Karmelo Anthony murder trial

604,278 Views | 4365 Replies | Last: 13 days ago by Reginald Cousins
fc2112
How long do you want to ignore this user?
fc2112 said:

P.H. Dexippus said:

Highway6 said:

If he gets more than 20 years I will be shocked

I'll take the over. A jury that quick to convict? Probably more than one are aware of how parole impacts length of sentence. My WAG is 35-45 years.

I thought a lighter sentence was possible since he was so young.

But coming back so fast? I'll go with 40 years.


Not a bad guess at all.
MattAg84
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Rex Racer said:

TexasAggie81 said:

FrioAg 00 said:

It's just so sad how many innocent kids are being born into this culture and never have a chance in hell at escaping it.

Yes, at some point they all become responsible for themselves and what they perpetuate, but they don't start out this way. It's engrained from the first day though.

I just don't know where it goes. What TF do we do with this subculture that is just completely valueless and lost.


The "culture" isn't progressing. It's regressing. Despite the advantages offered and taken, beginning with LBJ, there is seemingly little overall progress … save and except those who smartly changed their mindset, actions, and choices.

I would argue that beginning with LBJ was the beginning of this culture we have now.

Yeah LBJ wasn't offering "progression". He was selling the black leaders a trade from plantation to welfare slavery and they gladly took it. And here we are.
AgBQ-00
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Honest question...could any of you leave your kid to hear the sentencing on their own and not be in the courtroom with them?
God loves you so much He'll meet you where you are. He also loves you too much to allow to stay where you are.

We sing Hallelujah! The Lamb has overcome!
TheRatt87
How long do you want to ignore this user?
FrioAg 00 said:

It's just so sad how many innocent kids are being born into this culture and never have a chance in hell at escaping it.

Yes, at some point they all become responsible for themselves and what they perpetuate, but they don't start out this way. It's engrained from the first day though.

I just don't know where it goes. What TF do we do with this subculture that is just completely valueless and lost.


The only way this subculture changes is thru internal action. "The Community" gets as fatigued as the rest of us, decides to start self-policing, and embarks on a crusade of vigilante justice to rid itself of the bad actors. The non-Community's only role will be to no bill and nullify juries of those prosecuted for taking out their own trash.

Until then, all we can do is continue to move away from and avoid any interactions with this subculture, as well as exercise our 2A rights to protect ourselves from this violent, valueless subset of society.
Kozmozag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
That will never happen, move away from blue cities or states.
FCBlitz
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DoitBest said:

Does anyone know what race KA was there to run?


He was their to ruin the white race.

There will be two narratives and only one will be tolerated.

Suppressed narrative. The angry, racist black youth killed a white youth in a confrontation the black youth totally was in control of. It's the classical case of a black individual with no conflict resolution skills.

The MSN narrative. There is a grey area where a white, muscular athlete imposed his presence on the black youth who was misunderstood as the conflict between the two youth escalated. The black community will falsely claim this is a clear case of white racists put away another young black man in prison. This young black man was angry because he is growing up in a society controlled by white racists and is not to blame for the killing of the white kid. Society is to be blamed ruining the black kids life.

The MSN will and others will allow the "Black kid is innocent" conversation to be the one discussed. The discussion that the racist, black kid killed the white kid will never be discussed. Thus validating the idea that young black youths are not responsible for their actions.
FCBlitz
How long do you want to ignore this user?
On 740, did I hear KA could get out in 17.5 years? Surely, that is not correct?
Got a Natty!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
His two lawyers cost a bundle. So a lot of it went there.
AgBQ-00
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
it has been discussed in the thread. Theoretically it could happen. But from those who would know there is a next to 0% chance it does happen.
God loves you so much He'll meet you where you are. He also loves you too much to allow to stay where you are.

We sing Hallelujah! The Lamb has overcome!
Scriffer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Correct by the law itself, but several on here have mentioned that it's extraordinarily rare for a violent offender of this level to get out on their first try.
Got a Natty!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
That is correct.
1/2 of his sentenced served and he will be eligible for parole.
Got a Natty!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
MattAg84 said:

Rex Racer said:

TexasAggie81 said:

FrioAg 00 said:

It's just so sad how many innocent kids are being born into this culture and never have a chance in hell at escaping it.

Yes, at some point they all become responsible for themselves and what they perpetuate, but they don't start out this way. It's engrained from the first day though.

I just don't know where it goes. What TF do we do with this subculture that is just completely valueless and lost.


