Caruso will play in the NBA
122,100 Views |
371 Replies |
Last: 13 hrs ago by dave94
Caruso is also a perfect example of how someone can make a career in the league by finding an important thing that no one else is willing to do and then being elite at that thing.
He is a monster at deflections, mostly due to his effort and BBIQ and he just makes himself into a disruptive force when he's on the court that positively impacts winning. The 3 point shooting is a huge bonus, but he makes 20 million dollars a year because he creates chaos defensively.
He is a monster at deflections, mostly due to his effort and BBIQ and he just makes himself into a disruptive force when he's on the court that positively impacts winning. The 3 point shooting is a huge bonus, but he makes 20 million dollars a year because he creates chaos defensively.
_lefraud_ said:
Are you watching the same clip as me?
Castle is no where close to being set, and is moving/lunging towards AC. Castle is a couple inches bigger, and 25 pounds heavier...
Castle looks more like a fullback in that clip than a guy trying to set a screen.
Still a non-call because AC wasn't set either.
A defender doesn't have to be set if the offensive player lunges, lowers shoulder and/or extends their arm, which Castle clearly does in that clip.
_lefraud_ said:
A defender doesn't have to be set if the offensive player lunges, lowers shoulder and/or extends their arm, which Castle clearly does in that clip.
He never established a legal guarding position to draw the foul.
Again, he doesn't have to establish a legal guarding position if the offensive player "setting a screen" lowers his shoulder, extends his arm, or lunges at him.
Sorry your team is losing.
Sorry your team is losing.
One of my favorite internet fan things is disingenuous arguing.
As someone with no dog in this series, It's very obvious what's happening in that clip. Caruso can see that Castle doesn't see him or expect him to charge the ball, so he's going to run towards the ball and force the contact and by the time Castle sees him there's nothing he can do, partially because the angle Caruso takes isn't directly toward the ball, he intentionally gets to Castle as quickly as possible. Caruso exaggerates the contact, he even kind of shuffles his left foot a bit so he can look like he took most of the force of the impact rather than deliver it.
So it is all of those things. It's a set up by Caruso, but Castle does commit the foul, Caruso does flop to exaggerate the contact, but it is an offensive foul. When you're playing a team that you KNOW plays this way, Castle has to be more aware of his positioning and where Caruso is.
For me that's fairly safely on the "smart but annoying basketball" side of the line compared to just outright flopping, and "smart but annoying" is basically Caruso's entire brand of basketball and it's made him rich as hell.
As someone with no dog in this series, It's very obvious what's happening in that clip. Caruso can see that Castle doesn't see him or expect him to charge the ball, so he's going to run towards the ball and force the contact and by the time Castle sees him there's nothing he can do, partially because the angle Caruso takes isn't directly toward the ball, he intentionally gets to Castle as quickly as possible. Caruso exaggerates the contact, he even kind of shuffles his left foot a bit so he can look like he took most of the force of the impact rather than deliver it.
So it is all of those things. It's a set up by Caruso, but Castle does commit the foul, Caruso does flop to exaggerate the contact, but it is an offensive foul. When you're playing a team that you KNOW plays this way, Castle has to be more aware of his positioning and where Caruso is.
For me that's fairly safely on the "smart but annoying basketball" side of the line compared to just outright flopping, and "smart but annoying" is basically Caruso's entire brand of basketball and it's made him rich as hell.
2 things:
I'm proud to have been on page 1 of this thread
he makes 20 million dollars a year - let that sink in for all the doubters
"I didn't come here to lose!" Charley Moran
Classic veteran basketball stuff. I doubt anyone here was mad about all the cheap fouls Taylor used to draw. He was a master of the cheap foul.
Oh I don't have a dog in the fight either. Like Bob says, it's one of the more annoying things about basketball. This is a bang bang play and the clip is in slow motion so naturally you're going to see things that are more obvious.
From the NBA rule book, A player must allow a moving opponent without the ball the opportunity to avoid contact if he moves into his path.
To me it's a non-call because both players are trying to get to a spot. Offensive calls are usually called when the defensive player gets hit in the chest which is not the case. AC rotated his shoulder to avoid contact just like Castle raised his hands to avoid a collision.
So we agree to disagree.
From the NBA rule book, A player must allow a moving opponent without the ball the opportunity to avoid contact if he moves into his path.
To me it's a non-call because both players are trying to get to a spot. Offensive calls are usually called when the defensive player gets hit in the chest which is not the case. AC rotated his shoulder to avoid contact just like Castle raised his hands to avoid a collision.
So we agree to disagree.
