Nevermind
Philo B 93 said:
I loved this when it came out on the "Encomium" Zeppelin covers album that we are all very familiar with. It made the song accessible to me on guitar and vocal.
Big Cat `93 said:
Underrated.
WestGalvestonAggie said:Big Cat `93 said:
Underrated.
Zebra is probably the most underrated band of all time and Randy Jackson is a GD genius.
He still does the Zeppelin symphony thing. You might get a chance to see it yet!maroon barchetta said:WestGalvestonAggie said:Big Cat `93 said:
Underrated.
Zebra is probably the most underrated band of all time and Randy Jackson is a GD genius.
This. Find their live performance in Houston in '83 at The Summit on YouTube. Randy nails everything live. He's incredible.
Houston Symphony did a thing a couple years back where they played Zeppelin songs and Randy sang all the Plant parts over those symphonic arrangements. I bet that was something to see.
It was awesome!maroon barchetta said:WestGalvestonAggie said:Big Cat `93 said:
Underrated.
Zebra is probably the most underrated band of all time and Randy Jackson is a GD genius.
This. Find their live performance in Houston in '83 at The Summit on YouTube. Randy nails everything live. He's incredible.
Houston Symphony did a thing a couple years back where they played Zeppelin songs and Randy sang all the Plant parts over those symphonic arrangements. I bet that was something to see.
maroon barchetta said:WestGalvestonAggie said:Big Cat `93 said:
Underrated.
Zebra is probably the most underrated band of all time and Randy Jackson is a GD genius.
This. Find their live performance in Houston in '83 at The Summit on YouTube. Randy nails everything live. He's incredible.
Houston Symphony did a thing a couple years back where they played Zeppelin songs and Randy sang all the Plant parts over those symphonic arrangements. I bet that was something to see.
birdman said:
Great White did a whole album of LZ covers.
Babe, I'm Gonna Leave You was the best.
Zep had ripped off the original songwriter.
Yellerjacket said:
No Quarter cover by Tool is amazing.
Quote:
It is jaw droppingly good. I'm a Tool fan but not a Tool nutjob. My favorite band ever is Rush but I think the greatest band ever was LZ (90% of their catalog is gold) and prior to this I thought most LZ covers were hot garbage. There have been a few decent ones but not something I would listen to again and again. This is 11+ minutes of greatness.
No Quarter was a LZ masterpiece too - it was the centerpiece of live shows from 1973 onward. You wanna hear greatness listen to the Celebration Day 2007 Live version by LZ.
To even have the audacity to tackle this is ballsy. Get it wrong and it's a flop of embarrassing proportions and you took up 11+ minutes of an album for it.
Covers tend to fall into one of 3 different types:
1. Tributes to the original that sound much like the original band and version.
2. A cover that just sounds like the band covering it, but doing that song.
3. A different rendition based on tempo, genre, style, instruments, etc. A complete departure that redefines the song.
1 and 2 generally add very little other than serving as an homage to the original. They both can be very good but in the end they are adding little. 3 sometimes works very well and can be very welcome (Alien Ant Farm doing Smooth Criminal, Disturbed doing Sound of Silence, Social Distortion doing a punk cover of Ring of Fire).
This cover is all three of those things in different parts - which is possible partly because it is so long.
0:00 - 4:00 It starts out as very much a LZ homage in tempo, tone, etc. but the excellent musicianship comes through.
4:01 - 5:12 interlude
5:13 - 9:54 In the second section it morphs into more of a Tool sound as it continues to build in intensity.
9:55 - 11:26 The third section is a cacophony of sound as it is a taken to a new frenetic level and a powerful ending.
It just delivers beginning to end.
Claude! said:
Not terribly surprised that nobody has mentioned (at least as far as I could see from a quick skim of the thread) Dolly Parton's cover of Stairway.
It's probably more due to the fact that everybody loves the American treasure that is Dolly Parton. Though in fairness, several of her songs charted more broadly than the country charts - "Here You Come Again" and "9 to 5" were both top 3. She's also apparently putting out a rock album (looks like mostly covers) later this year.Rocagnante said:Claude! said:
Not terribly surprised that nobody has mentioned (at least as far as I could see from a quick skim of the thread) Dolly Parton's cover of Stairway.
Is this what got her into the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame?