Who?mikejones! said:
Then their rankings are stupid and this entire thing is ****ingn stupid and needs to be ended
They're awful rankings but they're the rankings. And all of the dumb things they've done actually "make sense" when you understand they are using flawed methodology.
My only point has been we should amplify and criticize the methodology rather than throwing our hands up and screaming this makes no sense.
Bartoo and crew are analytics guys and they take a very hands off approach when reporting the committee numbers. I think that's wrong and they should be using their platform to criticize the committee methodology. They know full well it's a dumb way to calculate SOS.
But ... they have an analytics business and they're to the point now where ADs are paying them to provide insights on things like coaching searches. So they aren't going to make a stink because committee members are potential clients.