Entertainment
Sponsored by

Colbert & Talarico vs the FCC

16,513 Views | 433 Replies | Last: 22 hrs ago by CharleyKerfeld
Aggie_Journalist
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Stephen Colbert was told by CBS' lawyers that he could not interview U.S. Senate Candidate James Talarico live on air because of threats from FCC chair Brendan Carr, who opened a probe into The View for broadcasting an interview with Talarico. Colbert was also told not to mention this on air, which he did anyway.


Then he interviewed Talarico - but on YouTube instead of live TV. Here is the interview:
schmendeler
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Pretty crazy times we are living in
wangus12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Its ridiculous honestly. I don't like Colbert, but the government overreach we have right now is absurd
javajaws
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
wangus12 said:

Its ridiculous honestly. I don't like Colbert, but the government overreach we have right now is absurd

I don't like government overreach either, but what makes you think this is new? As I understand it this is based on long-standing policy as part of using these airwaves (need to provide equal opportunity for both parties). As alluded to doing this over youtube, etc there is no issue.
maverick2076
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wangus12 said:

Its ridiculous honestly. I don't like Colbert, but the government overreach we have right now is absurd


Yeah, I really hate it when the government enforces laws duly passed by Congress.
schmendeler
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
javajaws said:

wangus12 said:

Its ridiculous honestly. I don't like Colbert, but the government overreach we have right now is absurd

I don't like government overreach either, but what makes you think this is new? As I understand it this is based on long-standing policy as part of using these airwaves (need to provide equal opportunity for both parties). As alluded to doing this over youtube, etc there is no issue.



Your understanding is incorrect. Talk shows are exempted from an equal time rule. It's due to pressure from the FCC. It's part of a pattern.
wangus12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quad Dog
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Streisand Effect strikes again. By trying to kill this, the FCC guaranteed more people would watch it.
keithd03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Late night talk shows are not automatically exempt
1981 Monte Carlo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.
schmendeler
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
keithd03 said:

Late night talk shows are not automatically exempt


But if doing an interview, they are
wangus12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

That's every politician.
keithd03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Somewhat learning as I go here but I don't believe interviews are exempt.

"Importantly, the FCC has not been presented with any evidence that the interview portion of any late night or daytime television talk show program on air presently would qualify for the bona fide news exemption," the FCC said in a public notice Wednesday.
1981 Monte Carlo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wangus12 said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

That's every politician.

Yeah, just about. But it's worse when it's a politician who wants to take more from you, and also make the city more dangerous for your loved ones. One who says we need to take in unvetted third world bangers because the Bible is against borders and Jesus wouldn't have turned anyone away, or some such completely made up nonsense.
schmendeler
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
1981 Monte Carlo said:

wangus12 said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

That's every politician.

Yeah, just about. But it's worse when it's a politician who wants to take more from you, and also make the city more dangerous for your loved ones. One who says we need to take in unvetted third world bangers because the Bible is against borders and Jesus wouldn't have turned anyone away, or some such completely made up nonsense.


Jesus was famously in favor of refusing to help strangers
1981 Monte Carlo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I also love Democrats complaining about the equal-time-rule and "fairness doctrine" stuff when it was their leaders who advocated for such things...when in reality, it should have been the GOP pushing for it, given the long standing prevailing biased for the left in the media and entertainment industry.
1981 Monte Carlo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
schmendeler said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

wangus12 said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

That's every politician.

Yeah, just about. But it's worse when it's a politician who wants to take more from you, and also make the city more dangerous for your loved ones. One who says we need to take in unvetted third world bangers because the Bible is against borders and Jesus wouldn't have turned anyone away, or some such completely made up nonsense.


Jesus was famously in favor of refusing to help strangers

I am all for helping strangers. Do it quite often and you can tell it's good for the soul. Statistically, conservatives are actually FAR more generous with their money and time when it comes to such charitable causes.

I am talking about letting millions of unvetted people, including countless violent criminals stream across your borders...while many law abiding immigrants go through the process to do things the right way.
Ervin Burrell
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
schmendeler said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

wangus12 said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

That's every politician.

Yeah, just about. But it's worse when it's a politician who wants to take more from you, and also make the city more dangerous for your loved ones. One who says we need to take in unvetted third world bangers because the Bible is against borders and Jesus wouldn't have turned anyone away, or some such completely made up nonsense.


Jesus was famously in favor of refusing to help strangers

Loving thy neighbor is communism.
1981 Monte Carlo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ervin Burrell said:

schmendeler said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

wangus12 said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

That's every politician.

