Entertainment
Sponsored by

***** SURVIVOR 42 Thread *****

16,902 Views | 178 Replies | Last: 3 yr ago by tx1c
rhutton125
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think they're saying Rox went because he's black, but rather that because 2 of the 4 black players just went, I CAN'T go here and that's some pressure that the other players don't have to carry.

Glad they both played their idols so that it didn't directly influence the votes (so to speak). Like if you really wanted Dreya out but she scared you out of it via the race issue - well let's take that off the table entirely.

I hate any time they skip the vote, because that puts a different pressure on you that's kinda anti-Survivor (ie. maybe Lyndsey could have gotten enough votes but as soon as Dreya says Tori, Maryanne is really disincentivized to start whispering or signaling to pull someone else onto Lyndsey).
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
As crazy as Tori was early in the year, it was a real bummer she didn't throw out that they were only voting for her because she was white.
Tabasco
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
rhutton125 said:

Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think they're saying Rox went because he's black, but rather that because 2 of the 4 black players just went, I CAN'T go here and that's some pressure that the other players don't have to carry.

Glad they both played their idols so that it didn't directly influence the votes (so to speak). Like if you really wanted Dreya out but she scared you out of it via the race issue - well let's take that off the table entirely.

I hate any time they skip the vote, because that puts a different pressure on you that's kinda anti-Survivor (ie. maybe Lyndsey could have gotten enough votes but as soon as Dreya says Tori, Maryanne is really disincentivized to start whispering or signaling to pull someone else onto Lyndsey).


They 100% said Rocks went out because he was black, made false statements that blacks always get booted first (first 9 or so were non-black, and historically this is not a thing in survivor), and they literally said there is a "subconscious racism" or something that leads people to vote out blacks (rocks and drea both voted our black channel).
BayAg_14
How long do you want to ignore this user?
God forbid a minority gets voted out because they suck at the game. Been watching Survivor the last 15 years and about had it between that and the LGBTQ bs. Not sure I will be tuning in next season.
rhutton125
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I guess that's true but I think they backtracked on it. Like that there's an unconscious bias in the world but also they don't know what led to the Rox vote since they weren't there.

My takeaway (and I won't be revisiting it to confirm or anything) is that they have to deal with an extra layer of the game, unfortunately. I saw someone share a video from season 4 where Sean and Vicepia are talking about the same thing - they have to play the game of survivor, and then they also have to be hyper aware of being black because right now people will see them having a heart to heart and would probably say "they're allying, we need to take them out" when really it's just a conversation.

Either way, glad they played their idols. Having this conversation and then not playing the idols and getting away with it would have been ****ed.
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Now I really wish Rocksroy had done something horrifying to get voted off, like used a racial or homophobic slur himself. Oh well, on with the show.

Just waiting for Probst to introduce a special African-American Idol so the black person who does best at the next challenge can't be voted off.
achooooo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Helloimustbegoing; after listening to the whiny black racists pull the race card I said "nothing changes." Race had nothing to do with it but Probst loved to spur it on. Drew and Rocks VOTED for Chanel!!! Why didn't Jonathon nip this in the bud by bringing that up? Also, Drea did you know that 2 Asians, 1 black man and 1 white man voted out Rocks. Drea's and the "follow the leader" reaction from Maryann was the most vile, foul, unnecessarily racist and provocative move in the game; and CBS and Probst just love it. How about a new Survivor rule; you can't vote out Black people until all other races have been voted off. I have just written facts and voiced my opinion. Watch how long our "moderators" take to delete it. Elon Musk needs to buy Texags!
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm not sure if Probst loves it or not, I think he's just trying to avoid getting the Chris Harrison treatment.
achooooo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Helloimustbegoing, you may be right. It may just be CBS. If you watched Big Brother you saw a group of people applauded and complimented for forming a group based solely upon skin color and then voting out only people who did not share their skin color. It was nauseating to watch but it was even more nauseating to watch most people support such blatant racism. I just don't want Drea to get away with her race baiting hypocrisy; remember she, together with Rocks, voted Chanel of the show!
Rudyjax
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Haven't watched yet but saw some comments and read this thread. Worth watching?
achooooo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Aye Davanita, it's like watching a car crash with no blood. Just race card playing at its worst. Worth watching though; 2 weeks ago there were 5 blacks, 4 whites, and 2 Asians. Two blacks were voted off which included votes by other blacks. Drea being one of them. Drea then gets down and dirty. At least her black ally, Maryann, didn't vote for Chanel, but she sure jumped on the race train with Drea. When the only white man spoke up he was told the usual " you just don't understand" line. Sorry, Drea, we all understand. One article about the episode said that Jonathon (the white man) was from Alabama so he really would struggle with understanding Drea's point. This episode ruined Survivor for me. I stopped watching Big Brother after several episodes of watching a group of racists set up an alliance.
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Aye Davanita said:

