Entertainment
Sponsored by

***** SURVIVOR 50: Come on in, guys! THREAD *****

7,972 Views | 153 Replies | Last: 41 min ago by Saxsoon
CharleyKerfeld
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Tonight's flashback episode is the premiere episode of 2010's Heroes vs. Villains all-star season, a really fantastic season with a stacked cast. Russell played two straight seasons and finished 2nd and 3rd. According to Wikipedia,


Heroes
Stephenie LeGrossa
Rupert
JT
Fireman Tom
James
Colby
Sugar
Amanda
Candice
Cirie

Villains
Sandra
Coach
Boston Rob
Coach
Randy (not sure how he got here)
Parvati
Jerri
Russell
Courtney
Danielle



Counterpoint
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
On Monday's episode, after Erik gives away his immunity idol, a man in the jury says something like "now I'm not the dumbest player in Survivor history!"
Being relatively new to Survivor, my question is...what did THAT guy do?
jdgilberg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
My first thought is James, a favorite from Survivor China who got voted out with two hidden immunity idols in his bag.
double aught
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
What season did the show move to HD?
CharleyKerfeld
How long do you want to ignore this user?
jdgilberg said:

My first thought is James, a favorite from Survivor China who got voted out with two hidden immunity idols in his bag.

That's it exactly. I think that Fans/Favorites season sort of tarnished James' rep as a nice guy as well. I can't remember exactly why though.
DoitBest
How long do you want to ignore this user?
S
We just started tonight's show, seems like Coaches back isn't so bad after all....
DoitBest
How long do you want to ignore this user?
S
And after that match, we are lol didn't remember that
CharleyKerfeld
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I watched the first half of the premiere of Heroes v. Villains that aired tonight. It's really fascinating for a number of reasons, including that since they were still in the live finale era, Russell didn't know that he didn't win his season, and obviously thinks he's going for title #2.

Other than winners at war, it seems like H v V must have had the best cast of all time in terms of wanting the best and getting the best.


Also, Parvati.

DoitBest
How long do you want to ignore this user?
S
After watching tonight's rerun, we almost ready to say Coach is 1st out on his tribe & will be rooting for Ozzy...but how old is he now....
DoitBest
How long do you want to ignore this user?
S
Dayum...Mrs.Best moved on the the reunion/winner episode.....
Russell the coon azz, is a real piece of work....wow....
Saxsoon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
DoitBest said:

After watching tonight's rerun, we almost ready to say Coach is 1st out on his tribe & will be rooting for Ozzy...but how old is he now....


Based on interviews nearly everyone but two want to work with Coach and many in the press pool for 50 are wondering if he might be the Sole Survivor

To be clear interviews tha occurred pre game
CharleyKerfeld
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Watching Rob and Sandra bet a dollar on whether coach was going to climb a palm tree or fall to his death in the Heroes v Villains first episode was fantastic TV.
Thunderstruck xx
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I've seen I think the first 15 seasons before I lost interest. Probably around the time they went super woke. Jeff not saying "guys" anymore is just stupid. Is there any entertainment value left in this show?

If I do watch this one I'll be rooting against Cirie and Ozzy. I can't stand either of them.
Counterpoint
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Thunderstruck xx said:

I've seen I think the first 15 seasons before I lost interest. Probably around the time they went super woke. Jeff not saying "guys" anymore is just stupid. Is there any entertainment value left in this show?

Is this season an all new cast, or some past members returning too?

