Had slap tears, plus minor rotator cuff issues, and other long term shoulder issues in both shoulders at the same time.
Concentrated on the right first, I'm a righty. Went the PT route, also had steroid shot, and 1 round of PRP injection. Choose not to get surgery, so that I could continue working (outdoor based job) and really didn't have the time to be out of commission. PT helped, especially once work let me off from the more strenuous work. Started bowling within a year of the diagnosis, was pretty much good the last couple years until this Jan when I aggravated it (now dealing with frozen shoulder).
When I started concentrating on the left shoulder doing PT, I wasn't truly happy with the PT doc. Because during the first go around I was already doing exercises that worked both sides (band work and other exercises), and the 2nd doc wanted me doing light weights (which I demonstrated I could do either heavier or a carp ton of lw reps).
Go with quality PT first and then let you and the ortho doc determine if surgery is truly needed. I'm sure I'll finally get the surgery sometime in the future and I'll be out of commission for awhile due to putting it off.
TAMUG'04 Marine Fisheries.