TXAG 05 said:
aTmAg said:
This thread has me thinking....
Why are there so few great football movies, but there are a ton of great baseball movies? Football is heads and shoulders more popular than baseball in the US.
One theory: It's easy to fake an actor being good at baseball. It's completely believable that Kevin Costner, Robert Redford, or Gina Davis could be good at baseball. It is damn hard to fake an actor being good at football. When you see a supposedly NFL quality football team in a movie, it looks like A&M could crush them. So you have to really suspend disbelief.
I think a sport that suffers this problem even more is soccer. Can you imagine a movie about Messi? Nobody else can do what he does/did. They would have to show real footage and then somehow stick the actors head on top of Messi's. It would look ridiculous. Especially if they show early footage that is all blurry. I cannot think of a single decent soccer movie off the top of my head.
A movie about soccer would be worse than actually watching soccer.
I was the same way about soccer until my kids played and I was asked to coach one of them. There's a lot more to it then what meets the eye.
But I cannot imagine a soccer movie ever being good. Maybe a true story about some player in a war torn area who somehow plays for his national team or something. But the soccer itself would be a side note, not the main story.
If you knew much about soccer, you would know that every time they show actors on a soccer team, they are laughably bad when they play. And the show pretends they are amazing. It's hilarious.
To do a biopic about somebody like Messi would probably require them to generate all the soccer scenes with CGI. That would be atrocious.