Anecdotes of people catching Covid while wearing masks

5,328 Views | 59 Replies | Last: 5 yr ago by ElephantRider
Confucius
How long do you want to ignore this user?
This heavily starred thread on F16 got me thinking: Has anyone heard of someone dutifully wearing facemasks when needed and still catching coronavirus? I haven't heard of anyone being good with masks and catching it, and you would think with mask truthers out there thinking this is a sham, that there would be actual stories of mask usage not working.

https://texags.com/forums/16/topics/3125092/1

AggieOO
How long do you want to ignore this user?
clicking on that link and going to F16 will probably give you corona.
ElephantRider
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AggieOO said:

clicking on that link and going to F16 will probably give you corona.

It may not give you the corona, but it will definitely kill brain cells
KlinkerAg11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think you can catch it while wearing a mask.

To me it's slows the transmission down, and more importantly I think it gives you a lower viral load.

I think it could be the difference between a severe case or a mild one.
Petrino1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
There was a poster here that said he caught it and was very good about wearing masks and staying home/social distancing.
Duncan Idaho
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Since 700+ healthcare workers have died, I think there is a fair amount of anecdotal evidence that you can catch it wearing a mask.

But I dont believe anyone (of any credibility) has ever said that masks (any mask) 100% prevent transmission the virus. It is about making a material reduction in risk through a low cost means.

These arguments remind me of the arguments against condom use. They dont work 100% of the time, so why bother using them or encouraging them?

012-MAN
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I thought the virus enters via your mount/nose or eyes. Thus wearing a mask can restrict it from entering the nose/mouth but it can still get in via your eyes. Also you can get it by rubbing your hands on your nose or eyes.

thus... it helps, but does not prevent
chigger
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.

I don't know why this is so difficult for people to understand. Obviously there has not been enough done to educate people. Either that or willful ignorance. Use the surgery example. Surgeons don't wear them to protect themselves. They wear them to protect the patient.

Like mentioned above, I believe It can make some difference in your own protection. But that's not the main point.
Confucius
How long do you want to ignore this user?
For the record, I'm not arguing against the use of masks. Just found it funny there are so many mask truthers out there without a scintilla of evidence indicating they are right.
Capitol Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
chigger said:

People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.


This is getting tiresome to a lot of us and should only be allowed to go so far. The clock is ticking on this mask thing. It can't become a new normal. Neither can closing businesses or limiting mass gatherings and events. While it sounds great to say this, in the end with absolutely questionable methods of accounting for cases and deaths from the virus and the simple fact that we at some point just have to move on with our own lives, it's on the scientists, pharmaceutical companies and doctors to find the right treatments, a vaccine or something to mitigate the effects of the virus or we are going to just have to concede this is with us, people will sadly and unfortunately die but the majority of us will be fine and go on. The protecting others line will only go so far.
ElephantRider
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Capitol Ag said:

chigger said:

People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.


This is getting tiresome to a lot of us and should only be allowed to go so far. The clock is ticking on this mask thing. It can't become a new normal. Neither can closing businesses or limiting mass gatherings and events. While it sounds great to say this, in the end with absolutely questionable methods of accounting for cases and deaths from the virus and the simple fact that we at some point just have to move on with our own lives, it's on the scientists, pharmaceutical companies and doctors to find the right treatments, a vaccine or something to mitigate the effects of the virus or we are going to just have to concede this is with us, people will sadly and unfortunately die but the majority of us will be fine and go on. The protecting others line will only go so far.

If you don't want businesses to close, we need to limit the spread. Why are you not willing to help limit the spread?
Capitol Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
ElephantRider said:

Capitol Ag said:

chigger said:

People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.


This is getting tiresome to a lot of us and should only be allowed to go so far. The clock is ticking on this mask thing. It can't become a new normal. Neither can closing businesses or limiting mass gatherings and events. While it sounds great to say this, in the end with absolutely questionable methods of accounting for cases and deaths from the virus and the simple fact that we at some point just have to move on with our own lives, it's on the scientists, pharmaceutical companies and doctors to find the right treatments, a vaccine or something to mitigate the effects of the virus or we are going to just have to concede this is with us, people will sadly and unfortunately die but the majority of us will be fine and go on. The protecting others line will only go so far.

If you don't want businesses to close, we need to limit the spread. Why are you not willing to help limit the spread?
You are not addressing my point. Businesses can stay completely open now. We do not need to limit the spread technically. Sure, for a humane perspective, it might make people feel comfortable to limit the spread. From a hospital perspective, it may keep the hospitals from overcrowding and allow for other obvious issues from arising if hospitals have trouble treating non covid along with covid patients. But that doesn't mean we HAVE to limit anything.

