Real Estate
Sponsored by

For those of you that bought a vacation/second home, was it worth it?

14,877 Views | 91 Replies | Last: 1 mo ago by James Forsyth
EclipseAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yesterday said:

Our kids actually think the house we rent on LBJ in Kingsland is ours since we've gone to it so many times.
Before we bought our home in Galveston, we used to rent the same beach house every year (kids were little).

The owners eventually sold to full-time residents and so we had to find a new house. That next year, we drove past the old house and there were kids playing in the front yard. My youngest yelled out, all concerned, " Hey, someone's at our beach house!"

RoyVal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
RoyVal said:

This post has been a great read (and very good timing).

My wife and I are empty nesters now (mostly except when my daughter comes home from college) and we've been south of Houston in the clear lake area (aka the burbs) ever since I graduated from college. I never got to to live "in town" but my wife and I enjoy the hell out of going into Houston to try restaurants and check out new bars and drive around and look at real estate (I've had my real estate license for 25 years even though I don't do real estate for a living), etc.

I'm trying like hell to decide between moving to a new home with an open floor plan (our current house is 3000 square feet, but not open floor plan at all so it feels small) or just buying a a condo in town and keeping our home. We've put in $150k in upgrades/upkeep over the last 20 years so we have it mostly the way we want it, plus I only owe 5-6 more years on it.....at a 2.5% interest rate so I'm in no hurry to pay it off.

Hearing all you guys talk about the enjoyment of a 2nd home REALLY has be considering pulling the trigger on a town home I've looked at 3-4 times very close to downtown Houston, close to a lot of things we enjoy and just keeping my current home! Driving into town has just become such a pain in the ass with traffic...I think we'd do even MORE in town if we had a town home.

We originally thought about making a town home a weekend getaway PLUS part time Airbnb, but some of your posts confirmed some of my thoughts about the hassle and stress of doing both...so thanks for sharing your thoughts.
and just like that....we had our offer accepted in the fastest turn around in history....and I low balled him! Damn TexAgs made me buy a town house LOL!
HumpitPuryear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Have a little lake cabin that we love. Bought it years ago when values and taxes were low. Then the VRBO investors came and then the tax man came. Now it costs us $10k annually for taxes alone. Consider the vacations you can have for $10k every year not counting insurance and maintenance. We are going to sell soon and buy property out of state. Which will likely be our retirement place. It's great that the value of the property went up so much but we are basically being taxed off the property which sucks. Texas needs property tax reform but that's another subject. You should be aware that your tax situation can change dramatically in Texas.
RoyVal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
HumpitPuryear said:

Have a little lake cabin that we love. Bought it years ago when values and taxes were low. Then the VRBO investors came and then the tax man came. Now it costs us $10k annually for taxes alone. Consider the vacations you can have for $10k every year not counting insurance and maintenance. We are going to sell soon and buy property out of state. Which will likely be our retirement place. It's great that the value of the property went up so much but we are basically being taxed off the property which sucks. Texas needs property tax reform but that's another subject. You should be aware that your tax situation can change dramatically in Texas.
death and taxes man......amazing how many GREAT properties I've seen over the years that I just couldn't pull the trigger on because of taxes....
MAS444
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The property taxes helped seal the deal for us with a place in Colorado. Our effective tax rate is a small fraction of what it is in Texas.
Yesterday
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ag exemption and an RV.
f burg ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Arky has a fairly low rate (13th lowest state)...which was one of many reasons we liked buying there.
docb
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I have a couple of different getaways between our home in Steamboat Springs and our house at our ranch. I have to say I have thoroughly enjoyed both. I certainly do not think I would want a third one as it would just be too much to deal with for us.
HumpitPuryear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yesterday said:

Ag exemption and an RV.
Yep, this is the one tax loophole left in Texas property taxes that will save you tons of money vs a "vacation home".
Waiting on a Natty
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Tex117 said:

cjsag94 said:


I think proximity to home is a huge factor. Anything over 2 hours away, I just don't think will get the use -
This. It really needs to be 2 hours away or less.

Otherwise, its just too much of a production to use it.
Amen to this.
cgh1999
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Waiting on a Natty said:

Tex117 said:

cjsag94 said:


I think proximity to home is a huge factor. Anything over 2 hours away, I just don't think will get the use -
This. It really needs to be 2 hours away or less.

Otherwise, it's just too much of a production to use it.
Amen to this.

