strictly can prevent cases, especially for a certain time period. But again, at what cost, and is it just merely kicking the can down the road? That's what these will never directly compare. What was the cost of saving 109 thousand cases? 5 billion dollars, 2 million jobs, loss of freedoms of choice, businesses, putting your life on hold for 18 months, etc?

Considering that the US likely has 25-40% of their population infected the last year, I'm not sure how worth it everything was. Maybe one could argue that we'd have had 60-70% without the measures? I don't really know. I highly doubt it.

What I do know is that many states clearly went overboard, as Texas seems to have functioned just fine with less restrictions than many others.
AgResearch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BBQ4Me said:

Or maybe these measures do help.
https://news.umich.edu/strict-public-health-measures-during-holidays-likely-saved-lives-in-michigan-u-m-researchers-say/
These lockdowns just delay case surges. See Michigan today:



Hopefully their old/vulnerable population is getting vaccinated.
BBQ4Me
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Michigan is doing poorly right now, but it can be argued that it's due to a loosening of mitigation efforts. Many of the cases are in a younger population, who don't seem to be taking precautions
DadHammer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The young aren't affected.

They may have worst governor or at least top three stupid.

Lockdowns don't work, period.
BBQ4Me
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
DadHammer said:

The young aren't affected.

Wrong

They may have worst governor or at least top three stupid.

Keep politics off the board.

Lockdowns don't work, period.


Brazil says hi
TexasAggie008
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
We've all had a personal list of people throughout the last year that we've worried most about (by TX's classifications - this generally means people in vax groups "1a" and "1b").

Fast forward to now and, at least in Texas, I think its safe to say that if you are in 1a or 1b and HAVENT gotten the vax yet - at minimum the first shot - then there's really no excuse (unless you're choosing to NOT get the vax aka you're on your own). For my own most-at-risk list, everyone has now been vax'd for at least a few weeks...including the family members who pretty much make 0 effort to be healthy or do annual checkups etc.

So that being the case...if a given "young person" no longer knows any high risk people who aren't either vax'd, or passing on it.....why SHOULDN'T they go on about business as if its 2019? There is no longer a lecture that can be given about #socialdistancing for grandma, or a guilt trip about how all of us have to do our part to make sure hospitals aren't overwhelmed by (primarily) 1a and 1b patients.
WoMD
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TexasAggie008 said:


There is no longer a lecture that can be given about #socialdistancing for grandma, or a guilt trip about how all of us have to do our part to make sure hospitals aren't overwhelmed by (primarily) 1a and 1b patients.


I wish that were the case. Bay Area sports networks (I use a vpn to watch giants games after bailing from SF last fall and moving to Idaho, thank god) are still showing the same commercials from a year ago about how you're a horrible person if you don't care about this because (showing video of old guy dying in hospital bed) YOU kill old people if you don't care. Yeah, it's still being shoved into the faces of the most compliant populations, and they are still going right along with it as if it's March of last year and nothings changed.

SF is in literally the same fear state as when I left, if not worse, because they have been told that everyone outside of California is evil and stupid and putting their lives at risk for daring to reopen. And a lot of that is by the media (sfchron.com is an embarrassment when it comes to this), not just the politicians, who are worshipped and followed unquestionably. I dread having to go back to get the rest of my stuff this month. My neighbors will be so incredibly pissed I will have guys in the building helping me move.
beerad12man
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
WoMD said:

TexasAggie008 said:


There is no longer a lecture that can be given about #socialdistancing for grandma, or a guilt trip about how all of us have to do our part to make sure hospitals aren't overwhelmed by (primarily) 1a and 1b patients.


I wish that were the case. Bay Area sports networks (I use a vpn to watch giants games after bailing from SF last fall and moving to Idaho, thank god) are still showing the same commercials from a year ago about how you're a horrible person if you don't care about this because (showing video of old guy dying in hospital bed) YOU kill old people if you don't care. Yeah, it's still being shoved into the faces of the most compliant populations, and they are still going right along with it as if it's March of last year and nothings changed.

SF is in literally the same fear state as when I left, if not worse, because they have been told that everyone outside of California is evil and stupid and putting their lives at risk for daring to reopen. And a lot of that is by the media (sfchron.com is an embarrassment when it comes to this), not just the politicians, who are worshipped and followed unquestionably. I dread having to go back to get the rest of my stuff this month. My neighbors will be so incredibly pissed I will have guys in the building helping me move.
It's insane, isn't it? A year of information into this, and some still haven't changed their narrative from a year ago.

I still see some very good friends and even family in other areas ofthe country that still have "Stay home, it could save lives" on their facebook profile pictures. Maybe they just haven't removed but if after a year, you don't understand how foolish this thought process is, and how the entire world can't just stay home for 13 months putting life on hold, I can't help you.

Texans really do think differently. At least those in my inner circle.
NASAg03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BBQ4Me said:

DadHammer said:

The young aren't affected.

Wrong

They may have worst governor or at least top three stupid.

Keep politics off the board.

Lockdowns don't work, period.


Brazil says hi
Peru says hi. They have some of the strictest lockdowns, more death / capita than Brazil, and their infection case curves look exactly alike.

But keep hoping lockdowns work and supporting your argument with a single piece of data...
Page 1 of 2
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.