PabloSerna said:
No I don't. As a Eucharistic Minister, I have never been instructed by a priest or bishop to ever do such a thing. Why then would I do so on my own accord? However, I would obey if told so to be clear.
Thanks Zobel for the EWTN links, I like others who have closely followed this over the years are well familiar with that part of the history debated here in the USA. There is more however and you will need to get those links added in if you want to tell the full truth.
In a nutshell, the USCCB, felt compelled to do something, what they did not know, but they agreed to get together and draft a statement. You can imagine when all the bishops get together there is going to be a difference of opinion on how what pastoral guidance should be for everyone. To be clear, no bishop is in favor of abortion in the way some Catholic politicians have voted.
The issue is how to deal with known pro-abortion Catholic politicians who present themselves for communion. In the end, what started out as a sure fire document to set rules for ALL dioceses in the US, it did not come out that way. In part because the Vatican gave a warning not to politicize the Eucharist and instead to emphasize the healing power of the sacrament for the weary. Also, because like 10 parents in a room discussing how to deal with Johnny - they each had a different take.
So again- Abp Coakly understands that when he states in most cases- but not all. Only he would know, because only a Bishop can make those decisions for his diocese.
Maybe something worth considering, both Pelosi and Biden were denied communion- Pelosi by her Bishop (important) and Biden by a priest while on the campaign trail in South Carolina - both received communion at the Vatican.
The takeaway here is that this a pastoral matter.
What is the sin of scandal?
Scandal involves leading others into sin, whether by word, deed, or omission, which causes them to sin or lose faith. This concept is deeply rooted in Scripture and Church teaching.
Scandal, in Catholic theology, is any behavior or attitude that might lead others to sin. It's not just about personal sinfulness, but about influencing others to fall away from God's path.
Jesus strongly warns against scandal. In Matthew 18:6-7, He says, "Whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him to have a great millstone fastened around his neck and to be drowned in the depth of the sea."
Types of Scandal:
- **Direct Scandal**: When someone deliberately acts in a way intended to lead another into sin.
- **Indirect Scandal**: When one's actions are not intended to lead others into sin but do so nonetheless due to carelessness or negligence.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC 2284-2287) emphasizes the grave responsibility individuals have to avoid scandal, especially those in positions of authority or with influential public roles.
Scandal can have wide-ranging effects, damaging the faith of individuals or communities and leading to moral or spiritual harm.
Ultimately, the sin of scandal is a reminder of our call to be witnesses to Christ, helping others grow in holiness rather than leading them away from God.
