Yeah I had to turn on subtitles for Blackthorne's accent. And Rodrigues.
Shogun 10-episode miniseries coming to FX
59,014 Views |
421 Replies |
Last: 2 mo ago by aTmAg
HummingbirdSaltalamacchia
Joined:
Jan 10, 2006
Posts:
10,900
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm sure I'll have more to add later, but damn, I'm loving this show. 3 episodes in (no re-watches yet, never saw the original nor read the book) and I'm getting a handle on most of the characters finally.
Don't know if it was mentioned earlier, but they do have an English dubbed version. Seems like, especially Taranaga and Yabushige, that it is the actors themselves, doing the dubbing.
My hard of hearing ass is used to reading subtitles anyway, so probably just as good hearing it in Japanese.
My hard of hearing ass is used to reading subtitles anyway, so probably just as good hearing it in Japanese.
The problem with that is they don't normally dub people who are already speaking English in scenes, which is what those people are having a hard time understanding hahaRick Dalton said:
Don't know if it was mentioned earlier, but they do have an English dubbed version. Seems like, especially Taranaga and Yabushige, that it is the actors themselves, doing the dubbing.
My hard of hearing ass is used to reading subtitles anyway, so probably just as good hearing it in Japaneses.
Like I say, I close caption anyway, so it's all good for me. Just throwing that option out there.
Tried it and didn't do much for me.
Just pissed I have to wait a week between episodes. Shoulda stayed away until it was run through and binge it.
Tried it and didn't do much for me.
Just pissed I have to wait a week between episodes. Shoulda stayed away until it was run through and binge it.
Meant this guy
I'm enjoying this.
I too would like to binge it, but oh well.
I too would like to binge it, but oh well.
Question:
Who was the young woman weeping who received the cremains of her baby and husband?
Who was the young woman weeping who received the cremains of her baby and husband?
OldArmy71 said:
Question:
Who was the young woman weeping who received the cremains of her baby and husband?
Hirumatsu's granddaughter. Wife of the samurai who spoke out of turn in ep 1 and shamed Toronaga, who committed sepukku to end his line, killing himself and his son. The wife - Fujiko - isn't allowed to kill herself with them, and badly wants to.
Thank you!
I tuned in bit over halfway through Ep. 1 and haven't watched all of it yet. That explains a lot.
OK, I watched Ep. 1. Thank you again.
I tuned in bit over halfway through Ep. 1 and haven't watched all of it yet. That explains a lot.
OK, I watched Ep. 1. Thank you again.
Had the idea that a game of thrones style intro to help geography and alliances would really be awesome.
Great series. Does the new episode hit tonight?
12:01am every Tuesday.aggierogue said:
Great series. Does the new episode hit tonight?
well.. that escalated quickly.
As someone who has read the novel 3 times and owns the original miniseries on disc (and watched it at least half a dozen times), I am enjoying this version. It is much more focused on the Japanese take of the events of the story rather than John Blackthorne's experiences. I don't think that's a bad thing. The best thing about the story has always been the cunning of Toranaga to avoid the traps and machinations of his enemies. As someone earlier mentioned, they have downplayed the sadistic/cruel nature of Yabu in this version. Father Martin also seems less menacing here but much remains to be seen.
They have done well in representing the novel so far. For those of you who think this is great, I highly encourage you to read the book. It is far greater than anything they can put on screen.
They have done well in representing the novel so far. For those of you who think this is great, I highly encourage you to read the book. It is far greater than anything they can put on screen.
Wow! That dialed up in a big way quickly!
So what was it that he ate that was like stinky cheese?
I'm assuming it was fermented tofu, aka stinky tofu.OldArmy71 said:
So what was it that he ate that was like stinky cheese?
Fermented soybeans
Thank you.
Soy seems pretty innocuous.
So why were they acting as if he was eating stewed brains or something gross?
Soy seems pretty innocuous.
