Earley is an easy scapegoat

8,634 Views | 72 Replies | Last: 9 mo ago by Fairview20
Gyles Marrett
How long do you want to ignore this user?
It's easy to blame him. He's been far from perfect. I've criticized several decisions myself.

But the simple reality is injury and not having the depth many thought is by FAR the bigger issue.

The players that played in place of Grahovac and Sorrell last night went 0-9 with 8K's. You can't lose two of your best bats and replace it with that and expect to win much is the reality. At some point somebody filling in has to step up or that the status quo of outcomes is not going to change.
W
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
part of it is the transfer players

they're just not good -- outside of Henseler

so the middle of the order is incredibly weak 4-5-6
Wabs
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
W said:

part of it is the transfer players

they're just not good -- outside of Henseler

so the middle of the order is incredibly weak 4-5-6
And then 7-8-9 is worse.
Texas_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Weird take. I might agree with you that we should not have been the #1 team in the country. But to say a team that is .500 at this point and putting up an o-fer in SEC play is scapegoating our coach is a little odd. We are bad, bad. Not just losing Grahovac bad. We weren't a good hitting team with him on the team. I think the wheels are about to really come off at this point. This team is lost, uncomfortable and mental. Problem is, we have a first year head coach that appears the same.
Come Out Roll
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Texas_Ag11 said:

Weird take. I might agree with you that we should not have been the #1 team in the country. But to say a team that is .500 at this point and putting up an o-fer in SEC play is scapegoating our coach is a little odd. We are bad, bad. Not just losing Grahovac bad. We weren't a good hitting team with him on the team. I think the wheels are about to really come off at this point. This team is lost, uncomfortable and mental. Problem is, we have a first year head coach that appears WORSE.


FIFY
TAMUallen
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Stop making excuses for poor coaching.
StinkyPinky
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I agree coaching definitely plays into it and should should be held to significant accountability. But it is also fair to say we are a different team offensively. The top 10 offensive players in 2024 in order….

Schott
Appel
Kent
Montgomery
Violence
Grahovac
Ali
Burton
Sorrell
Chestnutt

We have only 3 of those players that are actively participating (lost 70%). That is an entire different scenario than having a returning offense
FM 949
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
scapegoat and reason are two different words.
The Collective
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
We were so sensitive over having our Coach stolen that we decided to do whatever it took to keep our guys from transferring. That's why we are here today. Some have said we had no option to make a long term hire due to timing. That might be true… unless something changes, we should know in May.
Gyles Marrett
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Texas_Ag11 said:

Weird take. I might agree with you that we should not have been the #1 team in the country. But to say a team that is .500 at this point and putting up an o-fer in SEC play is scapegoating our coach is a little odd. We are bad, bad. Not just losing Grahovac bad. We weren't a good hitting team with him on the team. I think the wheels are about to really come off at this point. This team is lost, uncomfortable and mental. Problem is, we have a first year head coach that appears the same.
It's weird to think our biggest issue is replacing two very high likely 1st round MLB draft picks with guys that went 0-9 with 8k's? lol Never said Earely has been great. But give me those 9 AB's with a healthy Grahovac and Sorrell and we very likely have a very different situation currently.

I swear a huge percentage of people on here don't understand baseball.
The Collective
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I also have lots of questions over the preseason coverage of this team… embarrassment of riches. We don't appear to have the depth that many expected.
AggieBB
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Gyles Marrett said:

It's easy to blame him. He's been far from perfect. I've criticized several decisions myself.

But the simple reality is injury and not having the depth many thought is by FAR the bigger issue.

The players that played in place of Grahovac and Sorrell last night went 0-9 with 8K's. You can't lose two of your best bats and replace it with that and expect to win much is the reality. At some point somebody filling in has to step up or that the status quo of outcomes is not going to change.


You seem to forget Grahovac is a high k guy as well so basing this off of last night is pretty funny. Definitely miss him but Hensler is at least as good as Gavin. Now LF, that's a valid point. This is 100% on the head man. He's obviously not ready for this job. That was my concern when we hired him, but I thought with all the talent they would cover up some of the flaws.
greg.w.h
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TAMUallen said:

Stop making excuses for poor coaching.
So…you know no plan survives contact with the enemy???
Gyles Marrett
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AggieBB said:

Gyles Marrett said:

It's easy to blame him. He's been far from perfect. I've criticized several decisions myself.

But the simple reality is injury and not having the depth many thought is by FAR the bigger issue.