I'd argue 90 minutes. Our place is 2 hours and EVERY time we hit the 90 minute mark the whole family starts to complain about it being too far. Nevermind I've been driving and they're all streaming Netflix or sleeping.
Waiting on a Natty
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
cgh1999 said:

Waiting on a Natty said:

Tex117 said:

cjsag94 said:


I think proximity to home is a huge factor. Anything over 2 hours away, I just don't think will get the use -
This. It really needs to be 2 hours away or less.

Otherwise, it's just too much of a production to use it.
Amen to this.

I'd argue 90 minutes. Our place is 2 hours and EVERY time we hit the 90 minute mark the whole family starts to complain about it being too far. Nevermind I've been driving and they're all streaming Netflix or sleeping.
Our second house is in College Station. So its use is different from what the OP is speaking of. Because traffic has gotten so bad (too damn many people live in TX now) it takes us at a minimum 3 hrs. 15 minutes to get there.

We are retired and have season tickets to FB, basketball and baseball. That trip, which we are making in just a few minutes, is a beating. Especially for the number of times we have made it. A good Aggie friend of mine who lived out of state for years told me about the 2 hour rule. Since I have never had a second house for relaxing purposes I can't 100% say it works. But 3 hours is WAY too much.
Yesterday
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm sure there is a good reason, but why not live in College Station?
Waiting on a Natty
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yesterday said:

I'm sure there is a good reason, but why not live in College Station?


Presently an easy answer. We are caring for my 96 year old FIL in San Antonio. When he passes we will move.

Tough question for us is "To where?"

I'm a small town guy, we met at A&M and we really enjoy the communities of B/CS. But our interest in Aggie athletics is waning. We both hate the humidity and Aggieland is getting pretty crowded. On the flip side, we have lots of friends in Aggieland and kids and grandkids in Katy.

Three Aggie couples who we have known for 40+ years are recruiting us to move to Granbury. Wife and I are thinking about a new adventure in the 4th quarter of our lives, living in an area of Texas that is new to us.
Plus, we love Granbury AND Ft. Worth. Plus the cost of living is substantially lower in that part of Texas.

First world problems and we are blessed to have these two options.
maroonpivo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Where is your place in Steamboat? In-laws is in Clark and I wish it were closer to town in the winter months.
docb
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Steamboat Blvd between town and the ski area
stallion6
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TheWoodlandsTxAg said:

I am considering it.

I am not asking if it was worth it from an investment standpoint because it obviously was considering the price of every property in the country has doubled over the last couple of years.

I am asking if the vacation home or second property was worth it from the stand point of personal enjoyment.

Do you feel the personal joy and enjoyment was worth the money you spent on the vacation/second home?
Yes for my family situation. Bought second home in Bryan, allows me to visit family in the area and Aggie sports. I come in town about every 3 weeks and it is just like taking a short vacation. However, I did buy before the interest rates increased. Will most likely be my retirement home some day.
tamc93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
We kept a house that our daughter used in BCS as a game day house for us. The cost of it basically offset hotel bills and allows us to attend multiple functions.

We have looked at other "island spots', but do not want to be tied to one location yet or be hassled with doing chores when we want to relax. At the same time, we know several people who have done well with the air bnb concept.
busdriver88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG

When our son started at TAMU, fish in the Corps, and we purchased season football tickets, I found that after making the 6.5 hour drive from Lubbock just to stay in an overpriced uncomfortable hotel room was sucking the pleasure out of each visit. We started kicking around the idea of a place, and found a realtor from TexAgs to help us find one. Bill Robbins helped us find a condo and we bought it back when interest rates were low. Plus, as you CT's know, that first year on the quad is rough, and we could tell our son needed a place to get the hell off the quad. He used it that second semester with his buddies as a place to get away from the "character development" on the quad. To be honest, having this spot (and they took great care of it) resulted in him having a set of buddies that will be his guys for life.

Got it paid off in less than a year, and we have throughly enjoyed having our own space when we come to town now. I love not having to pack a bunch of stuff before I hit the road to CSTAT. And having your own space is fantastic. Makes the drive from Lubbock so much easier.

My son is graduated, and we plan on keeping it. It will be only 3.5 hours away when we move to the coast in a couple of years. We do not rent it out as we want it available for us or friends if they need it.

