H-1B workers flew to India to renew U.S. visas. Now they're stuck.

4,412 Views | 71 Replies | Last: 1 day ago by Jack Squat 83
infinity ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Trump's coup on the H1Bs.

So what happened is that earlier, H1Bs to get renewed could go to Mexico and do a re-entry. Then Trump say nooooo you have to go back to your own countries. So the H1B Indians went to India and they booked their interview slots. Then Trump canceled all the slots citing social media vetting and moved all their slots to June, July, Sept of 2026.

So what happens now? Here is my guess.

These H1Bs cannot enter the US again until they get approved again which will be after their mid-2026 slots. Those may get moved again, no guarantees. Some have fancy $2-3M houses in the Bay Area, they cannot go back to which may get foreclosed on. Kids have school they cannot go back to. Fancy Tesla cars may get impounded. The chatter is that they can work remotely from India, but I think that is not legally possible as H1B means they have to live withing 50 miles of their work location, not 6000 miles away. Maybe they can transfer to an India office for legality purposes? If not, then it is unlikely that in these conditions, employers are going to keep them in the team for 8-10 months, they are likely to get fired. So if that happens, then they have no H1B so their Sept 2026 slot also vanishes. They are stuck in India with a lot of immovable property in the US.

Trump may give them some relief in some time but he would have struck enough terror in their hearts that they are probably looking to move back to India. It would be better for them than to risk this up and down uncertain life in the US as their kids get older and into middle school when it gets harder to just move back.

A difficult situation no doubt. I am sure the Dems are itching to help them out.

H-1B workers flew to India to renew U.S. visas. Now they're stuck.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2025/12/19/india-h1b-visas-skilled-workers-trump/
Today at 9:48 a.m. EST
Quote:

H-1B holders who returned to India this month to renew their visas had consular appointments canceled, stranding them far from their homes and jobs, lawyers said.


Quote:

By Pranshu Verma and Supriya Kumar

NEW DELHI Indian H-1B visa holders who traveled back to India this month to renew their American work permits are now stranded far from home after their appointments were abruptly canceled by U.S. consular offices and rescheduled for months later, according to three immigration lawyers who specialize in H-1B cases.

Hundreds, possibly thousands, of high-skilled workers had appointments canceled between Dec. 15 and 26, the lawyers said, a period many H-1B holders target for renewal since it coincides with the U.S. holiday season. In emails viewed by The Washington Post, the State Department told visa holders their interviews were being delayed after the implementation of the Trump administration's new social media vetting policy, "to ensure that no applicants … pose a threat to U.S. national security or public safety."


Quote:

The H-1B immigration program which has allowed hundreds of thousands of foreign workers with specialized skills to live and work in the United States for up to six years has been a source of controversy during Trump's second term. Some of his most influential far-right backers have called for the program to be eliminated, arguing it takes jobs from U.S. citizens. But tech executives in Silicon Valley have pushed back, saying H-1B workers are vital for their industry.

Tech Execs of SV ---> Biggest crooks.

Quote:

The sudden cancellations have upended lives, the lawyers said, leaving workers on expired visas fearful of losing their jobs. Emily Neumann, a partner at the Houston-based immigration firm Reddy Neumann Brown PC, said she had at least 100 clients stranded in India. Veena Vijay Ananth, an immigration attorney in India, and Charles Kuck, who practices immigration law in Atlanta, said they each had more than a dozen similar cases.


Quote:

Many of those affected are tech workers in their 30s and 40s, the lawyers said, who have lived in the United States for years. They are now scrambling to find alternative work arrangements with their U.S. companies. Some who traveled to India with their kids must now decide whether to keep them out of school or send them home alone; others are separated from their families entirely.


Quote:

'They're devastated'
India has long been the biggest beneficiary of the H-1B program, accounting for 71 percent of visa holders,
according to an April 2025 report from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). As of September, Amazon, Meta and Microsoft were the three largest sponsors of H-1B workers, the USCIS data shows. Amazon founder Jeff Bezos owns The Washington Post.

