Student Loan/house remodel advice

15,999 Views | 140 Replies | Last: 16 hrs ago by harrierdoc
Corps_Ag12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Here's a way to make your kitchen feel new without spending too much money:

  • Update floor tile
  • Update cabinet doors & drawer faces
  • Paint Cabinets
  • Add guides to drawers & replace cabinet door hinges
  • Do not replace cabinet boxes
  • Replace countertops
  • New, midrange appliances

Granted, you're going to have to be the one to find each of these guys so you don't have to pay a premium for a GC.

Do your own demo on the floors. You can rent a floor scraper from Home Depot/Lowe's/Sunbelt.

Get a Bagster from Lowe's & fill it up with everything you don't want, including flooring, old cabinet doors (keep drawers to be re-faced), etc.

A countertop company will probably remove & replace your countertops in one trip if you're not re-arranging anything.
Deputy Travis Junior
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Honestly OP your big mistake was not refinancing them a year and a half ago when rates were nothing. You could be paying 2.5% on them instead of 6.4% in which case this is an entirely different conversation. But you gambled on getting free **** and lost.
Charismatic Megafauna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AustinCountyAg said:

rononeill said:

What's the value of the home?


Home has increased over $100k in appraisals over past three years.

If your 50k cash is above and beyond your safety cushion, pay cash for the remodel, keep paying whatever you already are for student loans, then when rates get more reasonable refi the house and pay off the student loans
Also frigidaire gallery fridge and dw, zline oven/range/hood. Anything more is wasting money, asking for trouble, and/or showing off
AustinCountyAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Deputy Travis Junior said:

Honestly OP your big mistake was not refinancing them a year and a half ago when rates were nothing. You could be paying 2.5% on them instead of 6.4% in which case this is an entirely different conversation. But you gambled on getting free **** and lost.
interest rate have been frozen at zero percent since 2020
htxag09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AustinCountyAg said:

Deputy Travis Junior said:

Honestly OP your big mistake was not refinancing them a year and a half ago when rates were nothing. You could be paying 2.5% on them instead of 6.4% in which case this is an entirely different conversation. But you gambled on getting free **** and lost.
interest rate have been frozen at zero percent since 2020
Yet you paid $0....so now your interest rate is 6.4%....
Deputy Travis Junior
How long do you want to ignore this user?
A couple last comments before I duck out of this thread: first, you said your wife got bad financial advice and that's why she has so much student loan debt. Well now she wants to blow all the free cash that your set aside to pay off her high interest loans on a lavish kitchen remodel ($50k means zero compromise, top notch everywhere). This suggests she didn't learn anything from her loan decisions and is still very bad with money.

Second, i can't say what surprise financial hit its in store for you, but something always happens. An unexpected pregnancy, a car dies, the idiot in-laws who gave her bad advice run out of money and need you to pay for their groceries for the foreseeable future, a kid develops an auto immune disease that requires $200 of uncovered medicine a month, whatever. So that's why a compromise ie spend half the money on loans and half the money on a less fancy upgrade is a good idea. You get to live and do something nice for yourselves but it also improves your ability to handle the curve balls that life will undoubtedly throw at you.
DannyDuberstein
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This right here. This kind of kitchen can be modernized and look great for so much less. 100% change in look and functionality
Charismatic Megafauna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
50k for a zero compromises kitchen lol. A wolf dual fuel range costs 12k and a sub zero fridge is 15. That's 27k and you haven't even started demo yet

Edit: you can probably get 0% on those for a couple years though...not sure you can with zline
Deputy Travis Junior
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AustinCountyAg said:

Deputy Travis Junior said:

Honestly OP your big mistake was not refinancing them a year and a half ago when rates were nothing. You could be paying 2.5% on them instead of 6.4% in which case this is an entirely different conversation. But you gambled on getting free **** and lost.
interest rate have been frozen at zero percent since 2020


Okay? The point is that you didn't take advantage of the market when you had a chance because your were enjoying the $0/month payment and you didn't want to start shelling out cash again. Unfortunately that had a cost. I did a quick Calc in excel and if you'd refinanced last January at 2.5 or 2.6% on a 20 year 50k loan, you'd be paying $260 a month instead of $360 and most of your monthlies would be going to principal.
Charismatic Megafauna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
500,000ags said:



Part of me thinks the OP should talk to a realtor and see how his home value changes. If the ROI isn't actually negative 50%, but something more reasonable, I think that takes the stink off a decision like this.