In slow motion I agree. It was bang bang play at full speed leaving a judgment call to the officials to discern…
Keep in mind:
https://official.nba.com/rule-no-13-instant-replay/
And this 2023 article providing some interpretation:
https://sportsfanfocus.com/can-you-review-a-foul-in-basketball/
Keep in mind:
https://official.nba.com/rule-no-13-instant-replay/
And this 2023 article providing some interpretation:
https://sportsfanfocus.com/can-you-review-a-foul-in-basketball/
Yeah, it's 100% not an angle of pursuit he would take in a regular season game and he would have avoided the contact. But in the playoffs and in the context of this series, he took a weird angle and forced the contact.
To me, a situation like that is a no call because it's clearly someone just seeking out contact for the sake of the contact.
To me, a situation like that is a no call because it's clearly someone just seeking out contact for the sake of the contact.
ATL Aggie said:LandArchSA said:
I like Caruso. I like the Spurs. I don't like Caruso against the Spurs. That kid can play and seems to step up every time they need him. Which I also don't like...
He's having a heck of a series. Averaging 17 points and 24 minutes. 56% from the floor and 58% from beyond the arc.
He's dragging his massive scrote all over San Antonio this series and that's what has half the posters up in arms.
People think I'm an idiot or something, because all I do is cut lawns for a living.
I won't pretend to know the NBA's replay rules but live, at court level, and especially assuming the official is primarily looking at the player with the ball I imagine the defender gets that call like 95 times out of 100.
Tonight's the night. MVP.
Not quite.
If the Spurs have to lose game 7, I will accept Caruso getting the WCF MVP over Shai just for the soul of basketball.
Caruso may play like a b* sometimes, but he's at least a hustle/grit role player who should play that way. Shai has all of the talent in the world and doesn't need to do half the stuff he does.
Caruso may play like a b* sometimes, but he's at least a hustle/grit role player who should play that way. Shai has all of the talent in the world and doesn't need to do half the stuff he does.
salvatore_ditmars said:it sounds like none of the things that factor in whether a good college player can make the NBA.Quote:
Caruso's FG% improved each year, going from 37% his freshman year to 50% his senior year. His 3P% increased each year from .265 to .368. His FT% increased each year from .600 to .785. His FT% jumped .10 his senior year, which is significaint. His true shooting % likewise increased each year from .451 to .598. His win shares and win shares/40min increaed each year.
Interestingly his usage rate was lowest his senior year, and by a fair margin.
Does this sound like a player who has already peaked?
i do enjoy the irony of the BYU fan coming to tell us how the scrappy white kid on our team was the best player on the team.
I enjoy the irony of the top pick in the next draft being a black guy from BYU.
Like all the Steve Blake and Manu Ginobli comparisons, we have to sort athletes into color-coded bins to compare them. Ridiculous.
Even scouts make this mistake. Caruso had off-the charts athleticism. So did Dan Majerle, Tom Chambers, and Rex Chapman. And Ryan Swope. In Swope's case, I heard one scout saying they didn't realize how fast he was until they went back and looked at film. How embarrassing for that scout. Teddy Bridgewater and Byron Leftwich were great dual-threat QBs...right? I mean they must be.
94chem,
That, sir, was the greatest post in the history of TexAgs. I salute you. -- Dough
That, sir, was the greatest post in the history of TexAgs. I salute you. -- Dough
CC09LawAg said:
If the Spurs have to lose game 7, I will accept Caruso getting the WCF MVP over Shai just for the soul of basketball.
Caruso may play like a b* sometimes, but he's at least a hustle/grit role player who should play that way. Shai has all of the talent in the world and doesn't need to do half the stuff he does.
Caruso invented the Two-Way NBA contract. No, seriously.
Well someone's gotta do it…
38 minutes
12 points on 3-14 shooting
1-6 3PT
5-6 FT
5 RB
4 AST
3 TO
1 BLK
1 PF
-5
38 minutes
12 points on 3-14 shooting
1-6 3PT
5-6 FT
5 RB
4 AST
3 TO
1 BLK
1 PF
-5
dave94 said:
Well someone's gotta do it…
38 minutes
12 points on 3-14 shooting
1-6 3PT
5-6 FT
5 RB
4 AST
3 TO
1 BLK
1 PF
-5
Now do Chet Holmgren.
94chem,
That, sir, was the greatest post in the history of TexAgs. I salute you. -- Dough
That, sir, was the greatest post in the history of TexAgs. I salute you. -- Dough
Well nobody was arguing that Chet was good lol
Featured Stories
See All
10:12
14h ago
8.3k
Moss roars as Texas A&M reaches regional final
by Richard Zane
9:50
15h ago
3.7k
Rapid Reaction: Offense dominates as Moss rolls vs. Texas State
by Ryan Brauninger
Photo Gallery: Marcel Reed's youth football camp
by Daniel Grant
LB Mikahi Allen took his Aggieland visit as July decision nears
by Jason Howell
15:03
1d ago
8.9k
A&M erases five-run deficit in regional-opening victory
by Richard Zane