In July, the State Department announced that H-1B holders, and their dependents on H4 visas, would no longer be able to renew their documents remotely or in a third country as of Sept. 2 requiring them to return to their home countries to complete the process. On Sept. 19, Trump signed a proclamation imposing a $100,000 payment for new H-1B applications.


On Dec. 3, the Trump administration announced "expanded screening and vetting" procedures for H-1B and H4 dependent visa holders, including a review of their online presence. "Every visa adjudication is a national security decision," the State Department said. "A U.S. visa is a privilege, not a right."
In the following days, H-1B visa holders with renewal appointments in mid-to-late December started receiving emails from the State Department saying that "operational constraints" had forced consulates to reduce the number of appointments they could take each day, according to messages reviewed by The Post.

The bulk of the renewal appointments are being rescheduled between March and June, the three lawyers said; one applicant was given a makeup date in 2027
. Ananth said there's very little guidance she can give to her heartsick clients.
"They're devastated," she said.

Quote:

'What do I do?'
An Indian man who lives in the Detroit suburbs and works as an engineer said he flew back to India in early December for a wedding and had consular appointments set up for Dec. 17 and 23 to renew his H-1B visa, which is now expired. He spoke to The Post on the condition of anonymity for fear of jeopardizing his immigration status.


On Dec. 8, he got a series of emails from the State Department saying his consular appointment had been canceled and rescheduled for July 2 more than six months away. "I was like 'OK, What do I do?'" he recalled. The engineer has a wife in the United States on her own H-1B visa and a 5-year-old son. On Friday, he said, he was able to secure an expedited appointment after his company submitted documentation showing several of the projects he's working on are ramping up next year.

But he's still apprehensive: "I'm hoping they honor it and don't just bump it out further," he said. Lawyers said such exemptions are rare.

The changes to the H-1B program are misguided, the engineer said, because foreign workers help power many leading American companies (HA HA HA HA). He cited a recent job search he oversaw, where he said it would have been easier to hire a U.S. citizen for a technical role, but the lion's share of candidates with the requisite engineering and work experience were H-1B holders.
"If you see an overnight exodus of people working on H-1B's, I promise you, a lot of companies are going to fall flat," he said.


Unable to predict when employees will return, U.S. tech executives are scrambling to come up with accommodations and work arounds, said a person familiar with the issue.


This is the final kick.
Quote:

Since Trump returned to office, Neumann has advised her clients to avoid foreign travel given the uncertainty surrounding the H-1B program. After the spate of canceled appointments, she said, a new worry has emerged.
If H-1B holders are outside the country when their visa expires, she said, their company cannot file for an extension and will likely have to start the visa application from scratch and risk incurring the new $100,000 fee.
"No company is paying that," she said.


GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

are now stranded far from home


Sounds like they're stranded back at home to me
deddog
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

As of September, Amazon, Meta and Microsoft were the three largest sponsors of H-1B workers

This is the real problem.
Instead of going after individuals, Trump needs to get after the companies doing this.

Sucks for people stuck, with family back in the US.
torrid
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This has always been an issue for H-1Bs. They fly home for one reason or another, but then get stuck there. I have never known one to not eventually get back in the country, nor to be denied a green card.
oh no
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
so... they are back home and their sponsoring companies will either have to let them work remotely or... hire an American or something? this sounds awful. like literally hitler. do we riot?
Txhuntr
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Oh no! We'll have to backfill these jobs with Americans
BigRobSA
How long do you want to ignore this user?
deddog said:

Quote:

As of September, Amazon, Meta and Microsoft were the three largest sponsors of H-1B workers

This is the real problem.
Instead of going after individuals, Trump needs to get after the companies doing this.

Porque no los dos?
aggiehawg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Squadron7
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I hope they are doing this to "refugees" that continue to vacation in their home countries.
BusterAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I had a friend in graduate school that popped porches during the dotcom boom when he was in undergrad. He was making 10% to 20% of the value of the car on repossessing them.