The "culture" isn't progressing. It's regressing. Despite the advantages offered and taken, beginning with LBJ, there is seemingly little overall progress … save and except those who smartly changed their mindset, actions, and choices.

I would argue that beginning with LBJ was the beginning of this culture we have now.

Yeah LBJ wasn't offering "progression". He was selling the black leaders a trade from plantation to welfare slavery and they gladly took it. And here we are.


Both of those posts are right. And that is why IMO LBJ is the worst president we have ever had. What he did is still reverberating today and will for generations to come.
one safe place
How long do you want to ignore this user?
91AggieLawyer said:


By that standard, only the death penalty would suffice. And that would be the case in EVERY murder trial.



Works for me.
BMX Bandit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
what LBJ did pales in comparison to what democrats have done since then.
Got a Natty!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I ardently disagree. LBJ set the table for what is happening now. And the welfare system so that the Democratic Party will always be a force we have to deal with.

LBJ is the bedrock of our current problems.
BMX Bandit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
he set the table, then democrats the next 50 years have piled it higher and higher and higher. he gave them the football, and they have run with that like forrest gump nonstop.

this is not a defense of LBJ. far from it. this is telling you that as bad as LBJ was for the black community, "modern" democrats have exacerbated that tenfold.
Law-Apt_3G
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Got a Natty! said:

I ardently disagree. LBJ set the table for what is happening now. And the welfare system so that the Democratic Party will always be a force we have to deal with.

LBJ is the bedrock of our current problems.


Kennedy's immigration policies
agent-maroon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Eligibility is necessary but not sufficient to be paroled. I knew a woman the same age as KA who was sentenced to life as an accomplice to a double homicide in Oklahoma and was eligible for parole for maybe the last 20 years before she was released at age 65. Not an apples to apples comparison, but it should not be assumed that they will parole him on the first try or that they will ever parole him.
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
Hank the Grifter
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Got a Natty! said:

I ardently disagree. LBJ set the table for what is happening now. And the welfare system so that the Democratic Party will always be a force we have to deal with.

LBJ is the bedrock of our current problems.

"I'll have those <n-words> voting Democrat for the next 50 years."
He's been more successful than I think even he could have imagined. Though he got a major assist from Obama nearly 20 years ago.
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
So his dad didn't even show up as a witness in his sentencing?

Wow. Im super shocked.
GaryClare
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AgBQ-00 said:

Honest question...could any of you leave your kid to hear the sentencing on their own and not be in the courtroom with them?

I do not understand that decision at all. But as I reflect on this whole situation, it is hard to judge both families on any of their actions. It is unimaginable what both families have been through mentally and emotionally the past year and you wonder if either of them could be at their best relative to decisions.

But what strikes me as really strange, or perhaps telling, is I would have thought KA's parents would have the decency to look over at the Metcalf's and publicly apologize. I wouldn't have expected to be forgiven by the Metcalf's. But could they have at least said, "I am sorry"? I just can't help but think that would have gone a long way.

In a sense that shows what underlies this whole story with the Anthony's. Their son is still the victim. He literally killed a person and it appears they still think they are the victims. And that disposition is a big part of why KA is in this situation right now and meeting these consequences.
Mort Rainey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
FCBlitz said:

On 740, did I hear KA could get out in 17.5 years? Surely, that is not correct?


Technically yes, but by far the most likely outcome is he isn't out before 25 years. Even that is only if he changes who he is in prison. If he keeps the same outlook and attitude he does now, he'll probably end up serving all 35.


Too lenient either way. To me this easily fit the case of lock the door and throw away the key for life
Stupe
How long do you want to ignore this user?
S
FCBlitz said:

DoitBest said:

Does anyone know what race KA was there to run?


He was their to ruin the white race.

There will be two narratives and only one will be tolerated.

Suppressed narrative. The angry, racist black youth killed a white youth in a confrontation the black youth totally was in control of. It's the classical case of a black individual with no conflict resolution skills.

The MSN narrative. There is a grey area where a white, muscular athlete imposed his presence on the black youth who was misunderstood as the conflict between the two youth escalated. The black community will falsely claim this is a clear case of white racists put away another young black man in prison. This young black man was angry because he is growing up in a society controlled by white racists and is not to blame for the killing of the white kid. Society is to be blamed ruining the black kids life.

The MSN will and others will allow the "Black kid is innocent" conversation to be the one discussed. The discussion that the racist, black kid killed the white kid will never be discussed. Thus validating the idea that young black youths are not responsible for their actions.

Oh, brother.