Financially, not sure the numbers make sense until we sell the place, which may be never. But we have loved it. We don't go to the lake, or the mountains enough to make those make any sense. But we are in CSTAT a lot. If you are thinking about it, get it. It is only money, and you can always sell it.
There may not be time to do the job right, but there is always time to do the job over!!
swampstander
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm going to reiterate what a lot of people have said here. In 2015 I inherited half of my family's beach home in NH. I was able to do some real estate swapping and ended up with the entire thing. I was ecstatic. After spending $4000 to get rid of a squatter in 2017, we had to redo the entire place. New floors, paint, cabinets, counter tops, appliances, furniture etc... We settled in to our summer place spending June-August traveling back and forth from East Texas by car. I wanted what I had as a kid... a place where the whole family can get together and enjoy the beach. That happened exactly once. My son who has recently opened a new business lives in Tyler with his family. Daughter and her family live in So. California (at the beach). We are retired but coordinating everyone's vacation time, grandkids sports etc is a challenge. We are in the house right now getting it ready to sell. For the most part I am just tired of worrying about it and working on it. Did the recent storm blow shingles off? Are the pipes going to freeze when its minus 5 degrees? Every time we get here something is broken. Last summer it was the washing machine, this time the flag pole blew over and the basement toilet waste pump didn't work (fortunately I had a spare). We are growing weary of the four day drive back and forth every year and we feel trapped in some respects. There are other places we would like to visit but feel like we have to come here. We have noticed that our summer trips up keep getting shorter and shorter and its to the point that it just does not make any sense to keep it any longer for what we are paying in taxes and insurance. We are not abandoning the New Hampshire Seacoast because we love it. We can rent a place up here for a month for what I am paying in taxes and I don't have to worry about upkeep and insurance and we can fly up and rent a car while we are here.
swampstander

cgh1999
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The joys of a second home - my brother in law called me this week to let me know that part of my roof was missing and the decking was soaked through and leaking into my house.
I called a contractor who went to look at it and he noticed more damage. So, I get to drive up and meet with an insurance adjuster to hopefully get it replaced/repaired.
cgh1999
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Met with insurance adjuster today. They're basically only willing to cover a minor repair and not replacement of the roof which is what i really should do. So - i can either eat the $15k cost or just patch it and go with that.

Also met with a realtor today to see what the market is doing. The number I was given for a patient (3-6 month) sale is almost right on what I thought the value would be. That's good...but it doesn't help sway me any direction in the sell/keep decision. If it was 10% higher...sell today. 10% lower...hold on longer. Bigger value would override any emotional attachment.
Boiling Denim
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HumpitPuryear said:

Have a little lake cabin that we love. Bought it years ago when values and taxes were low. Then the VRBO investors came and then the tax man came. Now it costs us $10k annually for taxes alone. Consider the vacations you can have for $10k every year not counting insurance and maintenance. We are going to sell soon and buy property out of state. Which will likely be our retirement place. It's great that the value of the property went up so much but we are basically being taxed off the property which sucks. Texas needs property tax reform but that's another subject. You should be aware that your tax situation can change dramatically in Texas.
Had this exact conversation with my neighbor who purchased a Galveston bayhouse many years ago. Their taxes hit $12K last year which is double their current home's. They went maybe 10 times all year with their 2 elementary school kids. And that's just an hour drive

Once she started thinking of it in this taxes = vacation budget mindset she's over it. It also probably doesn't help when we talk to her about all the different places we go on vacation every year lol

They'll get the last laugh when they sell it and get a nice pile of cash to play with...if they sell. Kinda hard when that value keeps going up. Until then they'll just have to live vicariously through us as we sip mai tais on a beach in Maui
MAS444
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
10 times is some pretty decent use to me.
swampstander
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
swampstander said:

I'm going to reiterate what a lot of people have said here. In 2015 I inherited half of my family's beach home in NH. I was able to do some real estate swapping and ended up with the entire thing. I was ecstatic. After spending $4000 to get rid of a squatter in 2017, we had to redo the entire place. New floors, paint, cabinets, counter tops, appliances, furniture etc... We settled in to our summer place spending June-August traveling back and forth from East Texas by car. I wanted what I had as a kid... a place where the whole family can get together and enjoy the beach. That happened exactly once. My son who has recently opened a new business lives in Tyler with his family. Daughter and her family live in So. California (at the beach). We are retired but coordinating everyone's vacation time, grandkids sports etc is a challenge. We are in the house right now getting it ready to sell. For the most part I am just tired of worrying about it and working on it. Did the recent storm blow shingles off? Are the pipes going to freeze when its minus 5 degrees? Every time we get here something is broken. Last summer it was the washing machine, this time the flag pole blew over and the basement toilet waste pump didn't work (fortunately I had a spare). We are growing weary of the four day drive back and forth every year and we feel trapped in some respects. There are other places we would like to visit but feel like we have to come here. We have noticed that our summer trips up keep getting shorter and shorter and its to the point that it just does not make any sense to keep it any longer for what we are paying in taxes and insurance. We are not abandoning the New Hampshire Seacoast because we love it. We can rent a place up here for a month for what I am paying in taxes and I don't have to worry about upkeep and insurance and we can fly up and rent a car while we are here.
Our Beach House just went live if anyone wants to take the plunge.

https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/540-Hudson-St-Seabrook-NH-03874/95357882_zpid/
swampstander

Whoop Delecto
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Editorial in today's Galveston paper Hope this link gets behind paywall but here are a couple of excerpts:

But the oversupply of houses on the market is real. What it means for the future is worth thinking about.