Wonder if this problem is bad enough to look into that again.......
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MouthBQ98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I don't think we should be unreasonable to those who have diligently followed the lawful process in the past and met all the conditions as agreed to at the time, but I don't have a problem with narrowing or curtailing the process into the future with fair notice.
infinity ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
deddog said:

Quote:

As of September, Amazon, Meta and Microsoft were the three largest sponsors of H-1B workers

This is the real problem.
Instead of going after individuals, Trump needs to get after the companies doing this.

Sucks for people stuck, with family back in the US.


I agree with you but I think Trump is sending Amazon/Meta a message. He is giving them some months to get their affairs in order before the hammer falls on them. Let's be honest, with the number of H1Bs working there, those companies will collapse if he throws them all out overnight. And impact the stock market. Trump does not want that.

I got a few interview calls this week. One clearly stated no sponsorship, so they hire only US citizens.

Malibu
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I can feel sympathy for the plight of these folks as individuals. They made a life here, followed the process, and got screwed. There should have been more humanity in a process that ended this cleanly and not stranding people with no agency into a nightmare. That doesn't mean backfilling foreign labor for high skilled US jobs is a good policy. We could have both ended the policy and fairly allowed for people to make responsible plans for their future knowing it would sunset rather than marooning them away from their family and property.
Queso1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The people of the United States owe nothing to the world.
oh no
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Malibu said:

There should have been more humanity in a process that ended this cleanly and not stranding people with no agency into a nightmare.

humanity? stranding them into a nightmare? at home? sounds like their interviews were pushed back a few months.
Malibu
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yes...they flew back to their native country, where they no longer live, for a bureaucratic process, and now have to stay there several more months. That seems pretty life disruptive and awful for the people caught up in that, and could have been done more thoughtfully, even if its the right policy in the long run.
infinity ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
oh no said:

Malibu said:

There should have been more humanity in a process that ended this cleanly and not stranding people with no agency into a nightmare.

humanity? stranding them into a nightmare? at home? sounds like their interviews were pushed back a few months.


Lots of downstream impacts. I am sure Trump and/or team is orchestrating it that way.
Quote:

If H-1B holders are outside the country when their visa expires, she said, their company cannot file for an extension and will likely have to start the visa application from scratch and risk incurring the new $100,000 fee.

"No company is paying that," she said.



So all they do is keep pushing back the interview date on one pretext or other.
oh no
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Malibu said:

I can feel sympathy for the plight of these folks as individuals. They made a life here, followed the process, and got screwed. There should have been more humanity in a process that ended this cleanly and not stranding people with no agency into a nightmare. That doesn't mean backfilling foreign labor for high skilled US jobs is a good policy. We could have both ended the policy and fairly allowed for people to make responsible plans for their future knowing it would sunset rather than marooning them away from their family and property.

The process IS that their visas must be renewed. So they didn't get screwed. The just didn't get picked up for another season. Now they can take their experience learned here and can contribute in a beneficial way to their country.

If they want permanent residency, they need something other than an H-1B.

Assuming your visa renewal was automatic was and is a big problem of the problem.

Best Trump here.
Malibu
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I get liking this policy. The not even acknowledging that it indeed sucks a lot for individuals caught up in this is where I just shake my head and wonder if y'all have Jesus in your lives.
infinity ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
flown-the-coop said:

Malibu said:

I can feel sympathy for the plight of these folks as individuals. They made a life here, followed the process, and got screwed. There should have been more humanity in a process that ended this cleanly and not stranding people with no agency into a nightmare. That doesn't mean backfilling foreign labor for high skilled US jobs is a good policy. We could have both ended the policy and fairly allowed for people to make responsible plans for their future knowing it would sunset rather than marooning them away from their family and property.

The process IS that their visas must be renewed. So they didn't get screwed. The just didn't get picked up for another season. Now they can take their experience learned here and can contribute in a beneficial way to their country.

If they want permanent residency, they need something other than an H-1B.

Assuming your visa renewal was automatic was and is a big problem of the problem.

Best Trump here.


Hey you are right. I hadn't thought of it that way.