The players that played in place of Grahovac and Sorrell last night went 0-9 with 8K's. You can't lose two of your best bats and replace it with that and expect to win much is the reality. At some point somebody filling in has to step up or that the status quo of outcomes is not going to change.


You seem to forget Grahovac is a high k guy as well so basing this off of last night is pretty funny. Definitely miss him but Hensler is at least as good as Gavin. Now LF, that's a valid point. This is 100% on the head man. He's obviously not ready for this job. That was my concern when we hired him, but I thought with all the talent they would cover up some of the flaws.
Hensler isn't replacing Gavin in our lineup currently. He's playing his position in the field but Royo and Farr have been his replacement in the lineup....
Agryan00
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I agree. When Kent, LaViolet, and Hensler went 4-36 last weekend against Bama. Its just not fair Earley has such an inferior group of kids. We just need some depth behind them.

Can you remind me which coach again was responsible for recruiting in the offseason. We gotta replace that guy. Then again it sounds like it was a tough job as this was rebuilding year.
Gyles Marrett
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Agryan00 said:

I agree. When Kent, LaViolet, and Hensler went 4-36 last weekend against Bama. Its just not fair Earley has such an inferior group of kids. We just need some depth behind them.

Can you remind me which coach again was responsible for recruiting in the offseason. We gotta replace that guy. Then again it sounds like it was a tough job as this was rebuilding year.
You mean the class we brought it we were all raving about? Now we want to say he recruited poorly?

https://aggieswire.usatoday.com/story/sports/college/aggies/baseball/2024/11/18/texas-aggies-baseball-coach-mike-earley-inks-a-top-10-recruiting-class/76400387007/
Agryan00
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Did I miss something. When did Grahovac and Sorrell become the Machado and Soto of college baseball. The worse we play the better they get.
Marooned1994
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Earley isn't a scapegoat, he's the head coach and is responsible for this team...all of it - recruiting, hitting, defense, pitching. As much as I want him to be wildly successful, it's not happening and at this point I fear the team has lost confidence in him. Won't be surprised if we see the mass exodus we all feared last off season happen this coming off season.
Agryan00
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Marooned1994 said:

Earley isn't a scapegoat, he's the head coach and is responsible for this team...all of it - recruiting, hitting, defense, pitching. As much as I want him to be wildly successful, it's not happening and at this point I fear the team has lost confidence in him. Won't be surprised if we see the mass exodus we all feared last off season happen this coming off season.
Waiting for someone to say it. Grahovac going to look real nice in one of them orange uniforms playing for title next year down the street. Hopefully its one of them bright orange ones in Knoxville and not one of those puke orange ones. His dad is an ex-pro and they understand its a business. Why would he stay after this season? Once the anchor player leaves watch the rest of them go. We going to suck again! Hope Trev saved that money!
Great2BeAnAGGIE
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
He makes the lineup card.
He chose to place players in positions they really never played.
He makes the call on our offensive strategy.
He chose his assistant coaches.
He is solely responsible for an embarrassing drop from a unanimous #1 preseason ranking to unranked 0-4 in conference play in historic fashion.

I would love for the season to turn around but since he has never been a head coach before all I can do is wish. All I see right now is random decisions hoping he gets lucky.
Killzone3abc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This is cope. He coached these transfers all fall. Transfers that have had plenty of success in D1 baseball prior. He didn't identify our 1st basemen couldn't plays 1st. He didn't identify our starting LF couldnt play OF. He determines the offensive philosophy and plate approach. Our loses aren't just to SEC teams if you remember. We've lost 6 games to what should be inferior competition because the team as a whole is just unacceptably bad even with the injuries.
Killzone3abc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The Collective said:

I also have lots of questions over the preseason coverage of this team… embarrassment of riches. We don't appear to have the depth that many expected.

We have a roster full of guys everyone wanted. This is not a personnel problem, and I don't blame anyone for being high on this extremely talented team preseason.
Killzone3abc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
During coaching changes it's best to just assume no out of state kid is staying unless they have additional ties to the school.
jagged
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think we can all agree we are playing below our potential, even when considering injuries. Fielding has been about as terrible as the approach at the plate. Bad mix of bad pitch recognition and low self-confidence level. Result is we almost never get a clutch hit in the bigger games.

We need a better approach, whether play scrappier, little bit of small ball, get your guy on base to the next base. Just a lot of low quality AB's and little chemistry/complementary play.

