Entertainment
Sponsored by

Avatar: The Way of Water (Spoiler Thread)

15,564 Views | 135 Replies | Last: 2 yr ago by Brian Earl Spilner
Cromagnum
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Beautiful movie to watch, though the high fps did create a bad soap opera effect at times. I felt like David Attenborough was going to do some narration at times, especially when the whales showed up.

Felt like we didn't really develop a connection to the kids, especially the older brother and younger daughter (I can't even remember their names). The story really was just "our kids are in trouble again", over and over. Felt also like they sidelined Neytiri until they needed her to kick some ass.
Gig-Em2003
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Saw it in Dolby Cinema 3D. Absolutely stunning. Not dim at all and the sound was incredible. The HFR 48 was distracting when it happened.

Solid story, cared for the characters. So I guess at some point Spider will turn on the family and this will turn into Cobra Kai?
TCTTS
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Saw it again tonight, this time with the family, in 2D, and it was even better the second go-around. Everyone loved it, was in tears, and just swept up by the whole thing. It really is an incredible sequel.

What struck me this time is how much of the focus truly is on the kids - it's *their* story - and how much they grow over the course of the film, to ultimately be the ones teaching and guiding their parents in the end. The roles end up completely reversed. There's just such a great Goonies vibe I didn't know I was missing, in the Marvel/Star Wars age, where a ragtag group of kids disobeys their parents - in order to do the right thing - getting swept up in an adventure, and in all sorts of trouble, along the way. I don't know, just watching them all come together to help each other was really moving this time, and made me nostalgic for all those kinds of movies from the '80s that did roughly the same thing. Cameron captures that whole vibe so incredibly well, which gives it a classic, Amblin feel that I failed to appreciate on first watch, in all the spectacle and hype. To the point where, honestly, I kind of want to see it a third time.
Cinco Ranch Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I finally saw this last night with a group from my office. Saw it in 3D unlike my one and only theatrical viewing of the original movie. I am a sucker for James Cameron's science fiction efforts. I love his depiction of hardware of the future, and how he grounds it in the familiar even when the movie is set in 2159 (don't know that date is the fact, but I believe the original was 2154 and this one was 5 years later).

Visually, this movie is spectacular, as was the original. Clearly, this was a movie that was likely as close to 100% visual effects as any ever released. I have read nothing on how the effects were produced, but am presuming a lot of CGI was employed. There were many scenes that for my 55-year-old eyes appeared to be a bit off. The rendering was great - none of the characters appeared like young Princess Leia in Rogue One, for instance, but I just felt that the color spectrum was a bit too vibrant, cartoonish almost. That is a minor quibble that may very well be only in my eyes.

I cannot say that the story truly wowed me. It was largely meh for me, but it was a vast improvement upon the previous movie. I don't have a derisive statement to make about this one as I have for the first (Dances With Wolves in space, or something similar). I do get why the colonel was returned as an avatar, as his mission to kill Jake Sully drove the entire narrative, but just felt like a "getting the gang back together" approach. No, I don't have any alternatives to how Cameron could have developed his story. The colonel as an avatar is fine but IMO a bit lazy.

Regarding the 3D, I was amazed at that. Despite my issues with the color spectrum, the 3D gave that entire world a sense of being alive. And holy crap, when tracer fire was on screen, it literally appeared to come right at my chest. Same with splashes of water.

When it ended, I told my wife that Cameron had finally found a way to meld Aliens with Titanic and maybe a bit of The Abyss into his Avatar world. The scene were the youngest daughter and the Gamora gal's mom got sucked down the hole while the attack ship was sinking gave me an instant flashback to Newt falling down the chute with Ripley failing to pull her back by her jacket in Aliens. And of course the mom/daughter crawling through the upside-down cafeteria looked like something one might have seen in Titanic.
Bunbury
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Also watched last night and squeezed in a refresher of the original a few days prior. The stuff Cameron is good at, he is VERY DAMN good at. The original assault on HomeTree and then the Whaling set piece in the sequal are both as thrilling and well done as anything other directors are capable of. And he's at 100% when he just lets the viewer observe and enjoy the world he's built.

I'm not sure if the story/character/writing deficiencies are intentional or not (maybe he wants everything to be super broad/cliche to land with the largest possible audience and age-range), but I sort-of landed on the conclusion to just enjoy these movies' strengths and try to ignore the weaknesses.

Plot-wise keeping the colonel alive is a huge eye-roll, and intentionally having Sigourney Weaver voice her 'daughter' would likely be a plot-clue that the 'daughter' is some sort of clone or the pandora-magic version of that?
Brian Earl Spilner
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TCTTS
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I was wondering how the third movie would offer something fresh, considering The Way of Water is so good at introducing us to a new world (and new challenges), while staying on Pandora, and this is pretty good idea/answer...