At some point in this, IF there is not an effective treatment available, we cannot live indefinitely in masks, limiting mass events and closing businesses. Its not reasonable or realistic. Unfortunately, a lot of us realize that you just cannot save everyone or eliminate every virus. Since the overwhelming majority of us will be fine, it this does end up being the case and a way to mitigate the virus cannot be found within a reasonable amount to time, we will have to make the call to move forward. That time is coming faster than you think.

And I am totally willing to "limit the spread". I even wear these cute little dumbass masks. But how one defines "limit the spread" and how far each of us is willing to go for something where 99.997% survive, and most of which have no lasting effects nor even know they have it, it's just not reasonable to act like this is some end of the world killer virus. It simply is not.
FriscoKid
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
yes

https://texags.com/forums/16/topics/3123307/replies/56944321
tysker
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
chigger said:

People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.
Dont tell us, tell the people wearing a mask while alone walking their dog alone. Tell the people wearing masks on the beach. Tell the people wearing a mask while driving their car.
ORAggieFan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ElephantRider said:

Capitol Ag said:

chigger said:

People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.


This is getting tiresome to a lot of us and should only be allowed to go so far. The clock is ticking on this mask thing. It can't become a new normal. Neither can closing businesses or limiting mass gatherings and events. While it sounds great to say this, in the end with absolutely questionable methods of accounting for cases and deaths from the virus and the simple fact that we at some point just have to move on with our own lives, it's on the scientists, pharmaceutical companies and doctors to find the right treatments, a vaccine or something to mitigate the effects of the virus or we are going to just have to concede this is with us, people will sadly and unfortunately die but the majority of us will be fine and go on. The protecting others line will only go so far.

If you don't want businesses to close, we need to limit the spread. Why are you not willing to help limit the spread?
Or be like Sweden, don't close anything and move past it.
amercer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
tysker said:

chigger said:

People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.
Dont tell us, tell the people wearing a mask while alone walking their dog alone. Tell the people wearing masks on the beach. Tell the people wearing a mask while driving their car.


Sure. When I see them I'll tell them thanks for doing their part to limit the spread, for protecting others, and for showing some simple courtesy that seems really hard to come by these days.
htxag09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
chigger said:

People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.

I don't know why this is so difficult for people to understand. Obviously there has not been enough done to educate people. Either that or willful ignorance. Use the surgery example. Surgeons don't wear them to protect themselves. They wear them to protect the patient.

Like mentioned above, I believe It can make some difference in your own protection. But that's not the main point.

This. Studies have been done, cloth masks don't do a whole lot to protect you. The filtration isn't good enough. If you are immunocompromised, you should be wearing an N95 mask and taking other precautions, IMO. However, a sick person wearing a cloth mask will do a hell of a lot to keep the virus from spreading to others.

I'm not an expert. This is just my opinion after reading articles, studies, and listening to podcasts.
tysker
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
amercer said:

tysker said:

chigger said:

People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.
Dont tell us, tell the people wearing a mask while alone walking their dog alone. Tell the people wearing masks on the beach. Tell the people wearing a mask while driving their car.


Sure. When I see them I'll tell them thanks for doing their part to limit the spread, for protecting others, and for showing some simple courtesy that seems really hard to come by these days.
Watching CNBC right now and not a one is wearing a mask... Same goes for local news and most live TV I've seen over the last several months. You would think they would participate in the same courtesies and simple protections of others.
QuantumNoodle
How long do you want to ignore this user?
https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/14/cdc-study-says-mask-mandates-should-be-considered-after-examining-missouri-hair-salon.html

Quote:

The authors of the study investigated the case of two infected hair stylists in Springfield, Missouri, who appear to have not transmitted the virus to any of their 139 clients even as they continued to work while infectious.
The two infected hair stylists wore a mask. 98% of their customers wore a mask. None of their customers got infected.

[x] Masks
[x] Business Open
[x] Success
Capitol Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
ORAggieFan said:

ElephantRider said:

Capitol Ag said:

chigger said:

People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.


This is getting tiresome to a lot of us and should only be allowed to go so far. The clock is ticking on this mask thing. It can't become a new normal. Neither can closing businesses or limiting mass gatherings and events. While it sounds great to say this, in the end with absolutely questionable methods of accounting for cases and deaths from the virus and the simple fact that we at some point just have to move on with our own lives, it's on the scientists, pharmaceutical companies and doctors to find the right treatments, a vaccine or something to mitigate the effects of the virus or we are going to just have to concede this is with us, people will sadly and unfortunately die but the majority of us will be fine and go on. The protecting others line will only go so far.