Yeah, just about. But it's worse when it's a politician who wants to take more from you, and also make the city more dangerous for your loved ones. One who says we need to take in unvetted third world bangers because the Bible is against borders and Jesus wouldn't have turned anyone away, or some such completely made up nonsense.


Jesus was famously in favor of refusing to help strangers

Helping thy neighbor is communism.

See my above post. This is such a lazy and childish take.

Wanting borders and immigration law to exist and be enforced is not immoral. Or else just about every country throughout the world is evil/racist/fascist.
M.C. Swag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

lol based on what? Was he caught on a hot mic bragging about assaulting a woman? Was he found civilly liable for misappropriating charity funds? Or you just don't like his opinions so you think that makes him a snake?
1981 Monte Carlo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
M.C. Swag said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

lol based on what? Was he caught on a hot mic bragging about assaulting a woman? Was he found civilly liable for misappropriating charity funds? Or you just don't like his opinions so you think that makes him a snake?

He is constantly lying and using twisted Christian doctrine to support things like erasing our borders...and paint anyone who believes in borders and an actual legal immigration process as bigoted and "unchristian". If you start to pick up on his lies, you can see that his pious act is just an act. He's brilliant and cunning though, and has a very bright future...I genuinely think he may be the face of the democrat party within the next 10 years.

He is marketing himself as a moderate and as a civil person who "loves everyone from both sides". It's brilliant and it will work. Fully expect him to be president in my lifetime. Congrats on that, even though I detest him and everything he truly stands for.
schmendeler
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
1981 Monte Carlo said:

M.C. Swag said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

lol based on what? Was he caught on a hot mic bragging about assaulting a woman? Was he found civilly liable for misappropriating charity funds? Or you just don't like his opinions so you think that makes him a snake?

He is constantly lying and using twisted Christian doctrine to support things like erasing our borders...and paint anyone who believes in borders and an actual legal immigration process as bigoted and "unchristian". If you start to pick up on his lies, you can see that his pious act is just an act. He's brilliant and cunning though, and has a very bright future...I genuinely think he may be the face of the democrat party within the next 10 years.


What are these "constant" lies?
safety guy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Here's the problem with all politicians now. They may say and believe things before being elected, but after getting elected, they become trapped by the party and special interests.
Ragoo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
schmendeler said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

wangus12 said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

That's every politician.

Yeah, just about. But it's worse when it's a politician who wants to take more from you, and also make the city more dangerous for your loved ones. One who says we need to take in unvetted third world bangers because the Bible is against borders and Jesus wouldn't have turned anyone away, or some such completely made up nonsense.


Jesus was famously in favor of refusing to help strangers
jesus helped strangers and the poor as a metaphor of God's love for all mankind.

Jesus lived in a time where King's ruled over all men in absolute worse conditions that is fathomable today in western society. Yet, he made zero advocacy for contempt against the Kings or revolution to overthrow their rule.

Using piety or religion in general as justification for socialistic ideals is false doctrine.
Quad Dog
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
1981 Monte Carlo said:

M.C. Swag said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

lol based on what? Was he caught on a hot mic bragging about assaulting a woman? Was he found civilly liable for misappropriating charity funds? Or you just don't like his opinions so you think that makes him a snake?

He is constantly lying and using twisted Christian doctrine to support things like erasing our borders...and paint anyone who believes in borders and an actual legal immigration process as bigoted and "unchristian". If you start to pick up on his lies, you can see that his pious act is just an act. He's brilliant and cunning though, and has a very bright future...I genuinely think he may be the face of the democrat party within the next 10 years.

He is marketing himself as a moderate and as a civil person who "loves everyone from both sides". It's brilliant and it will work. Fully expect him to be president in my lifetime. Congrats on that, even though I detest him and everything he truly stands for.

"erasing borders" is a pretty big mischaracterization of his opinions on immigration.
https://jamestalarico.com/issue/immigration-border-security/
Ervin Burrell
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
1981 Monte Carlo said:

M.C. Swag said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

lol based on what? Was he caught on a hot mic bragging about assaulting a woman? Was he found civilly liable for misappropriating charity funds? Or you just don't like his opinions so you think that makes him a snake?

He is constantly lying and using twisted Christian doctrine to support things like erasing our borders...and paint anyone who believes in borders and an actual legal immigration process as bigoted and "unchristian". If you start to pick up on his lies, you can see that his pious act is just an act. He's brilliant and cunning though, and has a very bright future...I genuinely think he may be the face of the democrat party within the next 10 years.

