Onana is capable of shockers too frequently to be considered elite. Even Allison has some shockers because so much more is asked of goalies now than even 10 years ago and they play so frequently within 10 yards of their own goal. They are less frequent which is where the value lies.
We overpaid for him for sure. I mean, that's what we do. But calling him not a shot stopper after some of the saves he has consistently pulled off is just...myopic. He was 5th last season and is 2nd this season in expected goals saves. Which means he's either a shot stopper or has been extremely lucky for the last 60 EPL games. Can't take any opinion seriously that routinely completely ignores or discounts statistics like that.
None of that means he hasn't cost us games or that he is worth what we paid for him. It just means he isn't as nearly as useless or incompetent as people tend to point out.
We overpaid for him for sure. I mean, that's what we do. But calling him not a shot stopper after some of the saves he has consistently pulled off is just...myopic. He was 5th last season and is 2nd this season in expected goals saves. Which means he's either a shot stopper or has been extremely lucky for the last 60 EPL games. Can't take any opinion seriously that routinely completely ignores or discounts statistics like that.
None of that means he hasn't cost us games or that he is worth what we paid for him. It just means he isn't as nearly as useless or incompetent as people tend to point out.