I was gonna post yesterday and in the end opted to refrain, as this ongoing pit disagreement hits home some. For many years I was an avowed and stanch opponent of Pits of any kind. I saw, and was part of, a fairly bad attack by what I would identify as a Pit while in school at A&M. It really jaded me.
Fast forward about 22 years I ended up, reluctantly with great trepidation while having a weak moment, rescuing a female Pit that was on deaths door. Tried to rehome her, tried to shelter her; no way no how. She has been the best dog, out of many and out all of all kinds of breeds, that I have ever had.
When rescuing her I took her to my sage and very good long time Vet. A fine doc, fine man, and great Aggie. Two things he mentioned that have always stuck with me. One being that in his 35 years experience, he found that Pits, in general, were people dogs and needed to be around people, they were not "back yard and forget" dogs that had much interest in some inherited trait like hunting or water dogs. The other was that it perplexed him that in the early part of his career he rarely saw Pit caused violence or attacks on other dogs. He didn't elaborate, but said something with the amount and type of Pits changed in the early 80's.
Anecdotally, and I find Gunny's post interesting and informative, I don't remember hearing about the abundance of Pit attacks, or even a lot about dog attacks, growing up in the 70's and early 80's. Why? Did we just not hear about people being mauled? Or was there a much lower instance? I don't know. Further, I have spent most of my life living and working out of the U.S. and one thing I picked up on is that in the countries I lived in, to include the 2 poorest countries in the Western Hemisphere. The stray and uncontrolled dog situation was much worse than seen in the U.S., and there were aplenty Pit's and Pit Mixes. Yet in those countries, and in others, one didn't hear about common dog attacks on people, at least not very frequently. One stark difference is that terrible and aggressive dog behavior in those countries was not tolerated. Good or bad, there was lots of summary justice handed out. There was also lots less for profit breeding and keeping of animals as adornments, for lack of a better word.
As time has passed I have grown to look at Pits in a much different light, but still with abounding caution. Like Gunny relates, I am much more inclined to believe that conditions and early formation, along with repetitive enforcement, has a lot more to do with how a dog behaves. Lotta backyard and apartment abandoned dogs in the U.S.. If I could clone my current, and she is getting older, Pit I would do so.