Pardon the interruption fellas.
Island life pros include no traffic, you are never far from where you need to go, good fishing, a nice golf course, good mexican food, good seafood and a modest choice of decently priced restaurants with good quality. The gulf breeze keeps us slightly cooler than the rest of the state. Average price for a home is $175k. Plus we have a municipal airport for your aviation hobby.
Cons involve living in a relatively low income demographic. We don't have any indian restuarants and the asian places are limited. This may have no importance to you, but I'm a huge foodie and it does factor in for me. Other than that I don't have anything to complain about.
If you want to live "in town" I would look at the historical district or there are a few streets in particular I like: Sherman, Cadduceus, Denver, and Woodrow. This area is centrally located just a couple blocks from the seawall. They were high and dry during Ike. Once you go west of 61st St I would say 90% of the areas are great.
"a rumble ain't no rumble without me"