Impending housing crash?

26,681 Views | 182 Replies | Last: 3 yr ago by jja79
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sea Speed said:

Are y'all not moving now?
Pushing it to next year. We aren't desperate to sell so we will just float between the two. Timing just didn't work out.

This market is terrible. We've been tracking ~25 homes in our comp range for a month and only 2 have sold after dropping significantly in price. I'm not willing to sell my home for what I paid 7 years ago so we will just stay here and do 50/50.

edit: First world problems.
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yes I've been trying to buy another house and sellers aren't realizing how bad the market is and are still pricing then like it was last year. Every home I'm watching has been sitting and sitting with reduction after reduction and then longer this goes on the more they are going to have to lower that price because of inflation and interest rates. I'm hoping for some really good deals soon, for a new family home and as rentals. A lot of folks are going to be taking haircuts soon I think. I'm seeing some nice houses sit.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sea Speed said:

Yes I've been trying to buy another house and sellers aren't realizing how bad the market is and are still pricing then like it was last year. Every home I'm watching has been sitting and sitting with reduction after reduction and then longer this goes on the more they are going to have to lower that price because of inflation and interest rates. I'm hoping for some really good deals soon, for a new family home and as rentals. A lot of folks are going to be taking haircuts soon I think. I'm seeing some nice houses sit.
Yep, most people probably haven't done the math to realize that an entire swath of buyers who could previously purchase A class houses at 3% are now priced out and have to resort to buying D class houses at 6+%.

The available pool of buyers for houses in my range has all but disappeared.

Not that my house is A class...this is for illustrative purposes.
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
No I completely understand what you're saying. I think the folks who were scraping together everything to buy a 150-200k class home are the real lovers here. Stuck renting because the interest rates alone make it like having 2 P&I payments. I'm very very glad I'm not a first time home buyer.
Red Pear Luke
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sponsor
AG
Was discussing with El Jefe about the gap between Sellers and Buyers Expectations in this market. Until the job market starts to show significant job losses, it's gonna be tough because people like Youbet don't have to sell. They can float the mortgage or even rent the home. But if someone has to sell and move or loses a job and has to sell, it's going to push the selling over a cliff with price reductions.

There's going to also be issues of comps. If come this next summer there are 200 houses in your neighborhood and only 6 sold in the last 8 months and the prices of those were reduced, you'll see it hit valuations of any who choose to sell then.

You're also probably going to see sellers with guts who have a lot of equity and under cut the other houses for sale around them by going lower. So all those sellers stuck on that $500K sales price and been on the market for 4 months are gonna be upset with Mr. Rogers listing his house across the street he's owned since 1989 for $400K and getting it sold relatively quickly.
Diggity
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
"guts"... That's a nice way to put it.
Medaggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Small time investors like me have essentially left the buying market. People wanting to go from renting to buying are drying up facing 1.5-2x P&I on a similar home at 3%. I am hearing large VCs also are being very picky b/c financing is difficult.

Economics are about supply and demand. So if demand is going down, to keep prices stable, supply has to go down. If supply increases due to lost of job, then you will see a sharp drop.

I would be willing to take on a 6-7% interest rate if I am getting a 30% reduction from last year. No way am I taking on this much risk for a 10-15% reduction.
GaryClare
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
exp said:

txaggie_08 said:

exp said:

Money Printer is coming. House prices will not fall that much.
Why? Why would it make any sense to print more money right now?


Because if they don't the USA will default on it's debt. The current Fed actions are a show that will be cancelled soon to literally save the global us Treasury based fiat financial system from collapsing.
- 31 trillion in official debt
- 161 trillion in unfunded liabilities - "unofficial debt"
- 4.1 trillion in revenue from an economy fueled by Trump tax and fiscal policies that, should a recession occur, could easily go to 3 to 3.5 trillion.

192 trillion x 2% = 3.8 trillion
192 trillion x 3% = 5.7 trillion
192 trillion x 4% = 7.6 trillion

This is the annual interest payment on debt if our debt was fixed at these rates. No principle. The good news is the debt percentage rate is staggered over countless bonds and the last decade got us, the United States, some low interest rates on our debt. But considering the simplistic math problem above, we are going to have trouble making the interest payments when rates get too far above 2%. Forget about the principle. And don't forget about our $1 trillion annual deficit.

