fig96 said:
JJxvi said:
What the ****? If you are 5th or 6th best in the confederation, you have to finish 4th or better in the hex, but if you were 7th you just have to beat the other minnows and then the #4 team only???? But you also have no shot at qualifying automatically?
Yeah, that seems...questionable. You could theoretically have a hot Curacao or T&T team go to the World Cup while a team like Honduras doesn't even have a chance to play for it after the Hex.
It feels like they are soooo close to the right answer, but they CONCACAF'd it.
Here's one way they could fix it: Send the top three through automatically, and send the bottom three to a playoff with the top three finishers from this "7-35 tournament" (which I will call the minnow fight) as follows
Byes: Hex 4th place and Minnow Fight Champ
Game 1: Hex 5th place vs. Minnow Fight 3rd Place
Game 2: Hex 6th place vs. Minnow Fight 2nd Place
Game 3: Hex 4th place vs. Game 2 winner
Game 4: Minnow Fight Champ vs. Game 1 winner
Game 5: Game 3 winner vs. Game 4 winner
In this example, no one gets screwed by their placement. In the actual setup, it could be argued that 7th is preferable to 6th.