He is marketing himself as a moderate and as a civil person who "loves everyone from both sides". It's brilliant and it will work. Fully expect him to be president in my lifetime. Congrats on that, even though I detest him and everything he truly stands for.

There's no hate like Christian love.
M.C. Swag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
1981 Monte Carlo said:

M.C. Swag said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

lol based on what? Was he caught on a hot mic bragging about assaulting a woman? Was he found civilly liable for misappropriating charity funds? Or you just don't like his opinions so you think that makes him a snake?

He is constantly lying and using twisted Christian doctrine to support things like erasing our borders...and paint anyone who believes in borders and an actual legal immigration process as bigoted and "unchristian". If you start to pick up on his lies, you can see that his pious act is just an act. He's brilliant and cunning though, and has a very bright future...I genuinely think he may be the face of the democrat party within the next 10 years.

He is marketing himself as a moderate and as a civil person who "loves everyone from both sides". It's brilliant and it will work. Fully expect him to be president in my lifetime. Congrats on that, even though I detest him and everything he truly stands for.

Sounds like you just disagree with his interpretations of a thousand year old book written by anonymous men. I asked, why is Talarico a snake? What evidence do you have to show he's duplicitous or a man of low moral character? (Differences of Biblical interpretations are not evidence of moral failing)
1981 Monte Carlo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
schmendeler said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

M.C. Swag said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

lol based on what? Was he caught on a hot mic bragging about assaulting a woman? Was he found civilly liable for misappropriating charity funds? Or you just don't like his opinions so you think that makes him a snake?

He is constantly lying and using twisted Christian doctrine to support things like erasing our borders...and paint anyone who believes in borders and an actual legal immigration process as bigoted and "unchristian". If you start to pick up on his lies, you can see that his pious act is just an act. He's brilliant and cunning though, and has a very bright future...I genuinely think he may be the face of the democrat party within the next 10 years.


What are these "constant" lies?

You'd have to listen to him in long form discussion. I listened to him on Rogan a few months ago...I can't just rattle off all of the specific lies, but it's less about technical fouls, and more about dishonestly framing things, and operating off of false narratives to begin with. Like I said, he is very brilliant and cunning and will absolutely appeal to the low info soccer moms, and many others who don't know about the evils and ill effects of socialism (which he pretends not to be). He is great at painting the other side (people like me and my brown wife) as inherently racist/bigoted/ignorant/heartless/fascist in a very civil manner - as opposed to the Rashida Talib and AOC types, while projecting that he loves them and is not giving up on them lol.

I have to give him props, it is a highly effective strategy and he is super intelligent, calculated, and devoted. WIll pay off for him.

Obviously you are naturally going to think everything he does and says is great. You're little "gotcha" attempts like "Jesus was obviously against helping strangers" tells me all I need to know. He would make the same response to me, but in a much more polished and intelligent manner.

schmendeler
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ragoo said:

schmendeler said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

wangus12 said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

That's every politician.

Yeah, just about. But it's worse when it's a politician who wants to take more from you, and also make the city more dangerous for your loved ones. One who says we need to take in unvetted third world bangers because the Bible is against borders and Jesus wouldn't have turned anyone away, or some such completely made up nonsense.


Jesus was famously in favor of refusing to help strangers
jesus helped strangers and the poor as a metaphor of God's love for all mankind.

Jesus lived in a time where King's ruled over all men in absolute worse conditions that is fathomable today in western society. Yet, he made zero advocacy for contempt against the Kings or revolution to overthrow their rule.

Using piety or religion in general as justification for socialistic ideals is false doctrine.


It's only ok to use religion for things like going after trans people, or gay marriage, or putting the ten commandments in classrooms, or banning abortion. Things like helping people in need is totally against the example (sorry, metaphor) of Christ.
schmendeler
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
1981 Monte Carlo said:

schmendeler said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

M.C. Swag said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

lol based on what? Was he caught on a hot mic bragging about assaulting a woman? Was he found civilly liable for misappropriating charity funds? Or you just don't like his opinions so you think that makes him a snake?

He is constantly lying and using twisted Christian doctrine to support things like erasing our borders...and paint anyone who believes in borders and an actual legal immigration process as bigoted and "unchristian". If you start to pick up on his lies, you can see that his pious act is just an act. He's brilliant and cunning though, and has a very bright future...I genuinely think he may be the face of the democrat party within the next 10 years.


What are these "constant" lies?

