The Silverback said:
I own an Independent Agency and wanted to chime in here:
Regarding the umbrella, with virtually every company you must maintain liability limits of 250/500 or higher to be eligible. So having state min limits won't allow you to even get an umbrella.
Rates are going to continue to rise, for everyone. I recently attended a round table that Progressive hosted and I saw the stats for the top 15 major auto insurers and its not pretty. Virtually all of them have combined ratios of 100-125%. Meaning they are operating at a loss. Geico has taken over 40% rate over the last 3 years. most others are in the 20's%. Progressive has been ahead of the curve for rate increases but most others are going to see SIGNFICANT increases in the next 12 months.
When the pandemic hit everyone had rate decreases (which was part of the problem) and then things sky rocketed from there with inflation, more people driving, expensive vehicles with more technology, increasing costs of defense, etc. etc.
Also, comparing rates from one person to the next is essentially useless. Credit, driving record, zip code, applicable discounts, continuous coverage history, vehicle type, liability limits, deductibles, demographics.....the list goes on and on about what goes into rates. I have some people who have full coverage and pay $900 year for 2 vehicles and others who pay $900/month.
I don't know about everyone else, but I didn't get any significant rate decreases in 2020 or 2021. My homeowner's went up $50 (2.5%) from 2020 to 2021 and stayed flat in 2022. I am getting nervous about 2023 (it renews in Feb).
Auto didn't go down, either. I did add my son in 2020, but my share of the premium didn't go down, either. I had actually seen a bit of a decrease in that earlier this year (I assumed because with every passing year my son doesn't get a ticket or have an accident, I get a tiny break) but my October premium went up about $80 (5%). I also added an umbrella policy when I added him, so that was an extra expense. Considering what others here have been saying, I consider myself lucky.
I've tried shopping around, but I've been with State Farm since my early 20s (spun off from my parents' account) and I've never been able to beat both car and auto. Usually one quote would come back high and the other low, so it always ended up being a wash. And I got tired of spending the time to get quotes and getting the residual spam emails and phone calls.