Definitely Not A Cop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I was predicting Way of The Tundra.
Brian Earl Spilner
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yep, looking forward to having mixed allegiances among the races rather than just black or white, good vs evil.

And throw in the fact that Spider's allegiance is already somewhat wavering.
schmendeler
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
So, Comanche Na'vi
TCTTS
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ha, exactly. And then get ready for even more b*tching about appropriation/depiction from the same old left-leaning bellyachers.
Brian Earl Spilner
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Now I'm thinking the Fire Na'vi will be the ones who want to take the fight to Earth and the Sullys will be the ones resisting trying to prevent mass genocide on Earth.
Brian Earl Spilner
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Also, expect Oona Chaplin to be a member of that tribe.

Bruce Almighty
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Part 4 will be the wind Na'vi, part 5 will be the heart Na'vi and we'll then get a spin-off with Jake Sully growing a green mullet and going back to Earth as Captain Planet.
Sex Panther
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
So James Cameron starts a franchise called Avatar... and in it, there are different groups of natives. The first being an Earth Kingdom... and then we meet a Water Tribe... and now we're getting an evil Fire Nation...


Brian Earl Spilner
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Funny thing is JC had the name first.

"In 2004 we learned that we had to change the name of our show from Avatar to Avatar the Last Airbender because James Cameron already had the rights to a movie called Avatar."
AustinAg2K
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Finally got out to see it. In the beginning, I was again blown away by the 3D and I was reminded of what an incredible experience watching the first one was. After three countless times of watching the Navi, or the fish, or whatever, swim around the ocean, I found the effects less impressive. I guess I just got used to them pretty quick, unlike the first Avatar, where I was blown away the whole time.

The story was a major disappointment, though. I would have liked to see more depth added to the world other than, "Navi/nature good, humans bad." Even my kids felt the story was paint by numbers.

Overall, it was nice to be reminded of how great 3D can be when done correctly, so I'm not upset and spending the money, but unlike the first one, I won't be taking groups of friends back to see it again.
Ghost of Bisbee
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Saw this in IMAX 3D, really enjoyed it. Best 3D execution I've seen for any movie.

Would love to compare it to the Dolby Cinema option. I hear that format may be even better
The greatest prose to ever grace TexAgs:
https://texags.com/forums/5/topics/3216304/replies/59855160
Apache
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Great effects, meh story just like the first one. It's like he just rebooted the story and added some kids….Too many kids for me to grow to care about any one.
Lots of eye rolling for me:
Avatar operators with G shocks watches and Oakley shades ….oof.
Sea Navi have tattoos just like Mori.
The bad fish chasing Sullys kid just like Sully was chased in the first movie.
Use of air bags to raise up the whales, just like they used barrels in Jaws.

Towards the end of hour 2 I just wanted the movie to end.
Bummer.
Brian Earl Spilner
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

Use of air bags to raise up the whales, just like they used barrels in Jaws.


What was wrong with this?
schmendeler
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yeah it seems like it would be a standard technique for whaling; don't let the prey get away by diving.
Apache
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
That was a minor quibble. Just screamed Jaws (one of my favorite movies of all time) rip off.
Far worse was "bro" being thrown around. Sounded like my sons Jr High friends.

Another chuckle I got was when they killed the whale thing & pulled out a liter of golden goo and the guy said it was worth 800 million and would stop aging. Only 800 million and this is 100+ years in the future?
Maybe the currency devalued, but that number seems low. Elon, Bezos, Putin, Xi & the Saudi Royals would be snorting rails of the stuff at that price current day!

Very curious to see where Cameron takes the next one. I'm encouraged that he says the Ash Tribe will show the bad side of the Na'vi. The next film can't just be bad humans vs. Na'vi again.

Would be far more interesting if a tribe of Na'vi aligned with people to take advantage of their tech & used it to dominate their neighbors. (As happened when some of the Indian Tribes came into contact with Europeans in North America) Maybe a tribe that lived in a resource poor area of Pandora & struggled would be ripe for bribery....
Cinco Ranch Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

That was a minor quibble. Just screamed Jaws (one of my favorite movies of all time) rip off.

Far worse was "bro" being thrown around. Sounded like my sons Jr High friends.
I had the same thought regarding the barrels. Felt like a ripoff despite it being a sound tactic for dealing with aquatic critters.

And I also really hated the use of the word "bro". Too current for a movie set well into the future.
Cinco Ranch Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

Another chuckle I got was when they killed the whale thing & pulled out a liter of golden goo and the guy said it was worth 800 million and would stop aging. Only 800 million and this is 100+ years in the future?

Maybe the currency devalued, but that number seems low. Elon, Bezos, Putin, Xi & the Saudi Royals would be snorting rails of the stuff at that price current day!
This is not the first time I questioned financial numbers in a Cameron movie. In Aliens, the bean counter early in the movie stated the loss of the Nostromo was worth 47 million, minus payload. I'm pretty sure that in current days, 47 million would not even get you half of a F-35 fighter.
Apache
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

I had the same thought regarding the barrels. Felt like a ripoff despite it being a sound tactic for dealing with aquatic critters.