It is not anyone's fault if they bought expensive houses and cars on a TEMPORARY work visa. They should have waited until they got a green card which is more permanent.

I can foresee a housing market crash though with many H1Bs in places like SF, Seattle, Dallas, Atlanta forcing to flee. Prices will crash but make housing more affordable for Americans too.

Lots of impacts.
FCBlitz
How long do you want to ignore this user?
infinity ag said:

Trump's coup on the H1Bs.

So what happened is that earlier, H1Bs to get renewed could go to Mexico and do a re-entry. Then Trump say nooooo you have to go back to your own countries. So the H1B Indians went to India and they booked their interview slots. Then Trump canceled all the slots citing social media vetting and moved all their slots to June, July, Sept of 2026.

So what happens now? Here is my guess.

These H1Bs cannot enter the US again until they get approved again which will be after their mid-2026 slots. Those may get moved again, no guarantees. Some have fancy $2-3M houses in the Bay Area, they cannot go back to which may get foreclosed on. Kids have school they cannot go back to. Fancy Tesla cars may get impounded. The chatter is that they can work remotely from India, but I think that is not legally possible as H1B means they have to live withing 50 miles of their work location, not 6000 miles away. Maybe they can transfer to an India office for legality purposes? If not, then it is unlikely that in these conditions, employers are going to keep them in the team for 8-10 months, they are likely to get fired. So if that happens, then they have no H1B so their Sept 2026 slot also vanishes. They are stuck in India with a lot of immovable property in the US.

Trump may give them some relief in some time but he would have struck enough terror in their hearts that they are probably looking to move back to India. It would be better for them than to risk this up and down uncertain life in the US as their kids get older and into middle school when it gets harder to just move back.

A difficult situation no doubt. I am sure the Dems are itching to help them out.

H-1B workers flew to India to renew U.S. visas. Now they're stuck.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2025/12/19/india-h1b-visas-skilled-workers-trump/
Today at 9:48 a.m. EST
Quote:

H-1B holders who returned to India this month to renew their visas had consular appointments canceled, stranding them far from their homes and jobs, lawyers said.


Quote:

By Pranshu Verma and Supriya Kumar

NEW DELHI Indian H-1B visa holders who traveled back to India this month to renew their American work permits are now stranded far from home after their appointments were abruptly canceled by U.S. consular offices and rescheduled for months later, according to three immigration lawyers who specialize in H-1B cases.

Hundreds, possibly thousands, of high-skilled workers had appointments canceled between Dec. 15 and 26, the lawyers said, a period many H-1B holders target for renewal since it coincides with the U.S. holiday season. In emails viewed by The Washington Post, the State Department told visa holders their interviews were being delayed after the implementation of the Trump administration's new social media vetting policy, "to ensure that no applicants … pose a threat to U.S. national security or public safety."


Quote:

The H-1B immigration program which has allowed hundreds of thousands of foreign workers with specialized skills to live and work in the United States for up to six years has been a source of controversy during Trump's second term. Some of his most influential far-right backers have called for the program to be eliminated, arguing it takes jobs from U.S. citizens. But tech executives in Silicon Valley have pushed back, saying H-1B workers are vital for their industry.

Tech Execs of SV ---> Biggest crooks.

Quote:

The sudden cancellations have upended lives, the lawyers said, leaving workers on expired visas fearful of losing their jobs. Emily Neumann, a partner at the Houston-based immigration firm Reddy Neumann Brown PC, said she had at least 100 clients stranded in India. Veena Vijay Ananth, an immigration attorney in India, and Charles Kuck, who practices immigration law in Atlanta, said they each had more than a dozen similar cases.


Quote:

Many of those affected are tech workers in their 30s and 40s, the lawyers said, who have lived in the United States for years. They are now scrambling to find alternative work arrangements with their U.S. companies. Some who traveled to India with their kids must now decide whether to keep them out of school or send them home alone; others are separated from their families entirely.