Higher Fed rates and the higher income and corporate tax rates will hurt the economy bad enough to where we are going to have a tax revenue problem. We need a juiced economy and high inflation. A new college grad making 100k and paying $30k in taxes won't cut it. We will all see college kids make 500k coming out of college and paying $150k in taxes. A $500k house now will be $2.5 million in the future and a $75 meal now will be $300. But everyone will be making "more" money. That is only we pay our interest payment on the debt.

The alternative is defaulting on our debt obligations. Then dollar becomes worthless and we are a third world country. But this would solve our illegal immigration problem, so we will have that going for us.

We are going to have low rates and high inflation. There is not an alternative.




Tex117
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Medaggie said:

Small time investors like me have essentially left the buying market. People wanting to go from renting to buying are drying up facing 1.5-2x P&I on a similar home at 3%. I am hearing large VCs also are being very picky b/c financing is difficult.

Economics are about supply and demand. So if demand is going down, to keep prices stable, supply has to go down. If supply increases due to lost of job, then you will see a sharp drop.

I would be willing to take on a 6-7% interest rate if I am getting a 30% reduction from last year. No way am I taking on this much risk for a 10-15% reduction.
Its as simple as this.

What I was basically saying earlier in the thread.

(Its the sunshine pumper RE people that were saying there was the ever present supply shortage that was going to keep the prices up as mortgage payments essentially doubled for normal folks). For the same reason sellers are reluctant to lower prices on the belief that their real estate is some how immune from monetary policy, the same reason buyers aren't buying just reflected. Something will give eventually.

jja79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I was on a call yesterday with people from various banks and other mortgage lenders and this was discussed.

Let's say you signed a contract with a production builder in the spring at $500K and now as the house is nearing completion the market has changed and the appraisal for your purchase money mortgage comes in at $470K. Does the builder drop the price? Do you have to come up with an additional $24K now that your max loan (using 20% down as an example) since $$376K is now your max loan instead of $400K?
AgLA06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Or worse. You signed a contract for a house that is taking way too long to deliver because of various reasons and your rate is going to expire before you can close on the house. And current rates are 5%+ higher in addition to the house appraising lower.

I imagine we're going to start seeing people walking away instead of closing and builders with houses they can't sell that lose value each month.
Diggity
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Contract would typically say buyer has to come up with the difference. Weather they choose to enforce that would depend on the builder (and how large the deposit is)
jja79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The conversation was started by someone who said his market has had a rash of buyers walking away in that case. There is always the other issue of having been prequalified at 3% and now long maybe struggling to qualify at 6% or whatever.
zagman
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Medaggie said:

Small time investors like me have essentially left the buying market. People wanting to go from renting to buying are drying up facing 1.5-2x P&I on a similar home at 3%. I am hearing large VCs also are being very picky b/c financing is difficult.

Economics are about supply and demand. So if demand is going down, to keep prices stable, supply has to go down. If supply increases due to lost of job, then you will see a sharp drop.

I would be willing to take on a 6-7% interest rate if I am getting a 30% reduction from last year. No way am I taking on this much risk for a 10-15% reduction.


Here's a $300k house with your 30% reduction at 6%.

Sorry, investors still won't be buying. At 40% reduction they start getting interested because they feel confident they can raise revenue beyond what their increased expense level is. But at a 30% reduction they need 40-50% higher revenue over term merely to cover increased debt costs.

htxag09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
A house in the area we're looking at went on the market today, viewings starting tomorrow. Reached out to my realtor and set up a viewing at lunch and already 10+ appointments set up.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
htxag09 said:

A house in the area we're looking at went on the market today, viewings starting tomorrow. Reached out to my realtor and set up a viewing at lunch and already 10+ appointments set up.
May i ask price of home? I'm assuming it's below $700k?

Where we are, $700K seems to be the magic stopping point now. If it's below that, things are still moving. If it's above that, nothing at all.

