List A or List B.

Based on overall talent. Top 10 vs top 10. These two list were thrown together, and yes, I'm sure your list is much, much better. Just vote base on what's posted please

A. Tom Hanks,Tom Cruise, Harrison Ford, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Will Smith, Michael Keeton, Christian Pratt, Christian Bale, Johnny Depp, Robert Downey Jr

B. Robert Downey Jr, Leonardo Dicaprio, George Clooney, Denzel Washington, Robert De Niro, Harrison Ford, Morgan Freeman, Tom Hanks, Liam Neeson, Gerard Butler

Since there are duplicates, are we essentially comparing…

1. Tom Cruise, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Will Smith, Michael Keeton, Christian Pratt, Christian Bale, Johnny Depp

2. Leonardo Dicaprio, George Clooney, Denzel Washington, Robert De Niro, Morgan Freeman, Liam Neeson, Gerard Butler

?

In that case I'll say give me list 2… I think.

20ag07 said:

---

Weird debate that needs settling.

---

This started when an actors name was mentioned that I thought was an all-time great, and the other person wouldn't even have them in their top 10.

So we made our list (quickly)

nvm

List A are actors of movies that I would probably enjoy more today.

List B is easily the best as far as acting talent is concerned. And that's with Gerard butler, whom I feel like is a more appropriate add to list 1

HummingbirdSaltalamacchia said:

---

List A are actors of movies that I would probably enjoy more today.

List B is easily the best as far as acting talent is concerned. And that's with Gerard butler, whom I feel like is a more appropriate add to list 1

---

This is the correct answer. Entertainment value A, talent B.

If i'm summing up the actiing prowess of the lists, then List 2 would win.

But, like others have said, if you are saying I could never watch movies from actors on List 1 or List 2, ever again? I'm taking List 1 as my list of more entertaining movies.

The debate began with "I hate Tom Cruise"

He's on my list. I think he's very talented and love his movies. The other person refuses to watch his movies

20ag07 said:

---

Sorry you and your buddy are bored or whatever on a Saturday evening.

But you just asked us to help you win your debate about Tom Cruise

By giving us "top 10" lists that included Arnold Schwarzenegger and Gerard Butler.

So maybe you both should just spend the evening watching better movies.

---

Everything is going to be OK, I promise

Aggie Class of 2026 said:

---

20ag07 said:

---

Sorry you and your buddy are bored or whatever on a Saturday evening.

But you just asked us to help you win your debate about Tom Cruise

By giving us "top 10" lists that included Arnold Schwarzenegger and Gerard Butler.

So maybe you both should just spend the evening watching better movies.

---

Everything is going to be OK, I promise

---

Like anybody could even know that, Napoleon.

You would have to pay me to watch a Tom Cruise movie, so list B is an easy choice.

powerbelly said:

---

You would have to pay me to watch a Tom Cruise movie, so list B is an easy choice.

---

Because he's a terrible human being or his movies are horrible?

Aggie Class of 2026 said:

---

powerbelly said:

---

You would have to pay me to watch a Tom Cruise movie, so list B is an easy choice.

---

Because he's a terrible human being or his movies are horrible?

---

Terrible human. I couldnt tell you about any of his movies after Jerry Maguire

Aggie Class of 2026 said:

---

Al Bula said:

---

Yeah those lists are garbage that you and your buddy should feel bad about. Not playing, but Option C for me:

1. Daniel Day-Lewis
2. Joaquin Phoenix
3. Philip Seymour Hoffman
4. Gary Oldman
5. Anthony Hopkins
6. Bryan Cranston
7. Edward Norton
8. Christoph Waltz
9. Javier Bardem
10. Viggo Mortensen

---

To be fair I think your list is hot garbage but you already know that

---

Says the person that has Pratt and Depp in their top 10.

I'm going with Option A because that one has Cruise, Keaton, and Bale.

Who the hell is Christian Pratt?

The Porkchop Express said:

---

Who the hell is Christian Pratt?

---

He's Batman

Both lists suck and ran out of steam pretty quick. Gerard Butler? "Christian" Pratt? Lol ok bud

Depends on the kind of movie we're making.

I'll take B

No Robert Duvall?

aggiesherpa said:

---

No Robert Duvall?

---

I think you mean Rudolf Duvall

Aggie Class of 2026 said:

---

20ag07 said:

---

Weird debate that needs settling.

---

This started when an actors name was mentioned that I thought was an all-time great, and the other person wouldn't even have them in their top 10.

So we made our list (quickly)

---

I take it when you mean "All-Time", you mean "All-Time" like ESPN does, so basically the last 25-40 years.