Another angle to this is that if you have to move, a home with a nicely remodeled kitchen is 10x easier to move than one with avocado appliances and cabinet doors that won't shut. The pool of buyers in the second category is much smaller and they are the ones you don't want to be negotiating with when you sell. So you are going to end up paying for the remodel on the back end, instead of when you will get to enjoy it (it took me 11 years in 2 houses to come to this conclusion)
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
You can really really update on a budget. You can find matching appliances on Facebook marketplace if you try hard enough. You can probably put shaker doors on those cabinets and drawers for less than a grand, plus paint. You can DIY butcher block counters for less than a grand as well, and they are pretty awesome. Honestly, you should be able to update your whole home for 50 grand if you so some yourself. If you redo your kitchen to the 9s, I promise it won't stop there because then the rest of the house won't be up to those same standards.
harrierdoc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
My biggest concern in his response, and this really shows how both he and she think about personal responsibility, is that he's ok with letting the government - meaning my tax dollars - pay for his wife's debts for her education. I assumed as much earlier in the thread, but did not want to voice those assumptions, and wanted to give them the benefit of the doubt and uncertainty. But, with him admitting that they didn't pay ANYTHING on the debt when it was not mandatory, and now they want to spend it on something else for their own benefit, yet uncaring about the rest of us paying for their poor choices, that says a lot about where they are coming from.
Again, as I said previously, this is what is wrong with America today.
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I do understand what you're saying but if the govt is stupid enough to pay them then he would be an absolute moron for not taking advantage of the "free" government idiocy. Its not like this dudes decision to pay or not to pay had any bearing whatsoever on what happens in Washington or not.
one MEEN Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AustinAg,

Here's the long and short of it. Paying off a debt early helps your finances in two ways. You lock in the interest rate of the note as a gain. Can you beat 6ish percent in the stock market? And if you can, it only matters if you actually invest it instead of just blowing it on something else.

Also, you're going to free up $300 a month for the foreseeable future. That is going to really help you once you start getting real expenses with kids.

Your best option is to invest the 50k and thats only really marginally the best. Your second best option (really your best) is to pay off the loans. Your third best option is to pay down the loans by half and DIY the remodel. Your worst option is to drop 50k to have some general contractor do everything for you.

What really hurts you is just not paying your loans down when they were 0%. If this pot of money you saved it up is partially due to student loan relief- you owe it to yourself to at least put that amount of cash back into the loans.
rme
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
harrierdoc said:

My biggest concern in his response, and this really shows how both he and she think about personal responsibility, is that he's ok with letting the government - meaning my tax dollars - pay for his wife's debts for her education. I assumed as much earlier in the thread, but did not want to voice those assumptions, and wanted to give them the benefit of the doubt and uncertainty. But, with him admitting that they didn't pay ANYTHING on the debt when it was not mandatory, and now they want to spend it on something else for their own benefit, yet uncaring about the rest of us paying for their poor choices, that says a lot about where they are coming from.
Again, as I said previously, this is what is wrong with America today.
we stopped paying but moved the same payment amount to savings since the payment pause. Yes it's interest free. Our thought was to wait in case Biden decided to do some type of forgiveness, and if not just paying off the loans completely before the interest kicked back in. Now with the large sum we've saved we are thinking doing the kitchen remodel instead of paying off the loans.



I don't see how you jump to the personal responsibility comment. It is not unreasonable to stop payments when no interest was accruing. They even chose not to spend the "payment" money. This is a reasonable and responsible approach. Would you hurry to pay off a student loan knowing there was a chance some would be forgiven? I didn't like the Biden plan, but would do the same thing to maintain options. Seems no different than waiting to make a decision until a pending tax change is decided.
harrierdoc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yes, I would do everything in my power to personally make whole what debts I owed.

I made a decision to join the military so I wouldn't go into debt for my education. I took on the responsibility for my decisions. Many of my peers completed training 3 - 6 years earlier than I did, and realized that economic benefit. I don't think one way is better than the other, as long as the decision made is made purely on the idea that, no matter what choice is made, the decision maker is responsible for their choice, not someone else because I changed my mind and want a fancy, upgraded kitchen/car/vacation, etc…
rme
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I have no doubt, but you know that wasn't the question.
harrierdoc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Then, what was the question? Seems to me they are still hoping for some possible loan forgiveness in the future. Otherwise, why wouldn't you pay off the debt now, so as not to increase payback amt? Each $ saved in interest could be used to purchase an upgraded kitchen in the not too distant future. It seems that it didn't take them long to save the $50,000, so another 2 years in the current kitchen doesn't seem too unreasonable.
rme
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
That's reasonable. The question was about accepting a free option to see if debt was reduced by the government. I didn't see any intent by OP or his wife to not pay their obligations.

