Outdoors
Sponsored by

Any opinions on the Girsan Browning Hi-Power clones?

1,863 Views | 20 Replies | Last: 1 mo ago by shiftyandquick
shiftyandquick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I came across this gun for $339 + shipping + FFL (no tax).

Cerakote, 1 mag.

I have always wanted a Browning hi-power. Hard to beat this price. A friend of mine says Inglis brand (also Turkish) is probably better than Girsan.

This does have the magazine disconnect safety, but it can be fairly easily removed.

https://gunprime.com/products/eaa-girsan-mcp35-9mm-fde-15-round-capacity-hi-power-390460
BenderRodriguez
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
No experience with the Inglis/Hi power clones, but I do have a fair amount of rounds through Turkish 1911 Tisas clones and MKE MP5 clones.

The turks make decent functioning clones. Fit and finish are not as nice (obviously) as the guns they are reproducing, but their price has much more to do with Lira vs the Dollar than it does with quality, IMO.

If you want a shooter to tinker with, I think its a solid buy.
shiftyandquick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Thanks Bender. Unrelated question: What do you think of the Beretta 92xi SAO with the stainless slide? What do you recommend if one can only buy one version of Beretta 92?
Alte Schule
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Thanks OP I just ordered one. The total with shipping was $359 no tax. Comes with only one mag but EAA has them for $40.
BenderRodriguez
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
shiftyandquick said:

Thanks Bender. Unrelated question: What do you think of the Beretta 92xi SAO with the stainless slide? What do you recommend if one can only buy one version of Beretta 92?


I think the 92xi is a pretty gun.

It would limit what divisions you could shoot competitions with if that matters to you, being SAO.

I went with a M9A4 as my only beretta. Threaded barrel, G model decocker only, milled for red dot plates.

I'd also be tempted by a Langdon LTT build if i was going to buy one beretta. They build nice ones. Their red dot guns use a couple proprietary parts to get the dot lower on the slide than the milled beretta factory guns, if that matters to you one way or the other.
maverick2076
How long do you want to ignore this user?
shiftyandquick said:

Thanks Bender. Unrelated question: What do you think of the Beretta 92xi SAO with the stainless slide? What do you recommend if one can only buy one version of Beretta 92?


https://gunzonedeals.com/product/ber-92xi-full-size-9mm-18rd-blk?utm_campaign=Beretta_92XI_SAO_And_92G_LTT_Dedicated_Email_10152025&utm_content=touchpoint_1_side_by_side_daily_send_template_2&utm_medium=email&utm_source=zaius

Looks like there's an additional $75 rebate or $150 beretta store credit right now. Seems like a good price
shiftyandquick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
maverick2076 said:

shiftyandquick said:

Thanks Bender. Unrelated question: What do you think of the Beretta 92xi SAO with the stainless slide? What do you recommend if one can only buy one version of Beretta 92?


https://gunzonedeals.com/product/ber-92xi-full-size-9mm-18rd-blk?utm_campaign=Beretta_92XI_SAO_And_92G_LTT_Dedicated_Email_10152025&utm_content=touchpoint_1_side_by_side_daily_send_template_2&utm_medium=email&utm_source=zaius

Looks like there's an additional $75 rebate or $150 beretta store credit right now. Seems like a good price

yeah, that is what I was looking at.
zooguy96
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BenderRodriguez said:

shiftyandquick said:

Thanks Bender. Unrelated question: What do you think of the Beretta 92xi SAO with the stainless slide? What do you recommend if one can only buy one version of Beretta 92?


I think the 92xi is a pretty gun.

It would limit what divisions you could shoot competitions with if that matters to you, being SAO.

I went with a M9A4 as my only beretta. Threaded barrel, G model decocker only, milled for red dot plates.

I'd also be tempted by a Langdon LTT build if i was going to buy one beretta. They build nice ones. Their red dot guns use a couple proprietary parts to get the dot lower on the slide than the milled beretta factory guns, if that matters to you one way or the other.


The Langdon Tactical builds are suweet! My BIL let me shoot his - really nice trigger and holographic red dot. I'd get one if my finances allowed me right now.
I know a lot about a little, and a little about a lot.
TheEyeGuy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The Girsan hi powers are absolutely good to go. If you get a standard one, look up how to remove the mag catch safety.

Complete night and day.

If you really want someone impressive, do that, upgrade the springs and do some polishing.

$40 in parts plus a bit of elbow grease and... Things get real nice
Owner of Texian Firearms:
Dealer in Firearms, Optics, Night Vision and other shooting accessories.
US importer/distributor of Rudolph Optics
Supporting bad financial decisions since 2015
shiftyandquick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I shot the Girsan hi power clone (MC P35) and the Beretta 92xi. And also shot the Glock 19 (gen 4) for the first time.

I had one malfunction among the 3 guns. The Beretta. Not sure what happened. Maybe a failed strike, or maybe the hammer didn't go back or something. I wasn't paying close enough attention. It was not a FTF jam.

I actually liked the Glock 19 the best. Maybe because I am used to the glock trigger and glock sites. It was the most accurate for me. Just right on the button accurate shooting from the start all the way to the finish.

