Ag with kids said:
K2-HMFIC said:
The de-sal plant was cancelled by the sport fishing lobby.
Too much industry drawing too much water.
But most importantly, not enough rainfall on the Nueces River watershed (Bracketville, Carrizo Springs, Tilden).
I do understand the concerns. They're going to dump the brine in the Bay, not in the Gulf, and there's concern that it will cause the water to get TOO salty in the Bay and kill off a lot of fish...
We've been in a drought down here for quite awhile...water restrictions for years. I live on the island so I just have a rock yard, but I do have a pool...
I'm pretty sure the city council voted to continue on with the desal plant with their last vote...
Part of the issue is the confusion over which desal plant we are talking about. There was a brackish water desal plant that would have discharged brine to Petronila Creek was killed largely by sport fishing interests who were confused about what the brine would actually be like relative to the already saline creek water.
Then there is the fully permitted CC inner harbor seawater desal plant that was planning to discharge to the CC channel that was killed initially by social justice issues and people confused about why constantly adding capacity and complexity to a plant design would cause the cost to go up. That one is back looking for a new design contractor now that the city council has voted to restart the process with a new contractor. But the status of the very large loan they received from TWDB for the plant is unclear at this point.
There is another port funded seawater desal plant that has not been fully permitted yet that plans to discharge their brine offshore in the gulf. I have questions about that one's durability to ride out a hurricane given its location, but it seems to be the least controversial and most likely to be approved without trouble.
People keep hearing details about one of these plants and conflating it with what is happening with another. Each of the plants has unresolved questions about their potential ecological impacts, but at some point Corpus is going to have to accept that either they start down the path on one or more of the plants right now, or they face losing major employers and having to make dramatic choices about who gets what little water they have left and what it will cost. For all those who think groundwater is the answer, keep in mind that pumping shallow groundwater in large quantities along the coast will almost certainly cause subsidence and will also impact ag viability in the area as well. Here is a map of what large scale groundwater pumping did for the Houston Galveston Area over the last century. Keep in mind that the contours are in meters, so it is showing 6-10 feet of subsidence in some areas. How would Houston's recent flooding be different with some of those areas 6-10' higher than they are today?