Also, not sure if it was the wild offseason or what but hard to not think the Grahovac injury situation was poorly managed and resulted in pretty much a worse case scenario.
GymBroFisher
How long do you want to ignore this user?
With a healthy squad, I would be agreeing Earley is terrible. But Gavin and Sorrell are two massive injuries. Schott also reinjured himself. I mean it's a lot of stuff Earley had no control over. that's 3/4 your top hitters if healthy most likely. Do that to any top team and see how much worse they get.
northeastag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Honest question for those of you that think Earley is the problem. Considering the current level of play will not get the team anywhere in the vicinity of Omaha this year, would you rather see a total meltdown and a subsequent firing of the coach, or would you rather see the team struggle into a regional, lose, and then see the coach stick around another year or two based on potential.
Wabs
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
northeastag said:

Honest question for those of you that think Earley is the problem. Considering the current level of play will not get the team anywhere in the vicinity of Omaha this year, would you rather see a total meltdown and a subsequent firing of the coach, or would you rather see the team struggle into a regional, lose, and then see the coach stick around another year or two based on potential.
I don't "want" to see anyone fired. I'm pulling for Earley and the team to turn this thing around and do well. I think the chances are slim, but we can only hope. My actual preference is for the team to do the best as they possibly can and then assess where we are at the end (or near the end) of the season.
MagnumLoad
How long do you want to ignore this user?
We need to adjust to the umpiring. When the ump is calling strikes on our hitters that are on the opposite box line, move up on the plate. Stand on the batter's box line closest to the plate. Take until you have two strikes. Pitch counts will go up. Walks will go up. HBP will go up. And you can still drive an outside pitch.
I hate tu. It's in my blood.
JaceAG12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Let's just compare this to TCU. Schloss also left them high and dry after a run of good seasons. They hired Kirk Saarloss an internal candidate with no HC experience.

In his first year they made a regional and second year they made the CWS.


Earleys performance has been absolutely terrible. Any other opinion is just excuses.
PhatMack19
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Coaching baseball is mostly mental when everyone has dudes. POS was good at it. Early isn't.

The best baseball coaches are basically psychologist
vwbug
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Percentages we are looking for new coaching in June ?
Tergdor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
vwbug said:

Percentages we are looking for new coaching in June ?
Depends on how much the athletic department wants to sell out their season tickets
NumberEinAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I agree
"They who would give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." Benjamin Franklin
Blonde Coffee Beans
How long do you want to ignore this user?
This team has tons of talent. The coaching staff does not
BTHOBadDecisions
How long do you want to ignore this user?
It's a truly unfortunate situation. This program not only had exceptional talent this year, but was also built for sustained success in the years to come. Yet, for reasons unclear, the coaching staff chose to abandon a proven formula in favor of their own approach to playing and recruiting.

The consequences go far beyond just this season. Future recruiting classes have already taken a hit. A clear example is the noticeable drop-off in the 2026 recruiting class after POS's departure. Strong recruiters understand how to retain top talentsomething this staff has clearly failed to prioritize. Not being able to capitalize on 2024 success is indefensible.

Even if they somehow manage to pull off a winning season, the deeper issues with recruiting and culture will remain. Rather than securing high school prospects who genuinely want to be here and buy into the program's long-term vision, the staff is now forced to rely heavily on NIL deals and the transfer portal to patch over their poor decisions.

But there's a fundamental difference between a high school recruit who is committed to the school's future and a transfer chasing NIL money. These represent two vastly different mindsetsand two different cultures. One builds identity, stability, and cohesion over time. The other is transactional, temporary, and ultimately unsustainable.

Meanwhile, the head coach has become a punchline in and around the areadespite having a winning team, blind support from boosters, and top-tier talent. Failing to capitalize on that momentum during the offseason falls squarely on him. His questionable in-game decisions and offseason training program are already raising concern, and as pressure builds, those mistakes are likely to get worse. Think it's bad now? Just wait until the Austin series.

It's also completely unfair to expect the fanbase to blindly support him and cover for his inefficiencies by throwing money at NIL deals to hide his failures. Not only is that an irresponsible approach, but it's also unstableespecially considering how frequently the NCAA has changed NIL rules over the past three years. This is not a long-term solution.

We can't keep giving the athletics department a free pass with zero accountability. The fact that the university handed out a four-year guaranteed contract to an unproven coachwith no performance benchmarks or meaningful oversightis a slap in the face to a passionate fanbase and a sign that the school doesn't truly respect the sport or its supporters.

This short-sighted strategy, lack of leadership, and failure to build a winning culture will have lasting consequences. The responsibility lies entirely with the staffnot the playersand unless changes are made quickly, the damage could define the program's trajectory for years to come.

Last Page
Page 1 of 3
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.