Yeah. He showed up at a track meet thinking "I'm going to ruin the white race. And I'm going to do it by going to another team's tent, not leaving, and killing someone. That will be the end of whitey."


Give me a break with the hyperbole.
Wildmen03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
GaryClare said:


But what strikes me as really strange, or perhaps telling, is I would have thought KA's parents would have the decency to look over at the Metcalf's and publicly apologize. I wouldn't have expected to be forgiven by the Metcalf's. But could they have at least said, "I am sorry"? I just can't help but think that would have gone a long way.

Apology admits guilt, and I'm sure they still think their son is innocent.
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The black response to this is sickening. That culture, created by the left, needs a complete overhaul.
Rattler12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GaryClare said:

AgBQ-00 said:

Honest question...could any of you leave your kid to hear the sentencing on their own and not be in the courtroom with them?

I do not understand that decision at all. But as I reflect on this whole situation, it is hard to judge both families on any of their actions. It is unimaginable what both families have been through mentally and emotionally the past year and you wonder if either of them could be at their best relative to decisions.

But what strikes me as really strange, or perhaps telling, is I would have thought KA's parents would have the decency to look over at the Metcalf's and publicly apologize. I wouldn't have expected to be forgiven by the Metcalf's. But could they have at least said, "I am sorry"? I just can't help but think that would have gone a long way.

In a sense that shows what underlies this whole story with the Anthony's. Their son is still the victim. He literally killed a person and it appears they still think they are the victims. And that disposition is a big part of why KA is in this situation right now and meeting these consequences.

The nut does not fall far from the tree........
Owlagdad
How long do you want to ignore this user?
So now if a kid comes uninvited to your tent at a track meet, yall ought to just clear out and let him be.
So now high school kids need 100% supervision at track meets? Lol, two coaches, one watching the shot put and one watching pole vault and two mile.
Lots of other things were lost because of this- and whose dang fault is that?
BMX Bandit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Wildmen03 said:

GaryClare said:


But what strikes me as really strange, or perhaps telling, is I would have thought KA's parents would have the decency to look over at the Metcalf's and publicly apologize. I wouldn't have expected to be forgiven by the Metcalf's. But could they have at least said, "I am sorry"? I just can't help but think that would have gone a long way.

Apology admits guilt, and I'm sure they still think their son is innocent.

disagree.

"I am so sorry Karmelo killed your son. This is a horrible tragedy and I hope you can one day find peace, I will pray for Austin and your family always"


no admission of guilt, can still maintain their spurious claim to self-defense.


its what a decent person would have at least said. but these are not decent people
Mort Rainey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GaryClare said:

AgBQ-00 said:

Honest question...could any of you leave your kid to hear the sentencing on their own and not be in the courtroom with them?

I do not understand that decision at all. But as I reflect on this whole situation, it is hard to judge both families on any of their actions. It is unimaginable what both families have been through mentally and emotionally the past year and you wonder if either of them could be at their best relative to decisions.

But what strikes me as really strange, or perhaps telling, is I would have thought KA's parents would have the decency to look over at the Metcalf's and publicly apologize. I wouldn't have expected to be forgiven by the Metcalf's. But could they have at least said, "I am sorry"? I just can't help but think that would have gone a long way.

In a sense that shows what underlies this whole story with the Anthony's. Their son is still the victim. He literally killed a person and it appears they still think they are the victims. And that disposition is a big part of why KA is in this situation right now and meeting these consequences.


These are people who have lived their whole life with a victim mentality. And that parenting is what got their kid locked up.

This wasn't a good kid by any stretch of the imagination. And the behavior of his parents and community over the past year gives us a pretty good idea of how he was raised to get here.
GaryClare
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Mort Rainey said:

FCBlitz said:

On 740, did I hear KA could get out in 17.5 years? Surely, that is not correct?


Technically yes, but by far the most likely outcome is he isn't out before 25 years. Even that is only if he changes who he is in prison. If he keeps the same outlook and attitude he does now, he'll probably end up serving all 35.


Too lenient either way. To me this easily fit the case of lock the door and throw away the key for life

I share your disposition. But I think what the jury considered is that he was 17 at the time. If he would have been in his upper 20's or older, I think he might have gotten the key thrown away.

His life is ruined regardless of the sentence. If everything goes perfect he's not getting out until he is an older adult. He won't get able to get a good job, he won't have his prime earning years to build a financial base, he likely will never be in a position to have a family, a home or a decent life - even after he gets out.