Haven't watched yet but saw some comments and read this thread. Worth watching?
Watch the first 40 minutes. The immunity challenge is fantastic.
OKCAG02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jonathan is such a beast.
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
OKCAG02 said:

Jonathan is such a beast.
I know the dude makes his life on the water, but being able to balance on that little platform at his size is nuts.

Going to his hometown of Gulf Shores this summer. If we see him, going to have him carry our car from the hotel to the beach and back.
emoney
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I just didn't see the episode like a lot of people saw it. Sure, I eyerolled during some of it (which I expected before the season because this is happening directly after season 41) but it wasn't as bad as lot of people are making it. If it is enough for you to stop watching the show, then you probably had two feet out of the door and weren't going to continue watching it anyway.

You might not like the way Drea reacted in that tribal but she was right about the fact that she needed to use her idol that night because she didn't want to be the next one out which she was going to be if she didn't play it. I know she mentioned Chanelle but what triggered her reaction was Rocksroy being taken out. She had every reason to be shocked because in her eyes, they had a solid 7 (Omer, Hai, Mike, Rocks, Lindsay, Jonathan and Drea), they were separated to the point where they had the majority in both groups plus Hai and Romeo (the only one in the other group who wasn't in her alliance) were not getting along before they split into two groups. There is no reason to think there would be anyone else sitting next to Chanelle but Romeo. If there is one person in that alliance who would never turn on her or the alliance, it would be Rocksroy because he was the only one who was loyal in their original tribe but what Drea doesn't know is he was most loyal to the guys alliance that he "assembled" earlier in the day.

I believe if the groups went in reverse, Rocksroy might be surprised to see Drea voted out over Tori but I don't think he is bothered as much because his #1 alliance would not have been affected like Drea's was.

Since Drea was going to use her idol, Maryanne had no choice but to use hers . I know they brought up race and in the past some of what they said was true but I don't think they were saying Chanelle was voted out because she was black because some have said, Drea was in on it and Maryanne was in on getting Drea out but after seeing Rocks surprisingly out over Romeo and how Drea reacted, what else is she going to do? Maryanne has already shown us she is very emotional. Look how she reacted when Jackson was going home. I think she felt bad at that point to vote out Drea right there which isn't possible anyway because she said she was going to play her idol. I am really curious if Drea was playing from a position of strength dropping her idol like that because losing that idol doesn't do anything. She can steal Mike's idol whenever she feels like it at this point. Tori was voted out because she was on the outs due to the face she was too loyal to Swahi which is the only reason why Tori was trying to get Drea out in the first place.

I said it last season and this season makes me feel like it's true even though some disagree. Alliances based on race is no different than alliances based on sex. It doesn't make them racist or sexist. In the end, the alliance will not survive in a game like Survivor based on either sex or race alone. If they don't get along socially, they will turn on each other and drop like flies one by one. It is why girls' alliances rarely work in the game and why Rocksroy's guy alliance ended so quickly because of what Omer said. He had no connection with Rocksroy so there is no point in aligning with him just because he is a guy, especially since he had better options while Rocks had none.

I hated to see Tori go out like that though. She made some mistakes in the game but some of the reasons why she wasn't trusted weren't completely her fault but i guess that's the game. I wasn't a fan of Rocksroy and he 100% is the reason why he got voted out.
achooooo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
emoney, you must be the most Christian man I've ever seen post.
Brandamne
How long do you want to ignore this user?
White man bad!
rhutton125
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I have one other thought. From a quick scan of the 41 Survivor winners, 21 are white males, 11 are white females, and only 9 are minorities of either gender (3 of which came from "diverse" seasons like S41 or the Race Wars season). A big part of that, I think, is that for the longest time - even up to season 39 - the vast majority of the contestants were white.

So while I don't think that played into this week's tribal, I do think it's something minority contestants are hyper aware of when they go on the show. Seasons are diverse now, but you see the people of your ethnicity dropping like flies and you just have to take that into account. It's an added layer to an already ultra-layered game that (unless you're the dumb players from Big Brother last year) white contestants don't really have to consider while playing. Not saying Survivor is unfair at all, but the history of Survivor plays into the present in various ways. No season is truly in a bubble.