If you don't want businesses to close, we need to limit the spread. Why are you not willing to help limit the spread?
Or be like Sweden, don't close anything and move past it.
It's funny how this simple concept seems to allude certain people. It's like they think that there is some sort of barrier if the virus starts to spread to being able to unlock a business's door and open it up to the public. Like a force field or something. Yet it is totally possible!
Duncan Idaho
How long do you want to ignore this user?
RockOn said:

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/14/cdc-study-says-mask-mandates-should-be-considered-after-examining-missouri-hair-salon.html

Quote:

The authors of the study investigated the case of two infected hair stylists in Springfield, Missouri, who appear to have not transmitted the virus to any of their 139 clients even as they continued to work while infectious.
The two infected hair stylists wore a mask. 98% of their customers wore a mask. None of their customers got infected.

[x] Masks
[x] Business Open
[x] Success


Notice that the 2% that were non-mask wearers didnt get sick either.

SeE MaSk DoNt MaTtEr. /f16
tysker
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
RockOn said:

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/14/cdc-study-says-mask-mandates-should-be-considered-after-examining-missouri-hair-salon.html

Quote:

The authors of the study investigated the case of two infected hair stylists in Springfield, Missouri, who appear to have not transmitted the virus to any of their 139 clients even as they continued to work while infectious.
The two infected hair stylists wore a mask. 98% of their customers wore a mask. None of their customers got infected.

[x] Masks
[x] Business Open
[x] Success
Not arguing that masks dont work but again details matter:
Quote:

The two stylists always wore either a "double-layered cotton face covering" or a surgical mask when interacting with clients, the researchers said. They added that clients reported wearing either a cloth face covering, a surgical mask or an N95 respirator for all or part of the time they were in the business.
Cloth masks =/ surgical masks =/ N95 respirators. Not all masks are equal.

Also the data set is incomplete:
Quote:

Not all clients agreed to be tested and some may have been tested too early in the virus' incubation period to turn up a positive test, despite potentially testing positive later, the researchers said.

Overall, 67 clients agreed to be tested and 72 refused, the researchers wrote, but of the 139 total clients, 104 were interviewed by the Greene County Health Department about whether they had developed symptoms. Some 87 of the 104 reached said they did not develop symptoms, and of those who did report symptoms, none received Covid-19 testing.

That means it's possible asymptomatic or mildly symptomatic people who could have been infected at the salon went undetected.
What did their client base look like? And even the ones that had symptoms didn't get tested because back in May we were still mainly testing people with bad cases that needed hospitalization.

The headline doesn't really give the full picture of the research.

edit to add: How did the first stylist transmit to the second if they were both wearing masks?
Quote:

One of the stylists developed symptoms on May 12, the researchers said, and continued to work until May 20, when they received a positive Covid-19 test result. In that time, the infected person passed the virus onto another stylist who also continued to work until May 20, despite developing symptoms on May 15,
Capitol Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
amercer said:

tysker said:

chigger said:

People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.
Dont tell us, tell the people wearing a mask while alone walking their dog alone. Tell the people wearing masks on the beach. Tell the people wearing a mask while driving their car.


Sure. When I see them I'll tell them thanks for doing their part to limit the spread, for protecting others, and for showing some simple courtesy that seems really hard to come by these days.
Yet masks helped no one in those circumstances that were mentioned! Were the birds protected on the guy's walk when he was alone wearing a mask? Were the invisible people in the car protected by the woman wearing her mask alone while driving? What about the guy alone on the beach? Thank God the whales and crabs and sea gulls won't get Covid!
BowSowy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Capitol Ag said:

ORAggieFan said:

ElephantRider said:

Capitol Ag said:

chigger said:

nm




BowSowy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
RockOn said:

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/14/cdc-study-says-mask-mandates-should-be-considered-after-examining-missouri-hair-salon.html

Quote:

The authors of the study investigated the case of two infected hair stylists in Springfield, Missouri, who appear to have not transmitted the virus to any of their 139 clients even as they continued to work while infectious.
The two infected hair stylists wore a mask. 98% of their customers wore a mask. None of their customers got infected.

[x] Masks
[x] Business Open
[x] Success
I remember hearing this. That's actually pretty astonishing to me
ElephantRider
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Capitol Ag said:

ORAggieFan said:

ElephantRider said:

Capitol Ag said:

chigger said:

People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.


This is getting tiresome to a lot of us and should only be allowed to go so far. The clock is ticking on this mask thing. It can't become a new normal. Neither can closing businesses or limiting mass gatherings and events. While it sounds great to say this, in the end with absolutely questionable methods of accounting for cases and deaths from the virus and the simple fact that we at some point just have to move on with our own lives, it's on the scientists, pharmaceutical companies and doctors to find the right treatments, a vaccine or something to mitigate the effects of the virus or we are going to just have to concede this is with us, people will sadly and unfortunately die but the majority of us will be fine and go on. The protecting others line will only go so far.

If you don't want businesses to close, we need to limit the spread. Why are you not willing to help limit the spread?
Or be like Sweden, don't close anything and move past it.
It's funny how this simple concept seems to allude certain people. It's like they think that there is some sort of barrier if the virus starts to spread to being able to unlock a businesses door and open it up to the public. Like a force field or something. Yet it is totally possible!