Quote:

'They're devastated'
India has long been the biggest beneficiary of the H-1B program, accounting for 71 percent of visa holders,
according to an April 2025 report from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). As of September, Amazon, Meta and Microsoft were the three largest sponsors of H-1B workers, the USCIS data shows. Amazon founder Jeff Bezos owns The Washington Post.

In July, the State Department announced that H-1B holders, and their dependents on H4 visas, would no longer be able to renew their documents remotely or in a third country as of Sept. 2 requiring them to return to their home countries to complete the process. On Sept. 19, Trump signed a proclamation imposing a $100,000 payment for new H-1B applications.


On Dec. 3, the Trump administration announced "expanded screening and vetting" procedures for H-1B and H4 dependent visa holders, including a review of their online presence. "Every visa adjudication is a national security decision," the State Department said. "A U.S. visa is a privilege, not a right."
In the following days, H-1B visa holders with renewal appointments in mid-to-late December started receiving emails from the State Department saying that "operational constraints" had forced consulates to reduce the number of appointments they could take each day, according to messages reviewed by The Post.

The bulk of the renewal appointments are being rescheduled between March and June, the three lawyers said; one applicant was given a makeup date in 2027
. Ananth said there's very little guidance she can give to her heartsick clients.
"They're devastated," she said.

Quote:

'What do I do?'
An Indian man who lives in the Detroit suburbs and works as an engineer said he flew back to India in early December for a wedding and had consular appointments set up for Dec. 17 and 23 to renew his H-1B visa, which is now expired. He spoke to The Post on the condition of anonymity for fear of jeopardizing his immigration status.


On Dec. 8, he got a series of emails from the State Department saying his consular appointment had been canceled and rescheduled for July 2 more than six months away. "I was like 'OK, What do I do?'" he recalled. The engineer has a wife in the United States on her own H-1B visa and a 5-year-old son. On Friday, he said, he was able to secure an expedited appointment after his company submitted documentation showing several of the projects he's working on are ramping up next year.

But he's still apprehensive: "I'm hoping they honor it and don't just bump it out further," he said. Lawyers said such exemptions are rare.

The changes to the H-1B program are misguided, the engineer said, because foreign workers help power many leading American companies (HA HA HA HA). He cited a recent job search he oversaw, where he said it would have been easier to hire a U.S. citizen for a technical role, but the lion's share of candidates with the requisite engineering and work experience were H-1B holders.
"If you see an overnight exodus of people working on H-1B's, I promise you, a lot of companies are going to fall flat," he said.


Unable to predict when employees will return, U.S. tech executives are scrambling to come up with accommodations and work arounds, said a person familiar with the issue.


This is the final kick.
Quote:

Since Trump returned to office, Neumann has advised her clients to avoid foreign travel given the uncertainty surrounding the H-1B program. After the spate of canceled appointments, she said, a new worry has emerged.
If H-1B holders are outside the country when their visa expires, she said, their company cannot file for an extension and will likely have to start the visa application from scratch and risk incurring the new $100,000 fee.
"No company is paying that," she said.






Wow that was a lot of effort to pry a "IDGAF" out of me…..but "A" for effort given.
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
infinity ag said:

flown-the-coop said:

Malibu said:

I can feel sympathy for the plight of these folks as individuals. They made a life here, followed the process, and got screwed. There should have been more humanity in a process that ended this cleanly and not stranding people with no agency into a nightmare. That doesn't mean backfilling foreign labor for high skilled US jobs is a good policy. We could have both ended the policy and fairly allowed for people to make responsible plans for their future knowing it would sunset rather than marooning them away from their family and property.

The process IS that their visas must be renewed. So they didn't get screwed. The just didn't get picked up for another season. Now they can take their experience learned here and can contribute in a beneficial way to their country.

If they want permanent residency, they need something other than an H-1B.

Assuming your visa renewal was automatic was and is a big problem of the problem.

Best Trump here.


Hey you are right. I hadn't thought of it that way.

It is not anyone's fault if they bought expensive houses and cars on a TEMPORARY work visa. They should have waited until they got a green card which is more permanent.