So why were they acting as if he was eating stewed brains or something gross?
Quote:
Natto is often considered an acquired taste because of its powerful smell, strong flavor, and sticky, slimy texture
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natt
Man - I remember less of this book than I thought. I'm really resisting the urge to wiki and am just taking it one episode at a time. I know the history of the era (big-picture), but the story is different enough that it'll keep me on the edge of my seat.
Stinky tofu is fried so not the same 
"And liberals, being liberals, will double down on failure." - dedgod
I didn't finish the episode last night so the last 1/3 of the episode must have been really good! Can't wait to finish it tonight!Stive said:
Wow! That dialed up in a big way quickly!
"And liberals, being liberals, will double down on failure." - dedgod
Question about cannon accuracy:
Were cannons in 1600 as amazingly accurate as depicted in this episode?
Were cannons in 1600 as amazingly accurate as depicted in this episode?
OldArmy71 said:
Question about cannon accuracy:
Were cannons in 1600 as amazingly accurate as depicted in this episode?
Everyone was extremely skeptical about the cannons until they saw those suckers in action, so probably not!
I like the guy with the blown off legs and arm (still trying to figure out exactly how that would happen) just talking to them like no bid deal. That was some pretty bad CGI.
The lady that joined him in the bedroom that night was the translator right? He seemed to think so but she seemed to be playing dumb. Was that just for public show that she was putting on that act? Or something else that I missed?
Dark light. Couldn't tell if that was that little smoke show or not.
You could see her bangs in the dark. They matched the translator's and not Fuji (the one who lost her husband and child).LCE said:
Dark light. Couldn't tell if that was that little smoke show or not.
I thought it was something with semen or testicles in it judging from the reactions of the women.OldArmy71 said:
Thank you.
Soy seems pretty innocuous.
So why were they acting as if he was eating stewed brains or something gross?
The CGI was bad? It looked fine to me. Are you somehow familiar with what dismembered bodies look like?LB12Diamond said:
I like the guy with the blown off legs and arm (still trying to figure out exactly how that would happen) just talking to them like no bid deal. That was some pretty bad CGI.
And on how: he mentioned putting chain in the cannon. That certainly wasn't just a cannon ball.
You missed my biggest point. Him just talking to them after that happening like no big deal.
Sorry, but he would have been like what we saw in Saving Private Ryan on the beach. Screaming or in shock. Not just carrying on a conversation. That right there made the scene pretty bad.
Sorry, but he would have been like what we saw in Saving Private Ryan on the beach. Screaming or in shock. Not just carrying on a conversation. That right there made the scene pretty bad.
LB12Diamond said:
You missed my biggest point. Him just talking to them after that happening like no big deal.
Sorry, but he would have been like what we saw in Saving Private Ryan on the beach. Screaming or in shock. Not just caring on a conversation. That right there made the scene pretty bad.
You'd think they'd be screaming when they gutted themselves by committing seppuku, but they're always stoic. Strange that's not like Saving Private Ryan.
One of the many things I've learned on TexAgs over the years is that no one (other than themselves by implication) is capable of rendering CGI that is not bad.aTmAg said:The CGI was bad? It looked fine to me. Are you somehow familiar with what dismembered bodies look like?LB12Diamond said:
I like the guy with the blown off legs and arm (still trying to figure out exactly how that would happen) just talking to them like no bid deal. That was some pretty bad CGI.
And on how: he mentioned putting chain in the cannon. That certainly wasn't just a cannon ball.
That criticism comes at just about anything employing that visual effects technology.
Featured Stories
See All
21:36
1d ago
2.4k
No. 13 Aggies dispatch East Texas A&M in Friday's home opener, 87-55
by Olin Buchanan
54:36
1d ago
6.9k
47:49
1d ago
2.5k
5 Thoughts: No. 13 Texas A&M 87, East Texas A&M 55
by Luke Evangelist
99:23
1d ago
2.2k