Came across this thread that I started. Just an update to what we wound up doing.
Set up a Titleist portal that all of the players get access to. Set up 10 different "packages" that each player gets to pick from. Packages each contained some variation of a Titleist duffel bag, Titleist backpack, balls, shirt, shorts, quarter zips, hats and Footjoy shoes. Pick your own package. Pick your size. Can even customize a number on the balls if you want to. Retail value is roughly $200 - $225. Not our cost. If you order by a certain date the merchandise will be shipped to the club and you'll get it at registration.
In addition, we're going to give out logo'ed caddie towels and a sleeve of logo'ed ProV1's at registration. Numbered 25. Also going to hand out a logo'ed Titleist valuables pouch (with a mini Fireball in it) before the start of Day 2. Those are all kind of surprise gifts.
We've gotten good feedback on the packages so far.