Hubby's bday is this week and I was trying to think of good dinner options. He really loves good seafood. Anywhere y'all think is special in SA or surrounding area? I don't care if it's casual or more formal - just a place that makes it well!
Post Reply
1 of 1
seafood?
7,665 Views |
33 Replies |
Last: 1 yr ago by Thaddeus73
Eddie V's Prime Seafood, little more high end
Fish City Grill is more casual
Also like McAdoos but n New Braunfels
Fish City Grill is more casual
Also like McAdoos but n New Braunfels
Upscale had a really well done fish selection.
+1 for the above, but Paesanoshas a decent seafood selection…..UnderoosAg said:
Eddie V's Prime Seafood, little more high end
Fish City Grill is more casual
Also like McAdoos but n New Braunfels
Edit….Lincoln Heights….below is the seafood trio….
Blackened Snapper at Fish City Grill-Rim was really good a few weeks ago. They have specials on chalkboard that rotate and not on regular menu.
If The Reel up in Spring branch, it has been excellent every time I have been. It is a sister restaurant to Macado's that was recommended above. Also a great choice but in new Braunfels.
Cappy's in Alamo Heights is pretty dang good.
bam02 said:
If The Reel up in Spring branch, it has been excellent every time I have been. It is a sister restaurant to Macado's that was recommended above. Also a great choice but in new Braunfels.
The Reel has been gone for several years now.
Oh. I realize now I had a typo. I meant to ask "is the Reel still…"
I haven't been in 3-4 years but went several times and it was always outstanding.
I haven't been in 3-4 years but went several times and it was always outstanding.
The Reel reopened in New Braunfels in the shopping area corner of 337 and 46. Been multiple times, still very good.
Tony Franklins Other Shoe
Joined:
May 6, 2014
Posts:
31,186
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Eddie V's and a very dirty martini.
Person Not Capable of Pregnancy
Person Not Capable of Pregnancy
Tony Franklins Other Shoe said:
Eddie V's and a very dirty martini.
The shoe understands
Eddie V's for sure. Same location as where Wildfish once was (was also very good).
Pappadeux ain't bad either but I haven't been in a long time.
As mentioned The Reel reopened in New Braunfels. Took my folks there for Mother's Day. The food was decent but they don't understand how reservations work. Both times I've been we've made reservations in advance and both times had to wait at least 20 minutes. Not sure I'll go back.
Pappadeux ain't bad either but I haven't been in a long time.
As mentioned The Reel reopened in New Braunfels. Took my folks there for Mother's Day. The food was decent but they don't understand how reservations work. Both times I've been we've made reservations in advance and both times had to wait at least 20 minutes. Not sure I'll go back.
The Reel is not affiliated with McAdoo's.bam02 said:
If The Reel up in Spring branch, it has been excellent every time I have been. It is a sister restaurant to Macado's that was recommended above. Also a great choice but in new Braunfels.
The head chef from when McAdoo's first opened left and started the Reel a long time ago but I don't know if he is still there or not. We ate there a month or two ago and it was pretty good but McAdoo's has a much better setting.
Ah must be a common misconception. I've heard it from multiple people.
I like Fish City - a smaller restaurant and doesn't seem as noisy as some. Bonus is they have several 2 top tables, so not as likely to have to wait for just 2 people.LCE said:
Blackened Snapper at Fish City Grill-Rim was really good a few weeks ago. They have specials on chalkboard that rotate and not on regular menu.
The people who own McAdoo's also own La Cosecha so that may be where the confusion is coming from.
Aren't The Reel and Dos Rios related?
I believe you are correct
Beckdiesel03 said:
Aren't The Reel and Dos Rios related?
Yes. Same ownership.
No Fred Fish Fry mention yet?
Slacking
Slacking
Bexar Ag said:
No Fred Fish Fry mention yet?
Slacking
Can't have them actually selling fish. Makes it harder to launder funds.
On step 12 of 22 step BAS Anonymous program. Please donate, the struggle is real.
Seafood place in the old Post Office.James Walker `02 said:The Reel is not affiliated with McAdoo's.bam02 said:
If The Reel up in Spring branch, it has been excellent every time I have been. It is a sister restaurant to Macado's that was recommended above. Also a great choice but in new Braunfels.
The head chef from when McAdoo's first opened left and started the Reel a long time ago but I don't know if he is still there or not. We ate there a month or two ago and it was pretty good but McAdoo's has a much better setting.
McAdoo's is in the old Post Office. The Reel is in a strip mall off of 337 and Hwy 46
Yessir. Went to McAdoo's a couple weeks ago. The catfish was good but was disappointed in the fried shrimp. Kind of tasteless. Don't believe they were Gulf shrimp.James Walker `02 said:
McAdoo's is in the old Post Office. The Reel is in a strip mall off of 337 and Hwy 46
Order the "Colossal Shrimp " at any Sea Island Shrimphouse.
Thank me later!
Thank me later!
Fish City Grill-Rim. Arrived. Saturday around 6:45. 4-5 tables occupied. Ordered crawfish etoufee and grilled swordfish. Etoufee was bland and probably microwaved with Swordfish raw. Not going back
Oyster Bar and Bay Seas in the gas station have great cat fish. McAdoo's is a great restaurant. The Bloody Mary Bar at Sunday Brunch is cool.
Fish City Grill at the Rim. Saturday around 6:45 and place was almost empty. Crawfish Etouffee was bland and lukewarm. Grilled Swordfish was raw and cold.
Drinks were no better.
Drinks were no better.
I believe Clementine has the octopus on the menu right now.
Always have one fish on the rotating mains.
Best dinner you'll have in all of SA.
Always have one fish on the rotating mains.
Best dinner you'll have in all of SA.
You can say that again...
Oh wait
Oh wait
On step 12 of 22 step BAS Anonymous program. Please donate, the struggle is real.
I love Sea Island...
Featured Stories
See All
Presenting Texas Aggies United's 'Battle At Reed' Sweepstakes!
by Texas Aggies United
35:25
2h ago
1.3k
The TexAgs Tailgate: Texas A&M vs. Southern California
by Richard Zane
35:16
10h ago
3.5k