Having said that, we had a showing this afternoon out of the blue. Lady is coming back on Sunday with her kids. We are going to play this lead out and if nothing comes of it, we are shutting it down.
htxag09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Slightly above $1mm
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
htxag09 said:

Slightly above $1mm
Makes sense. What i meant to type (honestly) is that there seems to be a donut hole where homes $700k-$1M are left out in the cold. Houses above and below that are still moving. Tells me that the middle class has been regulated to below $700k and the rich can still play.
Dan Scott
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I knew I was relocating at end of this year so earlier this year had target around $800K around $650K loan for comfortable payment. With these rates now, a 650K loan is now around $500K so I need to put additional $150K down or buy a home for around $600K. There is big difference between $800K and $600K home.

Pisses me off especially having to move out of my near perfect home with 3% mortgage.
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Millennial: can't afford a house?

Trumpism, though not necessarily solipsistic and undisciplined Trump himself, matters here:

- Bad actors such as BlackRock really do distort the market
- Land use regulation, which can work with conservationism IF there is minimal immigration
- WHY DO WE ALLOW FOREIGN BUYERS? WHO ELSE DOES THIS ? (NO ONE)

Thank God the dollar is mostly the global reserve currency.

Pat Buchanan was always correct.
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
For those reasons, a housing crash is contextual. I doubt it hits Texas.

We are at a new plateau. Both political parties are at fault (remember moron W and his "ownership society," ie no lending standards) … and the Left is most delusional.
austinAG90
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Dan Scott said:

I knew I was relocating at end of this year so earlier this year had target around $800K around $650K loan for comfortable payment. With these rates now, a 650K loan is now around $500K so I need to put additional $150K down or buy a home for around $600K. There is big difference between $800K and $600K home.

Pisses me off especially having to move out of my near perfect home with 3% mortgage.



Don't worry. Prices are going to come down a lot more. I sold a house I lived in for over 20 years in Nov 19 for $1mm and we bought a tear down in West Austin for $780 with plans to build new. Covid hit - my old house went to $2mm and our tear down project we said no. Sold it in Feb for $1.4mm. Sorry your timing sucks and Biden f'k you. Housing is screwed. Institutional Money is leaving the space with rates rising. No more large land grabs for Blackstone et Al.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yeah, it's going to get worse before it gets better. The Chief Econmiat at Goldmans said today he's expecting another 150-175 basis point increase by end of 2023. So that means the housing market is dead until 2024 at the earliest, if he's correct.

Granted, this is also the same clown org that denied and then was surprised by inflation in 2021 and continues to state a recession hasn't happened and most likely won't. They give it a 35-55% chance of happening over next year. All the fundamentals are good and this whole downturn is really just emotional sentiment.

Also at the same time they conveniently and cynically tell you that the stock market **** the bed while this recession wasn't happening so now that it sucks you might as well stay in it and ride it out.

No one really knows what they are talking about at this point.
Tex117
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
YouBet said:



No one really knows what they are talking about at this point.
No kidding.

My money is on a straight up recession next year. There has been nothing "subtle" about the economy so I just can't see a "soft landing." But thats just a pure guess.
Tex117
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Redstone said:

For those reasons, a housing crash is contextual. I doubt it hits Texas.

We are at a new plateau. Both political parties are at fault (remember moron W and his "ownership society," ie no lending standards) … and the Left is most delusional.
It hits Texas. To what extent. Don't know. But its not possible that Texas is immune for monetary policy of the fed which directly affects the market.

YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Tex117 said:

YouBet said:



No one really knows what they are talking about at this point.
No kidding.

My money is on a straight up recession next year. There has been nothing "subtle" about the economy so I just can't see a "soft landing." But thats just a pure guess.
Interestingly, the former head of Goldman predicts a 95% chance of recession next year. Now that he's out and maybe doesn't have clients on his jock I guess he can be real.
Tex117
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
YouBet said:

Tex117 said:

YouBet said:



No one really knows what they are talking about at this point.
No kidding.