ALL past members returning.
Thunderstruck xx
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Just looked it up and saw that. I'll probably have to root for Colby.
DoitBest
How long do you want to ignore this user?
S
I was just going off of every eye roll everyone gives anytime Coach starts pontificating.....
DoitBest
How long do you want to ignore this user?
S
Currently, I'm praying we join the game with y'all next week, as Mrs.Best is now intent on re-watching every season that aired this week.....
CharleyKerfeld
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DoitBest said:

Currently, I'm praying we join the game with y'all next week, as Mrs.Best is now intent on re-watching every season that aired this week.....

ya got 2 weeks! - it starts the 25th. I will post the rules on the 18th so everyone can dig in and make their picks.
Saxsoon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
A helpful chart with all of the friend foe choices the players made during ponderosa interviews

https://www.reddit.com/r/survivor/s/VJVmYv4aD0

Saxsoon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
If I had to take an early stab at guessing first boots,

Cila - as far down the totem pole Joe and Savannah are I am not sure they will be first boot just because they are good for the team challenges. Cirie may be the one in danger with 4 people clearly not wanting to work with her, could flip Joe for the majority. Her and Rick I see as the ones most people do not trust and probably the least damaging to lose for future challenges

Vatu - Rizo is really ****ed here. Useless in challenges, no one trusts him. He needs to work that Rizz magic to come out of this one alive or hope his team are the challenge kings. If not him then Angelina. Q is also in hot water but unless he really pisses off Colby, they might want to keep him for challenges

Kalo - Dee is the only one with the least amount of people against her in all of the tribes, and that is only half. This tribe is a tough one and really going to come down island politics. Charlie may end up pushing Kamila away which gets us into an even split. Charlie in general is going to have a rough time if he somehow survives to the merge. This team though is the most cohesive overall though with least likely amount of drama. And with Jonathan, Dee, and Coach, it is very possible they will dominate all of the challenges until the first tribe swap.


Obviously the game hasn't been played out yet (for our eyes) but Jenna and Coach are sitting very nicely at the top of the totem pole. Ozzy will heat up for challenges likely and get targeted.
CharleyKerfeld
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm going to type out the rules for the Survivor 50 Pickem tonight and post them tomorrow, so I would really welcome any other suggestions. Already including the "first voted off" person category.

I'll bump the thread every day until the debut to remind you to make your picks. We'll do the same format from last season with a spreadsheet. I'll put up $50 for the winner. If anyone wants to match that would be great, but nor pressure to do so.
CharleyKerfeld
How long do you want to ignore this user?
SURVIVOR 50 PICKEM STARTS IN ONE WEEK!

HOW TO PLAY
[ol]
  • Pick 5 contestants - any gender, any tribe, that you think will get the farthest in the game.
  • Pick 1 contestant to be the first person eliminated BY ANY MEANS - voted off, evacuated, quits, kills themself after listening to Coach talk for an hour.
  • [/ol]


    SUBMIT your on this thread or to me via DM before 7 p.m. CDT on Wednesday, February 25, 2026.

    PRIZE MONEY
    I'll Venmo the winner $50 at the end of the season. If anyone else wants to put some prize money, we can sweeten the pot, or give out some $ for second place.


    HOW IT WORKS
    [ol]
  • You get points based on what they accomplish / don't accomplish through the tribe and then individual parts of the game. Points are tabulated each week and the standings updated. I made up a **** ton of categories to try to make it as fun, silly, and engaging as possible.
  • The people you pick at the beginning that make the merge get a 0.5-point bonus on their achievements during the individual part of the game. So if it's 5 points for winning an Individual Immunity Challenge, you'd get 5.5.
  • If you have people voted out before the merge, you can redraft from the remaining players after the merge. But they don't get the 0.5-point bonus.
  • [/ol]

    POINTS BREAKDOWN

    PRE-MERGE CHALLENGES

    Your team finishes the challenge 1st (reward or immunity): +2 points
    Your team finished the challenge 2nd (reward or immunity) : +1 point
    Your team finishes the challenge 3rd (reward or immunity): - 1 point
    NOTE: If the tribes go from 3 to 2, the rule switches to 2 points for the winners and -1 point for the losers.


