Bad interview stories

1,414 Views | 15 Replies | Last: 11 hrs ago by AgLA06
Cromagnum
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Its always a crapshoot whether an interview really goes well or not. I have had about a 50/50 on feeling good or bad afterwards and whether that feeling matched whether I went to the next phase.

Had a 2nd round yesterday and it was a video call. I was expected to dress professionally and have all my AV stuff sorted out. Interviewer gets on and refuses to turn his own camera on. Brief intro of himself, but zero personality, and a thick Indian accent that was difficult to understand. Had to ask a few times to repeat because I had no idea wtf he just said. Dryly goes through his lines of questions to me which were all technical. Response to each of my answers was a simple "ok", and then deadpans each subsequent one. At least gave me time to ask serious questions at the end to force him to actually speak.

He didnt stump me on anything, but I felt zero human connection. He may as well have been an AI bot. Guess we'll see which side of the 50/50 this one falls.
beerag04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The video interview part reminds me of a pretty bad one. Had a final interview with the general counsel of a large company after several rounds of interviews. Video interview and he is several minutes late. He gets on and turns on his camera, but on my end I can hear him but the video is buffering. He apologizes for being late and asks me how I'm doing. To which I respond, just waiting on you to show up here, meaning on the video. He takes that as me being mad he was late and explains he was at an executive board meeting and could not just walk out for this interview. Didn't get any better from there.
superunknown
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Had one that still pisses me off to this day....it was an internal interview so it's not like I needed the job to pay bills, etc but it was a good promotional position to move towards. Since it was internal, I got a lot of feedback on the interview after being rejected.

The biggest complaint?

I talked about myself too much.

Can anyone tell me who tf I'm supposed to talk about during my job interview?
rilloaggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Posted this years ago but still haven't had an experience top this:

I replied to a posting from Texags for a sales role several years back. I did a phone interview with the person that posted it, and that went great. Did an in-person interview with the VP, sales manager, and a senior member of the sales team, and that went great. Came back to do a personality assessment test and that went well. The company then asks me to do a skype interview with a 3rd party consultant they work with to wrap the process up.

Don't recall what day of the week it was but the skype interview was set for 2:00PM. I was still working full time during this with another employer that had me spending lots of time in the field in the middle of the summer. I get home for the interview around 12:30 and my phone rings at almost 1:00, the number is a Chicago area code, same area code as the consultant. Having just come in from the heat, I am dirty, sweaty, and wearing a baseball cap, but I go ahead and answer. We proceed to have a normal conversation for about 45 mins and as we are wrapping up the consultant asks something along the line of "do you always wear baseball caps for interviews?" I respond that I was under the impression the interview wasn't until 2 but decided to go ahead and answer and that I thought it showed my ability to be flexible and put the needs of the customer first, yada yada. I sent a follow up email to thank the dude for his time, no response.

2-3 days go by, and I get a call from the VP I had previously interview with and he has the consultant on the line with him. Tenor of the conversation is completely different than the earlier interviews. What had been casual feeling and fun conversations in the past were now much more formal and tense feeling. In an earlier interview the VP said that a successful sales person should be making 6 figures with the company easily but in this conversation that salary range was met with incredulity when I answered that I thought I could make that. Towards the end of the call the consultant brings up the baseball cap again. I again explain that his call was an hour earlier than scheduled but in the back of my mind I was already feeling like this guy was weirdly fixated on a freaking hat. Didn't get the job, thank goodness lol! I have seen that company post several times since then and even seen a post from an employee looking elsewhere and unhappy with the company. Never been happier to have a baseball cap derail a promising interview lol
Beckdiesel03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Bad interviews weed out bad companies for you. That's been my experience.
500,000ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Interviewed with BofA out of A&M for their IB Group. This lady was a VP in the Oil & Gas coverage team (complete smoke show, but that's not really relevant) and she asks me the best example of a cyclical industry that I can think of. I tell her oil and energy because it's demand-dependent on the economy, supply cannot match demand changes, activity and outlook of the swing line producer, and a few other things. She said I don't really see oil and energy as cyclical because it's always needed. I said you should tell that to oilfield services. She got really annoyed and eventually we sat in silence for a good 3-4 minutes. Found out later she was negging candidates to see how they responded when a senior person was dominant or wrong. Guess they weren't looking for sarcasm.
Cromagnum
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I hate all the games so many interviewers play. Just find out if the candidate can do the damned job or not and if they would mesh with the team.
Hoyt Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Earlier in the year, I had my first new grad bring his mom to an interview. Like, into the building with him.