My money is on a straight up recession next year. There has been nothing "subtle" about the economy so I just can't see a "soft landing." But thats just a pure guess.
Interestingly, the former head of Goldman predicts a 95% chance of recession next year. Now that he's out and maybe doesn't have clients on his jock I guess he can be real.
Ha! Probably right.
AgsMyDude
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Medaggie said:

Small time investors like me have essentially left the buying market. People wanting to go from renting to buying are drying up facing 1.5-2x P&I on a similar home at 3%. I am hearing large VCs also are being very picky b/c financing is difficult.

Economics are about supply and demand. So if demand is going down, to keep prices stable, supply has to go down. If supply increases due to lost of job, then you will see a sharp drop.

I would be willing to take on a 6-7% interest rate if I am getting a 30% reduction from last year. No way am I taking on this much risk for a 10-15% reduction.


I'm in the same boat...I've been looking hard for awhile to add another rental to my portfolio in BCS and it appears there's very little that make it worth it. Most of what I see would be negative cash flow, especially with rates today.

And the ones that are rentals and listed aren't going to budge from their number. They have tenants paying the bills so no reason for them not to test the waters and no reason to sell below their threshold.
AgsMyDude
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
YouBet said:

Tex117 said:

YouBet said:



No one really knows what they are talking about at this point.
No kidding.

My money is on a straight up recession next year. There has been nothing "subtle" about the economy so I just can't see a "soft landing." But thats just a pure guess.
Interestingly, the former head of Goldman predicts a 95% chance of recession next year. Now that he's out and maybe doesn't have clients on his jock I guess he can be real.


Recession next year? As in another one or simply a continuation of the recession we're currently in.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AgsMyDude said:

YouBet said:

Tex117 said:

YouBet said:



No one really knows what they are talking about at this point.
No kidding.

My money is on a straight up recession next year. There has been nothing "subtle" about the economy so I just can't see a "soft landing." But thats just a pure guess.
Interestingly, the former head of Goldman predicts a 95% chance of recession next year. Now that he's out and maybe doesn't have clients on his jock I guess he can be real.


Recession next year? As in another one or simply a continuation of the recession were currently in.


Exactly.
AgsMyDude
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
YouBet said:

AgsMyDude said:

YouBet said:

Tex117 said:

YouBet said:



No one really knows what they are talking about at this point.
No kidding.

My money is on a straight up recession next year. There has been nothing "subtle" about the economy so I just can't see a "soft landing." But thats just a pure guess.
Interestingly, the former head of Goldman predicts a 95% chance of recession next year. Now that he's out and maybe doesn't have clients on his jock I guess he can be real.


Recession next year? As in another one or simply a continuation of the recession were currently in.


Exactly.


Well, which is it?
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AgsMyDude said:

YouBet said:

AgsMyDude said:

YouBet said:

Tex117 said:

YouBet said:



No one really knows what they are talking about at this point.
No kidding.

My money is on a straight up recession next year. There has been nothing "subtle" about the economy so I just can't see a "soft landing." But thats just a pure guess.
Interestingly, the former head of Goldman predicts a 95% chance of recession next year. Now that he's out and maybe doesn't have clients on his jock I guess he can be real.


Recession next year? As in another one or simply a continuation of the recession were currently in.


Exactly.


Well, which is it?
Why not both at this rate. Everyone has manipulated the meaning of it to the point that we no longer live in reality.
htxag09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Has everyone manipulated the meaning or is it just complex?
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
htxag09 said:

Has everyone manipulated the meaning or is it just complex?


Of course it's complex but we have people that know better abjectly claiming things are pretty good and that recession is a not even likely which is flat out gaslighting.

Some of these same people were surprised by the run up in inflation last year despite printing 40% of all money that ever existed in such a short time period.
AgsMyDude
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
YouBet said:

htxag09 said:

Has everyone manipulated the meaning or is it just complex?


Of course it's complex but we have people that know better abjectly claiming things are pretty good and that recession is a not even likely which is flat out gaslighting.

Some of these same people were surprised by the run up in inflation last year despite printing 40% of all money that ever existed in such a short time period.


How can people claim a recession isn't likely when we're literally in one by definition as I type this?
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.