quote:
Ultimately you can say that about every star to win a title.
Would Tim win #1 without David? Or 2-3 without TP or Manu?
Tim might have won #2 with any competent supporting cast. That was before TP and Manu were stars. In the playoffs, Duncan averaged more PPG than both of them combined (24.7 to 24.1), almost as many assists (5.3 to 6.1) and threw in 15.4 rebounds and 3.3 blocks. He put up an ORtg of 116 and a DRtg of 92 over the course of that playoffs.
Here are the stats by category, showing #1 and #2 for the Spurs over that playoffs
Duncan 24.7 ppg
Parker 14.7
Duncan 15.4 rpg
Robinson 6.6
Duncan 5.3 apg
Parker 3.5
Duncan 3.3 bpg
Robinson 1.3
I'm not really a Bryant scholar, so I don't know if he has anything similar on his resume. Just pointing out that there are (very rare) occasions where one player carries a team to a title. I don't think a player should be judged for not pulling that off, but at the same time Kobe should probably get a healthy asterisk for the Shaq championships.
[This message has been edited by Ulrich (edited 3/14/2014 10:07a).]