It's kind of ****ed, but if I (as a white man) were on the show, it'd be real tempting to just be a fear-monger. "We can't let them have an all-female alliance," "the two black players are getting too close, we need to vote one off," etc. But for 38 of the 42 seasons, if I went and talked to the other white guys, it wouldn't set off any alarms because us white guys would make up 40% of the cast already.

Hopefully, with the diverse casting policy, you'll eventually hear less and less of this. And any race-related drama would be based on overt in-game racism and not in-the-real-world perceptions, history or issues.
achooooo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rhuton125, you may be right. Time will tell. I also understand your point about how a minority would feel on a show with a majority of whites. This country has been through a lot of racial strife over the last few years. It really angered me to see it falsely stirred up on a prime tv show. Especially when Drea and Rocks had voted for Chanel. They knew race had nothing to do with it. Prior to that vote the majority of the players were black. To their credit, they were not racists like the blacks on Big Brother. I assume that race was never an issue in this season prior to Drew's blathering because you know CBS would have played it up.
Furlock Bones
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Background. I've never watched a full season of survivor until I found out paramount+ had them. So I binged season 30 to understand the show before getting into this one "live". I'm a white guy. Classically Fairly middle of the road which paints me as a right wing extremist these days.

I thought Drea's and Maryann's talk and idol move was fairly powerful. That actually seemed like Drea's first true emotion on the show. Maryann came off has incredibly poignant.


Anyway Tori is gone and that's a great thing. I never liked her from the beginning. I'm a therapist and I know people except myself.
KCup17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Who goes home tonight?

I think Drea has a great shot at winning it at the moment. I think Hai wont be able to get out of his own way and will get blindsided because he doesn't let other people drive.
Rudyjax
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I got screwed by not being able to reset my choices.
Rudyjax
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
helloimustbegoing messaged me and said they were taking a break on Texags. Can someone help with the scoring? I'm 2 weeks behind.
OKCAG02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jonathan is surprisingly good at balance challenges. I think he would sure won that one if not for his feet being so big.
Southlake
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Damn, it would be awesome to see Tribal before editing.
KCup17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Well... well... well.. looks like we have a new sheriff in town now.
Furlock Bones
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Omar out there making moves. Also, how did Lindsay miss that idol. Maryanne is now sitting pretty.
KCup17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I can't see Maryanne making it much father. I bet she gets blindsided and goes home with a idol in her pocket.
emoney
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think Maryanne could make it to the final four maybe, even though I don't think she has much of a chance to win right now. There's no reason to blindside her unless they find out she has the idol. There are bigger targets to get out before her. Also who were you referring to as being the new sheriff in your earlier post?
Tabasco
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Great episode, great tribal.
rhutton125
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Man Romeo sucks.

I think it goes Omar > Lindsay > Jonathan > Mike >> Maryanne >>>> Romeo. Romeo is going to be sitting up there with two strong players.
Southlake
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
So, after Tribal last night, everyone was all lovey dovey and smiling. They had a big love fest and Drea got to visit and hug everybody, chat with other players, make jokes with Jeff and everything is just a fun game ( as emphasized by Jeff), something that never happens at Tribal; usually it's a word or two and "The tribe has spoken - goodbye!" a far cry from the animosity and race baiting from last week when Drea complained about Blacks getting voted out early saying she couldn't vote out another Black person. Maryanne claimed the same thing but ironically, Maryanne voted Drea out this week!!
rhutton125
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think two weeks ago was "damn, two black people in a row. I can't in good conscience make it 3 straight." Not that they'd never vote a black player off again.

I do think it's interesting that Drea had more energy and personality in those 2 minutes than she had all season. The exhaustion - and the edit - are real! You hear about people like Jonathan who just get miserable at a certain point, but then you also hear about players that people love to death but you just don't see any of that loveable personality on TV, unfortunately. Wonder which was more impactful for Drea.
KCup17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I was referring to Omar. Until that point I think Hai had been running the show.
emoney
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think Drea was good with everyone for a reason. They also never showed us that she was working closely with Hai and Omar. We only see what the edit wants us to see. I have to think the way Drea was is in those 2 minutes was the Drea they all saw on the island throughout the season.

Kcup, I figured you were referring to Omar. I feel like he has been running the show since Chantelle was voted out and used Hai to deliver the idea to everyone else. Now all of the cards are on the table and Omar is fully exposed. I'm hoping he doesn't get Cerie'd in Advantageddon with three idols, immunity and a shot in the dark at play.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.