Entertainment
Sponsored by

*** Monster: The Ed Gein Story ***

1,470 Views | 8 Replies | Last: 2 mo ago by swimmerbabe11
Ryan the Temp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This is the next installment of Ryan Murphy's series on murderers after the Jeffrey Dahmer and Menendez brothers series. The 8-episode series tells the story of famed murderer and grave robber Ed Gein, played by Charlie Hunnam of Sons of Anarchy fame.



I was interested in seeing this because I had read about Ed Gein in the past and I generally love watching anything true crime-related. Gein is somewhat well-known, but definitely not a household name like Dahmer, Menendez, Bundy, Manson, etc. Nonetheless, Ed Gein was the inspiration for Psycho and aspects of his crimes influenced Texas Chainsaw Massacre and Silence of the Lambs.

So far I'm only four episodes in and Murphy has taken a different approach with multiple different storylines that take place in different times. There is a storyline about Alfred Hitchcock making Psycho interwoven with Ed Gein's story that later gives way to the making of Texas Chainsaw Massacre. I assume Silence of the Lambs will end up in there at some point.

One thing I think is interesting about this series, and not really in a good way, is that Murphy takes much more liberty about creating certain events or aspects of Gein's life and particularly the inclusion of events and other things that started as rumors after Gein was arrested and were later debunked. For example, Gein's relationship with Adeline Walker was wholly fabricated by Walker, and when pressed about her claims by authorities, she recanted. There is also no evidence Gein had anything to do with his brother's death. I also know that later, in an episode I have not watched yet, Gein apparently works with the FBI to help catch Ted Bundy. The FBI issued a statement saying this did not happen.

True to form, Murphy also had to slip some gay stuff into the series by including a storyline about Anthony Perkins' relationship with Tab Hunter and alleged struggles with homosexuality. Murphy includes scenes and claims of Perkins routinely vomiting after sex. This was a one-off claim made in a book about Perkins, and was widely derided as a flagrant lie by people who knew Perkins, including people he was known to have had intimate relations with.

The series is entertaining, for sure, but it seems much more broadly fictional than Dahmer or Menendez. I think it helps to know a little about Gein and the timeline of his crimes before starting the series so you know where you are chronologically in his story. The first four episodes are presented as if it is a relatively short period of time, when in reality these four episodes span more than 13 years of Gein's life.
Lola68
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Have you read Kingdom of Cain by Andrew Klavan?
Ryan the Temp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Lola68 said:

Have you read Kingdom of Cain by Andrew Klavan?

No.
Lola68
How long do you want to ignore this user?
It talks about how this case (and a couple of others) inspired those films. Also talks about Cain and Abel, and Leopold and Loeb cases and their influence on culture, etc.
VP at Pierce and Pierce
How long do you want to ignore this user?
A heavily fictionalized story about some whacko from the sticks in Wisconsin during the depression, no thanks.
Diggity
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The preview with the dark version of the Pet Shop Boys classic was fantastic
RightWingConspirator
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
A lot of liberties taken as far as the Ilsa Koch and the Adeline parts of the story, but it's interesting and weird.
Ryan the Temp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
RightWingConspirator said:

A lot of liberties taken as far as the Ilsa Koch and the Adeline parts of the story, but it's interesting and weird.

I finished it last night. I thought it was interesting how it presented the storyline of things that did not happen as ultimately being delusions in Gein's mind in a way that allowed the viewer to experience the effect of Gein's schizophrenia by not knowing what was real and what wasn't.It allows hindsight to explain some things in earlier episodes, like when Adeline is killed in the shower a la Psycho and Gein is confused when he sees her alive. I think it does a good job of helping the viewer understand how his mind functioned.

The last episode was almost entirely fiction with him assisting the FBI on the Ted Bundy case. As I mentioned before, the FBI actually put out a statement refuting this, but I can't help but wonder if it was a furthering of the schizophrenic effect used for his conversations with Ilsa Koch and Christine Jorgensen.

The one thing I really disliked about the end of the series was how the end of his life was presented in a way that sort of romanticized him and excused all the horrible things he did. It was like Murphy wanted viewers to be sympathetic toward Gein.

The next series will be about Lizzie Borden, so I expect that to be even more fictionalized than this was.
swimmerbabe11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

The next series will be about Lizzie Borden, so I expect that to be even more fictionalized than this was.


it almost has to be, because so little was known/could be proven about her story. Borden is a fascinating case.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.