And I also really hated the use of the word "bro". Too current for a movie set well into the future.

+
This is not the first time I questioned financial numbers in a Cameron movie. In Aliens, the bean counter early in the movie stated the loss of the Nostromo was worth 47 million, minus payload. I'm pretty sure that in current days, 47 million would not even get you half of a F-35 fighter.
It's as if Cameron spent so much world building on the Na'vi/Pandora environment he didn't do likewise on the human side. On one hand he has robotic spiders building infrastructure rapidly, on the other he has prop driven aircraft carrying soldiers with "ARs" G-shocks and Oakleys.

However it wouldn't be much of a movie if the humans hovered over the planet, released 1,000,000 armed flying drones equipped with AI & dispensed with the Na'vi overnight. (Which is the way war is headed)
cr0wbar
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Saw it over the weekend. I don't know how some of yall have seen this movie more than once, it's entirely too long. It's the longest video game cutscene of all time. Still unsure if the younger or older son died at the end. It was fun.
BCG Disciple
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Saw it. Was entertaining.

The battle sequences were some of the best I have seen. Immersive, engaging, and stunning to watch. Applied to both human v blue people and human v space fish.

During the cable scene my 7 year old excitedly proclaimed that "his arm got torn off like the guy in Jurassic world fallen kingdom." Moments like this, which are etched in a child's mind to be recalled immediately, make one realize the inappropriateness of a violent pg-13 movie to a kid. Luckily mom was not there.
Cinco Ranch Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Another Aliens reference - I recall watching that one with my mom one evening. After the big opening ambush by the aliens against the Marines and the Marines GTFO in the APC, Hicks told Ripley to "ease down, you're just grinding the trans-axle." My mom commented, you mean they're still using trans-axles?

Cameron has a great eye for tech and does a phenomenal job in world-building. I think he doesn't spend much time considering how tech truly evolves over time in the real world. I have to believe that by the time of Aliens, engineers have come up with a different mechanism to accomplish what the trans-axle does in current times. If not, then he's essentially saying mankind is still operating wagons.

The helicopters in Avatar look like something we could produce right now. The flying battleship thing is interesting, but is also something we could produce now although I would doubt its practicality.
LB12Diamond
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG


Pretty much nailed it!
Gig ‘Em Baby!
Apache
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

Pretty much nailed it!

FIFY!
Jim01
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Saw it with the kids yesterday. An enjoyable theatre experience for sure, but yes it was definitely too long. You can't tell me you couldn't cut 5-10 minutes out of each hour and it would have been just fine! Especially the middle section which at times felt like it was just showing off the underwater technology (which was beautiful) but didn't server the story at all.

My kids all really liked it. In the truck on the way home we all discussed the plot holes/annoyances and things you'll always have in the plot of a visually driven movie. I'm sure some of these have been discussed.

  • We were all annoyed that the older brother died. The younger one was just annoying. Always leading them into danger because he couldn't simply listen!
  • The brothers served a purpose, the adopted sister did too, but the younger sister seemed completely unnecessary. She was just kind of there.
  • At the end when the wife and kids are about to abandon ship and the fire encircles them. Why didn't they just swim under it? Didn't we just spend an hour+ watching you learn to the ways of the water and how to dive and stuff?
  • The colonel being emotionally attached to spider wasn't really well developed. Spider was also a weird character. He took to the marines VERY quickly.
  • The kids go save the whale and the younger brother says he'll lead them away. JUST SWIM IDIOTS! Also he led them away yet still somehow the other kids didn't manage to get away. Eye roll!
  • The bad guys plan sucked. Take out Jake and there will be peace? I don't think they'll stop fighting if you take out their hero. Also after the first battle Jake disappears. So is there peace? Why not just leave him alone?
  • Also the dialog amongst the kids was pretty cringey at times. I can just see 60+ old Cameron sitting at his computer Hey bro! What's up cuzzz! "This is how kids talk, right?"



Overall it was fun and beautiful but just too bloated. I don't think I would rewatch until maybe a viewing right before the next one comes out.
Cromagnum
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Bruce Almighty said:

Part 4 will be the wind Na'vi, part 5 will be the heart Na'vi and we'll then get a spin-off with Jake Sully growing a green mullet and going back to Earth as Captain Planet.


JFC.
TCTTS
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sneak peak at the title track for the Seed bearer., Rated NC-17

MBAR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I don't know if my theater was just bad, but we saw it at amc with Dolby 3d and I am not impressed at all. The higher frame rates are just bad and just make the movie look like a video game. I would rather watch bad cgi with an actual story than slog through the first two acts of this film ever again.


That being said the last act was solid. Cameron definitely knows how to do action. Space whale was amazing. Otherwise this is completely forgettable for me.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.