I found that the Girsan was the least accurate for me. When I started to pay much closer attention to the trigger and how I was manipulating it, the inaccuracy went away. This gun has the heaviest trigger of the 3 (the magazine safety is still in place). The Girsan I think would benefit from some additional checkering on the front strap and back strap (where it has none).

The Beretta was fine. Maybe with the least recoil. But it didn't blow my socks off or anything. I did catch my palm once in the magazine well when loading, which was not a good feeling.

I'm very much not an expert shooter. So these are just the impressions of such.
Smeghead4761
How long do you want to ignore this user?
shiftyandquick said:

I came across this gun for $339 + shipping + FFL (no tax).

Cerakote, 1 mag.

I have always wanted a Browning hi-power. Hard to beat this price. A friend of mine says Inglis brand (also Turkish) is probably better than Girsan.

This does have the magazine disconnect safety, but it can be fairly easily removed.

https://gunprime.com/products/eaa-girsan-mcp35-9mm-fde-15-round-capacity-hi-power-390460

I'm a bit confused - I Inglis Hi-Powers were made in Canada during WWII. (For reference, see here.)

Did some Turkish company buy the name?
shiftyandquick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Smeghead4761 said:

shiftyandquick said:

I came across this gun for $339 + shipping + FFL (no tax).

Cerakote, 1 mag.

I have always wanted a Browning hi-power. Hard to beat this price. A friend of mine says Inglis brand (also Turkish) is probably better than Girsan.

This does have the magazine disconnect safety, but it can be fairly easily removed.

https://gunprime.com/products/eaa-girsan-mcp35-9mm-fde-15-round-capacity-hi-power-390460

I'm a bit confused - I Inglis Hi-Powers were made in Canada during WWII. (For reference, see here.)

Did some Turkish company buy the name?

SDS owns the Inglis brand. And my understanding is that all their guns are Turkish imports.
Nacho97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Springfield Armory SA-35 is a hi-power knockoff, and it looks really nice
shiftyandquick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Nacho97 said:

Springfield Armory SA-35 is a hi-power knockoff, and it looks really nice

but much more expensive than the Turkish clones.
Gunny456
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I say if you like it and want it, go buy it and have fun with it. However if you are planning on someday passing on your firearms to your kids I have always gone by the auspices to go ahead and spend the money on the real thing or get a firearm of quality brand name that should increase in value in the future for your kids.
shiftyandquick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Gunny456 said:

I say if you like it and want it, go buy it and have fun with it. However if you are planning on someday passing on your firearms to your kids I have always gone by the auspices to go ahead and spend the money on the real thing or get a firearm of quality brand name that should increase in value in the future for your kids.

This brings up a topic that has been on my mind recently. I kind of took something like a 6 year break, not thinking much about firearms or buying any new ones.

So just recently diving in and taking a look again. Regarding pistols, I am struck by 1) how there are many more quality options than there used to be, i.e. great features, great reliability. 2) How cheap some of those options are now. It is now WAY cheaper to buy a quality pistol now than 25 years ago. The Keltec-types of 2025 actually work well.

You can buy a good functioning 1911 for $300 now (Turkish). There are many striker-fired pistol sub $400 that work very well.

Remember when Glock seemed to be the only reliable pistol? And then S&W M&P came in as the 2nd option? Now there MANY, MANY options of equal reliability.

So I think the idea of "just brand-named" guns has been turned on its head. What is brand name now? Is Canik "brand-name"?

How about Walther PPK? Yes, it is brand name. Yet we had several people talking here in a recent thread about how the guns aren't reliable.

The gun space is rapidly evolving. In the 1980s, the tooling was way different. Modern methods of manufacture have made things much more precise and reproduceable.

Who is to say how much a Girsan PC 35 is going to be worth in 20 years. Do I care? No. I just wanted a reliable Browning Hi-power to try, because of my interest in John Moses Browning and owning and using a small piece of history.
shiftyandquick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wrong thread
Gunny456
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I get what you're saying. Valid points.
There are more manufacturers now because the initial cost of tooling and production is much less due simpler actions made of stamped steel, polymer and alloy frames and slides.
With the increase in popularity of carry weapons and handguns the demand has given birth to more manufacturers which has increased the amount of competition in the market place leading to cheaper prices and cheaper made guns.
As I said in my original post…..it's your money, buy what you like and want…and above all have fun with it.
I had just gave an opinion that for a long term investment or heirloom you perhaps can save your pennies and get the real deal.
In a quick search I found this one. Not a bad deal.

https://www.gunsinternational.com/guns-for-sale-online/pistols/browning-pistols---hi-power/browning-hi-power-in-9mm.cfm?gun_id=103368360

What you really need to do is get both!
shiftyandquick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
No I don't. I don't need both.
Aggie Infantry
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I ordered on yesterday. Will follow up with my results.
When the truth comes out, do not ask me how I knew.
Ask yourself why you did not.
shiftyandquick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Aggie Infantry said:

I ordered on yesterday. Will follow up with my results.

Nice. Looking forward to it. I'm trying to decide on whether I should remove the magazine safety or not now.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.