Had another parent send me a scathing FB message for not hiring their daughter. That was a first.
Cromagnum
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Hoyt Ag said:

Earlier in the year, I had my first new grad bring his mom to an interview. Like, into the building with him.

Had another parent send me a scathing FB message for not hiring their daughter. That was a first.


Wow.
Texag5324
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I interviewed with Amazon one time and it was horrible. The first initial call went well, then the second interview made me want to hang up mid call lol. The guy was just throwing complex rapid fire behavioral/situational based interview questions at me, then everytime I would answer in depth he would say condescendingly "thats all?" or "anything else?" It felt like he was purposely trying to trip me up. Just got a bad vibe from him and turned me away from working for Amazon. I typically do well in behavioral based question interviews but Amazon was on another level.

Another time I interviewed with a famous asian fast food chain for a corporate office position. The recruiter just kept trying to over sell me on their work culture, like everything she responded with was just about their culture. It almost felt like a cult. Of course, anytime a company tries to over sell you on their culture that usually means they dont pay well, and that was exactly the case here.

They also wanted me to visit one of their fast food restaurants, observe the culture, report back, then fly to California to meet with the founder. It was like 4-5 rounds of interviews, it just all seemed like way too much for a middle manager level role for a fast food chain that wasnt paying much. I told the interviewer politely that I will remove myself from consideration because it wasnt a good fit, and she ignored that and kept trying to sell me on their culture lol. I finally had to be like hey sorry I gotta go and I wish you the best filling this role. It was just a very strange interview.
Beckdiesel03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
SAWS was one of the worst I had. It was 8 men mostly Hispanic and it was for an outreach position. It was the most race baiting sexist interview. This coming from someone that has a Hispanic name and has always been in construction. My very next job I got had a coworker come over from SAWS. We brought her a cake and sang her Happy Birthday. She cried. She said in 25 years at SAWS they had never done that for her. Second worst was a drywall manufacturer. They asked me what I did for fun and I said we go to the coast and fish. It was also a panel of men and then they asked what kind of fish we fished for. I'm like what do you think we fish for? It was like they were trying to catch me in a lie. They are now out of business.
The Chicken Ranch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I was asked once about their perceived 'my lack of accounting knowledge.' I said. "I have a MBA and 20 hours of accounting coursework. Plus I ran a business for 8 years." They replied, "But you didn't specifically list it on your resume." I said, "I thought a working knowledge of accounting was implied with a MBA and my work experience."
AgLA06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Hoyt Ag said:

Earlier in the year, I had my first new grad bring his mom to an interview. Like, into the building with him.


I don't care who their ride is as long as they wait in the lobby like anyone else. They try to insert themselves into the interview and that's a different story.

AgLA06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm leading a group of small companies, but growth has stalled and ownership appears to be looking to wind things down. They aren't spring chickens.

About a year ago I got a referral from a friend and end up networking with ownership of a different company. Lunches and conversations go well over 6-9 months and they reach out asking if I would be interested in taking a similar role for them supporting the current President who is now overwhelmed as the company has grown.

Conversations go well, role and comp are figured out, and they ask me to meet with the President one last time as a courtesy. It goes horribly.

From the second he walks in it is obvious he doesn't want any help and he's overwhelmed on purpose so he can micro manage things instead of mentor, train, and delegate. He's a complete ass. Best is he offers a role more apt for early career in supply chain and tells me my main job will be in another state opening a new facility so I wouldn't be in the corporate office around him.

I noped out of there quickly. He and ownership were going to have a war and I wasn't going to be the pawn in the middle. 2 months later multiple people call and tell me the President has been let go and the company has been in chaos since I interviewed. Ownership is bringing in a new President I had never heard a single word about.

Major bullet dodged.
swimmerbabe11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I recently had a request for references from the hiring manager, I provided them, a week later I get an email from the HR recruiter asking for references (as though I had never provided them) but stipulating that it could only be managers, and one was required from my current employer.

You want me to ask my current boss for a referral while I'm still working for them? no?
AgLA06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
"I only provide management references upon request after a discussion with HR management "

You either no longer have to worry about getting fired from your current job because you dodged a bad situation before on-boarding or the ignorant HR rep has the dumb request sorted by her boss who explains why when she tells them why you want to talk.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.