No one thinks that.

We have a governor who has shown that he will step in when numbers are rising. Why not do what you can to not give him the opportunity to shut things down? No one is asking you to wear a mask forever. Is it really that big of a deal to wear one for now?

We're also not Sweden, so it's silly to just say we should do what they did. They have 10 million people with low density, have universal healthcare, and are healthier and more socially conscious. New Zealand beat it by being hyper-aggressive, but what they did wouldn't work here either. None of it is one size fits all.

Sisyphus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Or be like Sweden, don't close anything and move past it.

Sweden's economy slowed by as much or more than their neighbors but they had 10x the number of per capita deaths. They didn't gain anything by remaining open. They lost a lot
FlyRod
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Everyone in Asia, where mask wearing is ubiquitous, cases are few/low, and life is returning to normal, is reading this thread and shaking their heads.
ElephantRider
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Capitol Ag said:

amercer said:

tysker said:

chigger said:

People still don't get it do they. It's not so much about protecting yourself. It's protecting others. It's a courtesy thing. No one said you wouldn't get it if you wear a mask. It's about preventing the spread.
Dont tell us, tell the people wearing a mask while alone walking their dog alone. Tell the people wearing masks on the beach. Tell the people wearing a mask while driving their car.


Sure. When I see them I'll tell them thanks for doing their part to limit the spread, for protecting others, and for showing some simple courtesy that seems really hard to come by these days.
Yet masks helped no one in those circumstances that were mentioned! Were the birds protected on the guy's walk when he was alone wearing a mask? Were the invisible people in the car protected by the woman wearing her mask alone while driving? What about the guy alone on the beach? Thank God the whales and crabs and sea gulls won't get Covid!


You're right, the mask serves no purpose there. I only wear when I'm going into the store. But why are you so triggered by the sight of someone in a mask? It doesn't affect you
Sisyphus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

To me it's slows the transmission down, and more importantly I think it gives you a lower viral load.

I think it could be the difference between a severe case or a mild one.

This is very true and needs to be communicated better. The viral load matters just as the amount of poison you ingest matters and could be the difference between becoming sick or dying. A mask won't necessarily prevent you from catching it but it will lower your exposure and that could be enough to spare you
Sisyphus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Dont tell us, tell the people wearing a mask while alone walking their dog alone. Tell the people wearing masks on the beach. Tell the people wearing a mask while driving their car.

If you're in an area where the virus is airborne, it will collect on the outer surface of the mask as you breathe in. So masks don't protect you well if you're touching them often to put them on and off. That's why people leave them on and they are smart to do so.

I don't understand why that would bother you.
Duncan Idaho
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Never mind that it is also about habits.

I wear a mask everytime I go somewhere because it is a habit. I wash my hands everytime I come in the front door, because it is a habit.

Once i put my mask on, it stays on until it comes off and goes in my UVC decontamination cabinet.
tysker
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
FlyRod said:

Everyone in Asia, where mask wearing is ubiquitous, cases are few/low, and life is returning to normal, is reading this thread and shaking their heads.

Or maybe Asian countries constantly deal with similar coronaviruses and have a different natural immunity level or greater amounts of memory T cells. Also masks are more common generally because covering your face is culturally acceptable (e.g covering your mouth/face when laughing). Or masks were already ubiquitous because high pollution levels like in the case of Thailand.
https://fpif.org/how-thailand-contained-covid-19/
Quote:

On the question of face masks, Thais did not wait for the public health authorities to tell them to wear them. They were smart to have ignored the early, foolish World Health Organization advisory discouraging people from wearing masks.

Indeed, even before the pandemic, they had already been using face masks in great numbers owing to Bangkok's high levels of air pollution, which had breached the critical limit several times in 2019. When fears of infection escalated in early January, mask wear rose to some 90 percent. Despite the WHO's ill-advised advisory, mask wear was about 99 percent by mid-March, according to my informal monitoring from riding the subway and light rail system
revvie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
eric76 caught it while wearing N95 mask. Check his posts
tysker
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sisyphus said:

Quote:

Dont tell us, tell the people wearing a mask while alone walking their dog alone. Tell the people wearing masks on the beach. Tell the people wearing a mask while driving their car.

If you're in an area where the virus is airborne, it will collect on the outer surface of the mask as you breathe in. So masks don't protect you well if you're touching them often to put them on and off. That's why people leave them on and they are smart to do so.

I don't understand why that would bother you.
Doesn't bother me but its counter to the science I have read about transmission and counter to the logic behind social distancing. Again very few people in the media or the news is wearing a mask even when reporting from public spaces. I assume you think they should be.
Page 1 of 2
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.