Keeper of The Spirits
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
i've always paid the minimum on my student loans assuming that one day they'd get forgiven, i think it's safe to say they will get forgiven at some point assuming you don't out earn the forgiveness level. the idea is wildly popular outside of the older right

you can't sell your diploma and they aren't going to repossess it. l
harrierdoc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sure, it's wildly popular by the people that aren't going to pay for it now. Unfortunately, the young don't have the benefit of experience and don't see what problems lie in their future.

Boortz had a great idea. If you accept $$$ from the government directly, you can't vote. Those that take will always vote for leaders that will keep giving and never vote for those that will take away for the betterment of the country.
Keeper of The Spirits
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
i'm not saying it's right or wrong, just that's it's going to happen. just like the tax credits you get for having kids too many people benefit
directly and more of those people are created with every loan given.

sorry for the derail, but my point is pay the student loans last atleast for the next year or four, if attitudes change about forgiveness then maybe start paying but it feels like a foregone conclusion at this point either through another EO or act of Congress
AustinCountyAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
harrierdoc said:

Then, what was the question? Seems to me they are still hoping for some possible loan forgiveness in the future. Otherwise, why wouldn't you pay off the debt now, so as not to increase payback amt? Each $ saved in interest could be used to purchase an upgraded kitchen in the not too distant future. It seems that it didn't take them long to save the $50,000, so another 2 years in the current kitchen doesn't seem too unreasonable.


We are not "hoping" for anything. The govt paused payments and froze the rates so we aren't accruing any extra fees. We've been taking our monthly payments and stashing them in savings in case Biden was stupid enough to forgive them. We can always lump sum a payment at 0% before they kick the rates back in.

500,000ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Harrierdoc, frankly speaking, your opinion is irrelevant and annoyingly political.

The government, especially during Covid, gave material handouts to corporates, small business owners, the unemployed, and people with children. I come from a small town and online can see Republican after Republican taking all those PPP loans and getting every single one of them forgiven. Take that personally responsibility argument to every single one of those parties if you are going to crap all over OP and this thread.
CC09LawAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
This is such a ridiculous and tired argument.

You bet people took PPP loans when the government shut down their businesses and they had bills to pay. And before you say there was a ton of fraud, well guess who ran it and allowed the fraud?

The government.

It's such a ridiculous apples to oranges comparison that it is quite frankly embarrassing that anyone would make it.
500,000ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
And people with student loans didn't have their jobs impacted at all?
CC09LawAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
That has zero to do with why they took the loan out initially.

But you already knew that.
500,000ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
How can you say people that own a business and people that work for the same businesses are not both impacted by the government? That's some mental gymnastics.
CC09LawAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
You're conflating personal responsibility in taking out PPP loans and their repayment with taking out student loans and their subsequent repayments.

It's two completely different things. Don't try to act like the student loan forgiveness movement is at all grounded in Covid.

ETA: But you did get a dig in at those mean old Republican neighbors you have, so good job!
500,000ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I am not conflating a single thing. Stimulus is stimulus.

PPP loans = stimulus
Student loans pause = stimulus
Child tax credits = stimulus
Unemployment = stimulus
Sub-3% rates = stimulus

There is one that gets people all fired up right now, and it's no coincidence why a certain few are botching about it and making this thread political.
Chipotlemonger
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
30k millionaires post about being a sucker was part in jest but also part truth. One might be a sucker to fully pay off student loans while their very existence is in limbo for multiple years, only to have them come around and forgive a chunk of it. Maybe you could get an IOU from Uncle Sam on the most recently paid loans in that scenario. Not sure! But also completely unlikely.

The PPP deal is the PPP deal. People working the system. If we expect the rich and famous or more well off people to use the system to their potential advantage, then turn around and scold people for not paying for a couple years on a loan that could have been partially or fully wiped out for them (depending on the amount), then that is very hypocritical. Objectively, financially, when I believe $10k-$20k forgiveness was floated, if someone paid off a student loan of that same or lesser amount then they are not making the right choice.
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
$30,000 Millionaire said:

There are people in this thread that would tell you to live in a trailer and eat ramen until you paid off all of your debt, and then you could begin to live.

As long as you're not deficit spending and you're saving sufficiently for retirement, do what you want.

Life is about a lot more than just net worth.
how is he saving for retirement when he still has $50K in student loans and wants to spend another $50K on a kitchen?!!?
htxag09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
500,000ags said:

And people with student loans didn't have their jobs impacted at all?

Unemployment has been near record lows for the last 2ish years….
reineraggie09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Why wait for payments to restart? Pay now before interest starts. I've been hammering for 3 years saving that interest money.
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
He mentioned he could pay lump sum if the interest is going to start again. As far as course of action goes, he probably took the smartest route. Save your payments in a separate account while there no interest and no payments due in the event the are forgiven. Can throw all that at the loan if payments and interest are announced to start up again.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.