YouBet said:
I get your points and I'm not discouraging going to the gym or lifting weights at all; I just think you can still accomplish much without doing those two specific exercises. That's all.
At 52, I'm not looking to be a body builder, but I still grow muscle doing a variety of other things. So, I'm just saying that goals will change and a shift in certain exercises may be necessary. Barbell squats and weighted deadlifts are just too much risk. FTR, I still do some dumbbell squats in form of Goblets and sometimes regular dumbbell squats with lighter weight.
Once my shoulders started giving me fits and I had back surgery then it became stupid for me to do those two exercises plus pushing weight overhead with shoulders. I still do shoulder work but it's always in a plane that is shoulder height or lower.
For me, mobility and functional strength are way more important at this point than getting swole and I think you will find most experts agree with me once you get into your 50s.
Let's revisit what "getting swole" is really all about. It's not lifting for strength. Its about volume and approaches to failure in rep ranges around 5-30 reps...
100% agree with your top point. And 52 as well. Now, bear in mind, that bodybuilders (competitive or recreational) don't always do conventional squats or deadlifts. Most I know don't. Bodybuilding is about muscle growth, not strength. When one is focused on aesthetics when they train, they are bodybuilders, especially in terms of how one programs their training. Remember, load alone isn't the main catalyst for growth. It is the approach to failure that is the best signal for muscle growth in rep ranges 5-30 reps. I haven't done a conventional squat or dead in 2-3 years. Not for risk. There really wouldn't be much more risk for me. Instead I don't b/c there are plenty of other exercises to reach my goal without the associated high levels of fatigue that conventional squats and dead lifts create. As I said, volume and approaches to failure are the most important necessities to grow muscle (along with sleep and recovery). I train in mesocyles that are 6-10 weeks long with 5 or 6 days a week to train. So I try to limit fatigue as much as possible. The load on the spine (axial load) is VERY fatiguing. And the amount of weight and back load the dead lift creates is as well. When one wants to maximize growth, these aren't really the best vehicles to grow the target muscles relative to the fatigue cost. Let's take the dead lift. When you think about a dead, the force curve isn't great for maximizing back growth. You're literally on the ground where the back would be lengthened the most. And the concentric portion is limited greatly as well. It will grow back muscles, but not at the rate that deficit barbell rows can. Or even better, a seated row where the spine is taken out of the equation. If one really wants to grow their back, pullups, pull-downs, rows and face pulls are better alternatives and a lot less fatiguing. And deads are terrible for growing legs. minimal "squat" portion at best ending with straight legs. Not much leg growth. Squats are great at growing quads and glutes. They are fantastic in this regard. But there are exercises that are just as good. Try a belt squat for instance. Yes, a lot less risk for injury, yes. But to me the biggest benefit is the lower fatigue cost. You are not loading the spine. And the handles allow one to more easily keep their squat upright and for incredible depth safely. Split squat variations with dumbbells or on a machine are amazing as well. Lunges with BW or DBs. We have an Atlantis Hack Squat at my gym. Maybe the best machine for legs ever. Leg press, especially the Arsenal Leg Press (some leg presses hurt my back-but Arsenal is great!), which somehow gives me no back pain even when I have my legs at there lowest point on the platform. So lots of great options...
For shoulders, I really do not program overhead shoulder press. Occasionally I will. But instead I rely on my chest presses for front delt work. I mainly focus on mid delt work like lateral raises, incorporating cables with cuffs. I also do a lot of rear delt work (not face pulls here) with an emphasis on lengthening the rear delt. Also use cables here but will do single arm rear delt flys on the fly machine. IF i do have a front delt exercise like an over head press, I do it last in my shoulder training to emphasize the side delt first. What many do not realize is that if you want bigger shoulders, the best way to get those is doing exercises to grow the lateral (side) and posterior (rear) delts. On these, emphasize the lengthened portion (bottom of the lateral raise), not the shortened portion (the top of a lateral raise). This can be done fantastically with cables. My favorite exercise here is lying cable crossovers using cuffs on a bench.
So in an interesting way, actual bodybuilding is a safe and effective way to train, grow the most muscle and enhance longevity. So it is OK to try to get swole.