I can foresee a housing market crash though with many H1Bs in places like SF, Seattle, Dallas, Atlanta forcing to flee. Prices will crash but make housing more affordable for Americans too.

Lots of impacts.

They can sell their house remotely and have their wares shipped to them.

I posted in another thread a while back but this happened to a friend of mine, H1-B from Jordan, who was told her visa may not be renewed. She planned accordingly and was indeed denied re-entry.

Even if you went to Mexico is was subject to review and could be denied.

There is literally nothing new here except if they are denied they are home instead of Ciudad Juarez.
oh no
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
if you aren't freaking out about the humanity of interviews being pushed back, then you must not have Jesus in your life.
Malibu
How long do you want to ignore this user?
That's a totally honest way of framing my thinking here. Between that and FTC's yea, you just sell your house from abroad and have someone ship your stuff back what's the big deal with that, just, well, y'all truly see the world very differently than me.
Cyprian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Damn, I'm assuming they went back to do more than getting a renewal, i helped someone out get one a long time ago, but we just hopped down to the border (Laredo), took about 4 hours and most of that was waiting around to pick the passport back up with the visa.
TAMUallen
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I was wondering why the air was smelling so much fresher!
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm praying an American citizen gets the job since this is... America. Is that Christ-like?
RyanAg08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Malibu said:

I can feel sympathy for the plight of these folks as individuals. They made a life here, followed the process, and got screwed. There should have been more humanity in a process that ended this cleanly and not stranding people with no agency into a nightmare. That doesn't mean backfilling foreign labor for high skilled US jobs is a good policy. We could have both ended the policy and fairly allowed for people to make responsible plans for their future knowing it would sunset rather than marooning them away from their family and property.


I think the true plight belongs to the Indians who live in the slums not the temporarily inconvenienced ones here who can buy expensive cars and send their kids to private schools.
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Logos Stick said:

I'm praying an American citizen gets the job since this is... America. Is that Christ-like?

Believe Mary, Joseph, Jesus and the rest of the Christ family were immigrants, no? I keep hearing that's why they were stuck in the manger for coloreds.
TAMUallen
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
flown-the-coop said:

Logos Stick said:

I'm praying an American citizen gets the job since this is... America. Is that Christ-like?

Believe Mary, Joseph, Jesus and the rest of the Christ family were immigrants, no? I keep hearing that's why they were stuck in the manger for coloreds.


Give unto the Amercians what belongs to the Amercians
FatZilla
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I work in the tech industry where we deal with staffing our projects like this all the time. Its 100% just cost driven why we hire and staff H1B on projects instead of America based resources (which we also have in spades). So its definitely not true that they are needed due to knowledge and not being able to find an American resource. A hypothetical example here is my America based resource costs my project lets say $125/hour while i can bring 4-5 offshore resources in for that same overall cost. Quality of the output rarely factors in on the front side where these projects get sold and staffed but i can 100% tell you i will give anything complicated to develop to my on shore resources before i fall back onto offshore and H1B lol
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
flown-the-coop said:

Logos Stick said:

I'm praying an American citizen gets the job since this is... America. Is that Christ-like?

Believe Mary, Joseph, Jesus and the rest of the Christ family were immigrants, no? I keep hearing that's why they were stuck in the manger for coloreds.


Nope. They went back to Bethlehem for the census per the decree by Augustus. Bethlehem was their ancestral homeland city. Every city they occupied in the Bible account was part of the same country Israel.
Rubicante
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
deddog said:

Quote:

As of September, Amazon, Meta and Microsoft were the three largest sponsors of H-1B workers

This is the real problem.
Instead of going after individuals, Trump needs to get after the companies doing this.

Sucks for people stuck, with family back in the US.


They never do, which is why illegal immigration continues to be a problem.

No one has ever stolen a job from an hard-working American. Jobs can only be given by illegal-loving employers.

Going all the way back to slavery, imagine how much different this country would look today without the great American weakness of the love of cheap labor.
Last Page
Page 1 of 3
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.