Galveston's housing glut rises from a one-time surge in investments in short-term rental properties that came out of the five years since 2020 in other words, the period of the Covid-19 pandemic.


Today, many owners are selling, and that has created the glut something like an 18-month supply of homes for sale versus a normal market of roughly six months. The oversupply in the 77554 ZIP code, the island's West End, is about 20 months.


It was a classic example of irrational exuberance.

Short-term rental registrations in Galveston spiked, rising from 2,300 in 2021 to a peak of about 4,900 in 2023.

JMac03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Values may be going up, but so are expenses. Many years ago we went in with another couple on a house. Fixed upper. We got out after about 2 years.

They finally sold it late last year - they just weren't making $$ anymore after paying the management company and insurance. Now I don't know how much they made off the house, but it just wasn't worth it for them anymore.
EclipseAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
HAR data shows that average price per square foot in Pirates Beach nearly doubled from 2018-2022, from $232 to $437.

That's incredible.
Yesterday
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
EclipseAg said:

HAR data shows that average price per square foot in Pirates Beach nearly doubled from 2018-2022, from $232 to $437.

That's incredible.
I'm ignorant, but I feel that can be said for most places in Texas. No?
Diggity
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
you aren't kidding.

Just looked up the complex where my parents used to own and folks that bought in the past several years are getting slaughtered.
Diggity
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yesterday said:

EclipseAg said:

HAR data shows that average price per square foot in Pirates Beach nearly doubled from 2018-2022, from $232 to $437.

That's incredible.
I'm ignorant, but I feel that can be said for most places in Texas. No?
maybe isolated pockets. but the (vast) majority of the state did not double in value over a 4 year period
v1rotate92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Bought 17 acres land with AG exemption 1.5 hours from home.
Built weld up barndo for $40k, taxes still only $220 year.
I love it, but would not like it as much if I was paying "normal" property tax and insurance
Also bought in '21 with low interest rate so the fact it's appreciated 40% makes me happy. Again, I would not get as much enjoyment out of something the government is raping me on
Slick
AggieMarkSA
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Diggity said:

Yesterday said:

EclipseAg said:

HAR data shows that average price per square foot in Pirates Beach nearly doubled from 2018-2022, from $232 to $437.

That's incredible.
I'm ignorant, but I feel that can be said for most places in Texas. No?
maybe isolated pockets. but the (vast) majority of the state did not double in value over a 4 year period
The beach homes in Galveston went crazy. The mindset was "who cares about the price, interest rates are low. Plus, we can always rent it."

Now people are stuck with low rates but high principals. There are going to be deals.
EclipseAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AggieMarkSA said:

Diggity said:

Yesterday said:

EclipseAg said:

HAR data shows that average price per square foot in Pirates Beach nearly doubled from 2018-2022, from $232 to $437.

That's incredible.
I'm ignorant, but I feel that can be said for most places in Texas. No?
maybe isolated pockets. but the (vast) majority of the state did not double in value over a 4 year period
The beach homes in Galveston went crazy.
Indeed. I've been around Pirates Beach since the '90s, as a renter, a dreamer, an owner and then an interested follower. And the price escalation, even for basic back row houses, was insane.
DrEvazanPhD
How long do you want to ignore this user?
EclipseAg said:

AggieMarkSA said:

Diggity said:

Yesterday said:

EclipseAg said:

HAR data shows that average price per square foot in Pirates Beach nearly doubled from 2018-2022, from $232 to $437.

That's incredible.
I'm ignorant, but I feel that can be said for most places in Texas. No?
maybe isolated pockets. but the (vast) majority of the state did not double in value over a 4 year period
The beach homes in Galveston went crazy.
Indeed. I've been around Pirates Beach since the '90s, as a renter, a dreamer, an owner and then an interested follower. And the price escalation, even for basic back row houses, was insane.


We looked at pirates beach, among other communities, in 2021-22. 600k + for a 3/2 1100 square foot bungalow with no view. No thanks
Page 2 of 3
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.