I understand Metcalf gets none of these considerations. But as humans so completely dependent of God's grace, it crosses my mind that it might be good that he was given some grace. As much I as I was hoping for 75 years, it is hard to say the jury did not make a wise decision.
Got a Natty!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
agent-maroon said:

Eligibility is necessary but not sufficient to be paroled. I knew a woman the same age as KA who was sentenced to life as an accomplice to a double homicide in Oklahoma and was eligible for parole for maybe the last 20 years before she was released at age 65. Not an apples to apples comparison, but it should not be assumed that they will parole him on the first try or that they will ever parole him.

Our parole system may be the most FU system in TX. And I have numorous cases I tried as proof. So no one knows what will happen in the future. The ones who say KA has zero chance of being paroled his first time up do not have the experiences I have with that system. They follow the law about like I do when driving on the open roads of west Texas.

The only offenders I am confident will spend 80%+ of their sentence in prison are DWIs and sexual assaults with a child as a victim.

Two defendants I still keep an eye on through the TDCJ offender website were convicted of murder. And they are still in prison. One had 2 murders and his life sentences were stacked. And he is the most dangerous person I have ever seen in a courtroom. Thank God he is still in prison and has been since 1984. The other killed his 4 year old son and has a life sentence. Has been in prison since 2021. So the parole system does work at times.
4stringAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
2000AgPhD said:

TexasAggie81 said:

FrioAg 00 said:

It's just so sad how many innocent kids are being born into this culture and never have a chance in hell at escaping it.

Yes, at some point they all become responsible for themselves and what they perpetuate, but they don't start out this way. It's engrained from the first day though.

I just don't know where it goes. What TF do we do with this subculture that is just completely valueless and lost.


The "culture" isn't progressing. It's regressing. Despite the advantages offered and taken, beginning with LBJ, there is seemingly little overall progress … save and except those who smartly changed their mindset, actions, and choices.

I think the argument can be fairly made that LBJ destroyed black society in the United States.

That was the likely goal. I think there's a racist quote about him saying he'd have all these blacks voting Democrat forever, only he didn't use "blacks".
Rattler12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GaryClare said:

Mort Rainey said:

FCBlitz said:

On 740, did I hear KA could get out in 17.5 years? Surely, that is not correct?


Technically yes, but by far the most likely outcome is he isn't out before 25 years. Even that is only if he changes who he is in prison. If he keeps the same outlook and attitude he does now, he'll probably end up serving all 35.


Too lenient either way. To me this easily fit the case of lock the door and throw away the key for life

I share your disposition. But I think what the jury considered is that he was 17 at the time. If he would have been in his upper 20's or older, I think he might have gotten the key thrown away.

His life is ruined regardless of the sentence. If everything goes perfect he's not getting out until he is an older adult. He won't get able to get a good job, he won't have his prime earning years to build a financial base, he likely will never be in a position to have a family, a home or a decent life - even after he gets out.

I understand Metcalf gets none of these considerations. But as humans so completely dependent of God's grace, it crosses my mind that it might be good that he was given some grace. As much I as I was hoping for 75 years, it is hard to say the jury did not make a wise decision.

What are the odds of this scenario happening for him even if he had not committed the crime?
Rex Racer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
GaryClare said:

Mort Rainey said:

FCBlitz said:

On 740, did I hear KA could get out in 17.5 years? Surely, that is not correct?


Technically yes, but by far the most likely outcome is he isn't out before 25 years. Even that is only if he changes who he is in prison. If he keeps the same outlook and attitude he does now, he'll probably end up serving all 35.


Too lenient either way. To me this easily fit the case of lock the door and throw away the key for life

I share your disposition. But I think what the jury considered is that he was 17 at the time. If he would have been in his upper 20's or older, I think he might have gotten the key thrown away.

His life is ruined regardless of the sentence. If everything goes perfect he's not getting out until he is an older adult. He won't get able to get a good job, he won't have his prime earning years to build a financial base, he likely will never be in a position to have a family, a home or a decent life - even after he gets out.

I understand Metcalf gets none of these considerations. But as humans so completely dependent of God's grace, it crosses my mind that it might be good that he was given some grace. As much I as I was hoping for 75 years, it is hard to say the jury did not make a wise decision.

If the kid is smart (yeah, I know), he will take the opportunity to get a Law degree on the tax payer's dime, and when he gets out, he could practice law and make himself some darn good money and have a half decent life. Now, will he do that? Naw.
FTAG 2000
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
FCBlitz said:

On 740, did I hear KA could get out in 17.5 years? Surely, that is not correct?


Theoretically but zero chance it happens.
First Page Last Page
Page 109 of 125
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.