    YOU'RE OUT OF THE GAME
    You get medically evacuated: -3 points
    You quit the game for any reason beyond your health or a family medical emergency: -10 points

    FINDING IDOLS
    You find a hidden immunity idol: +3 points
    You find any other sort of advantage: +2 points
    Some dummy gives you their advantage or idol anytime before Tribal Council: +2 points
    You give away your advantage or idol to someone else anytime before Tribal Council: -2 points
    You find an advantage note or HII clue, but you're too dumb to retrieve it by yourself / at all: - 2 points
    You make a fake immunity idol and some idiot falls for it: 3 points
    You're the idiot that finds the fake immunity idol and thinks that it's real: -3 points

    INDIVIDUAL IMMUNITY CHALLENGES
    You win: +5 points
    You're the first one out: -2 points
    You sit out because you think you're safe or you want to eat: - 2 points

    INDIVIDUAL REWARD / MISC CHALLENGES
    You win: +3 points
    You're the first one out: -1 point
    You get picked to go along with the winner on the reward: +1 point
    You go on the Journey and win: +2
    You go on the Journey and lose: -2

    AT TRIBAL COUNCIL - THE GOOD
    You play the Shot in the Dark and save your ass: +3 points
    You play your HII at Tribal Council and it saves you from getting voted off: +5 points
    You play your HII at Tribal Council and it saves someone else, or you give it someone else and they save themselves: +3 points
    You survive Tribal Council: +0.5 points pre-merge, +1 point post-merge.

    AT TRIBAL COUNCIL - THE BAD
    You play your HII at Tribal Council and it doesn't save anyone: -3 points
    You play your advantage at Tribal Council and it doesn't alter who goes home: -2 points
    You play or give your idol / immunity necklace to someone else at Tribal Council and then you get voted off that night aka The Ice Cream Scooper: -10 points
    You go home with an advantage in your pocket: -3 points
    You go home with a HII in your pocket: -5 points
    You get voted off at Tribal Council before the merge: - 5 points
    You get voted off at Tribal Council after the merge: -3 points
    You spell the name of the person you're voting for wrong: - 1 point (EVERY TIME)

    FINAL TRIBAL
    You are the Sole Survivor: +10 points
    You finish second: +6 points
    You finish third: +4 points
    You finish fourth: +2 points
    You get zero votes at Final Tribal: - 3 points


    EXTRA FUN
    You are shown on TV smashing your crotch into an object during a challenge: -3 points (EVERY TIME SHOWN)

    You are shown on TV smashing any other part of your body into an object during a challenge: -1 point (EVERY TIME SHOWN)

    You suffer an injury outside of a challenge that doesn't eliminate you from the game (falling out of a tree, stepping on a machete etc.) - 1 point

    You start crying back at camp or after the challenge (tears must be shed on TV) because you didn't get invited on the reward: -2 points (every challenge this happens)

    You lose any piece of your team's vital equipment for more than 10 minutes of the show including commercials (fishing gear, flint, machete): -2 points

    You have a breakdown about how unfair life is based on your race, gender, sexual orientation, anything political, or COVID-19: -3 points (EVERY TIME SHOWN)

    The camera shows you rolling your eyes while Coach is talking: +1 point (EVERY TIME SHOWN)

    The camera shows you rolling your eyes while Rizzo is talking: +1 point (EVERY TIME SHOWN)

    The camera shows you rolling your eyes while Colby is talking about Survivor: Australia: +1 point (EVERY TIME SHOWN)

    The camera shows you rolling your eyes while Jenna is talking about being on the first season: +1 point (EVERY TIME SHOWN)

    The camera shows you rolling your eyes when Q is talking: +1 point (EVERY TIME SHOWN)

    The camera shows you rolling your eyes when Rick Devens does one of his "breaking news" monologues: +1 (EVERY TIME SHOWN)

    You apologize for some sort of political/emotional BS from a previous time you played Survivor (you didn't think about other people's feelings, you didn't know any gay people, you were not aware of how much white guilt you should have): - 5 points (EVERY TIME SHOWN)

    You decide to play "Real Life Police" and call someone out for something you don't like about their life outside the game: -5 points (EVERY TIME SHOWN)

    You try to make up or use some dumb-ass nickname for Jeff Probst other than "Jeff": -2 points (EVERY TIME SHOWN)

    You eat/drink too much on a reward and get sick - either the top or the bottom kind: -2 points

    Here's a pretty picture chart of everyone





    Survivors ready?



















    CharleyKerfeld
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    Counterpoint is the first player in for the Season 50 pickem! Thanks for playing, CP

    I'm going to make my picks early so I don't have to keep racking my brain about it. It's a very different experience picking people you know (and mostly like) vs a bunch of strangers you've spent an hour with.

    My picks: Coach, Charlie, Christian, Jonathan, Aubry

    First out: Jenna
    veryfuller
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    Staff
    AG
    I'm a newer Survivor fan. I watched season 1 and 2 way back in the day, but was in high school, and DVR didn't exist yet, so it was hard to keep up. Started watching again last spring (season 48) and have been obsessively watching old seasons ever since. So I'm definitely a green fan, but feel like I have a pretty good gauge on how things play out. I'm still unfamiliar with some of the newer players, but I'm going to jump in and play pick'em this round.

    First out: I think Kalo tribe is most likely to lose the 1st immunity challenge. That tribe has a lot of really strong strategists. I think they end up getting out someone who is a real threat to win right out of the bat -- Jonathan

    My 5 picks:

    Mike, Aubry, Cirie, Coach, Christian
    Saxsoon
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    AG
    I still have to think on this but I think new era are going to cannibalize each other
    CharleyKerfeld
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    veryfuller said:

    I'm a newer Survivor fan. I watched season 1 and 2 way back in the day, but was in high school, and DVR didn't exist yet, so it was hard to keep up. Started watching again last spring (season 48) and have been obsessively watching old seasons ever since. So I'm definitely a green fan, but feel like I have a pretty good gauge on how things play out. I'm still unfamiliar with some of the newer players, but I'm going to jump in and play pick'em this round.

    First out: I think Kalo tribe is most likely to lose the 1st immunity challenge. That tribe has a lot of really strong strategists. I think they end up getting out someone who is a real threat to win right out of the bat -- Jonathan

    My 5 picks:

    Mike, Aubry, Cirie, Coach, Christian

    Welcome in to the game!
    Although i don't like you picking one of my final 5 to go out early
    veryfuller
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    Staff
    AG
    Sorry, I just feel like these returning player seasons always get going SUPER early. Just trying to think through what those strategic ladies would cook up tbh.
    CharleyKerfeld
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    veryfuller said:

    Sorry, I just feel like these returning player seasons always get going SUPER early. Just trying to think through what those strategic ladies would cook up tbh.

    No worries, I was teasing. Watching Jonathan in physical challenges during his first season was a show highlight for me. I think there was that one where the rest of the cast looked like they were about to drown while he's striding through the water like Godzilla.


    Here's the spreadsheet for 50 if you want to check your picks.

    .




    caleblyn
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    I'll play...

    Jonathan, Joe, Ozzy, Coach, Jenna

    First Out - Rizo
    CharleyKerfeld
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    caleblyn said:

    I'll play...

    Jonathan, Joe, Ozzy, Coach, Jenna

    First Out - Rizo


    You're in!
    Quinn
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    AG
    Emily, Mike, Genevieve, Jonathan, Colby.

    First Out: Q
    CharleyKerfeld
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    Quinn said:

    Emily, Mike, Genevieve, Jonathan, Colby.

    First Out: Q

    You're in! And while I'm not sure it's a shared opinion, I find Emily capable of being sneaky island hot once she stopped being clueless about how to speak to other humans.

    CharleyKerfeld
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    I watched 2-1/2 episodes of the "Road to 50" countdown last night that included this Devens' all timer when he destroys Ron and Julie.

    Although the other guy giving up immunity to take out Devens in the firemaking was even better.

    CharleyKerfeld
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    Probst speaks!
    New hype video
    Nice to see Christian has busted out his robot shirt again.

    Mozart Paintings
    How long do you want to ignore this user?
    AG
    Cirie, Charlie, Jonathan, Joe, Aubry

    First out Kyle
     
    ×
    subscribe Verify your student status
    See Subscription Benefits
    Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.