You'd have to listen to him in long form discussion. I listened to him on Rogan a few months ago...I can't just rattle off all of the specific lies, but it's less about technical fouls, and more about dishonestly framing things, and operating off of false narratives to begin with. Like I said, he is very brilliant and cunning and will absolutely appeal to the low info soccer moms, and many others who don't know about the evils and ill effects of socialism (which he pretends not to be). He is great at painting the other side (people like me and my brown wife) as inherently racist/bigoted/ignorant/heartless/fascist in a very civil manner - as opposed to the Rashida Talib and AOC types, while projecting that he loves them and is not giving up on them lol.

I have to give him props, it is a highly effective strategy and he is super intelligent, calculated, and devoted. WIll pay off for him.

Obviously you are naturally going to think everything he does and says is great. You're little "gotcha" attempts like "Jesus was obviously against helping strangers" tells me all I need to know. He would make the same response to me, but in a much more polished and intelligent manner.




So, not even one lie?
1981 Monte Carlo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
M.C. Swag said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

M.C. Swag said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

lol based on what? Was he caught on a hot mic bragging about assaulting a woman? Was he found civilly liable for misappropriating charity funds? Or you just don't like his opinions so you think that makes him a snake?

He is constantly lying and using twisted Christian doctrine to support things like erasing our borders...and paint anyone who believes in borders and an actual legal immigration process as bigoted and "unchristian". If you start to pick up on his lies, you can see that his pious act is just an act. He's brilliant and cunning though, and has a very bright future...I genuinely think he may be the face of the democrat party within the next 10 years.

He is marketing himself as a moderate and as a civil person who "loves everyone from both sides". It's brilliant and it will work. Fully expect him to be president in my lifetime. Congrats on that, even though I detest him and everything he truly stands for.

Sounds like you just disagree with his interpretations of a thousand year old book written by anonymous men. I asked, why is Talarico a snake? What evidence do you have to show he's duplicitous or a man of low moral character? (Differences of Biblical interpretations are not evidence of moral failing)

No, I think his interpretations are simply intentionally dishonest and politically calculated. His Biblical knowledge is actually horrendous...but he is very polished and intelligent, so only those who are pretty adept would pick up on it.

Anyways, I am probably going to catch a ban so won't engage any further. These politically oriented threads on the Entertainment board are like a honeypot. They always get me.
Ervin Burrell
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ragoo said:

schmendeler said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

wangus12 said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

That's every politician.

Yeah, just about. But it's worse when it's a politician who wants to take more from you, and also make the city more dangerous for your loved ones. One who says we need to take in unvetted third world bangers because the Bible is against borders and Jesus wouldn't have turned anyone away, or some such completely made up nonsense.


Jesus was famously in favor of refusing to help strangers

jesus helped strangers and the poor as a metaphor of God's love for all mankind.

Jesus lived in a time where King's ruled over all men in absolute worse conditions that is fathomable today in western society. Yet, he made zero advocacy for contempt against the Kings or revolution to overthrow their rule.

Using piety or religion in general as justification for socialistic ideals is false doctrine.

Someone tell that to the folks trying to put the Ten Commandments in classrooms. Or is that "different?"
M.C. Swag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
1981 Monte Carlo said:

M.C. Swag said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

M.C. Swag said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

lol based on what? Was he caught on a hot mic bragging about assaulting a woman? Was he found civilly liable for misappropriating charity funds? Or you just don't like his opinions so you think that makes him a snake?

He is constantly lying and using twisted Christian doctrine to support things like erasing our borders...and paint anyone who believes in borders and an actual legal immigration process as bigoted and "unchristian". If you start to pick up on his lies, you can see that his pious act is just an act. He's brilliant and cunning though, and has a very bright future...I genuinely think he may be the face of the democrat party within the next 10 years.

He is marketing himself as a moderate and as a civil person who "loves everyone from both sides". It's brilliant and it will work. Fully expect him to be president in my lifetime. Congrats on that, even though I detest him and everything he truly stands for.

Sounds like you just disagree with his interpretations of a thousand year old book written by anonymous men. I asked, why is Talarico a snake? What evidence do you have to show he's duplicitous or a man of low moral character? (Differences of Biblical interpretations are not evidence of moral failing)

No, I think his interpretations are simply intentionally dishonest and politically calculated. His Biblical knowledge is actually horrendous...but he is very polished and intelligent, so only those who are pretty adept would pick up on it.

Anyways, I am probably going to catch a ban so won't engage any further. These politically oriented threads on the Entertainment board are like a honeypot. They always get me.

You attacked a man's character and then retreated the instant you were challenged to support those attacks with substance. Just say you disagree with his policies. Like, not every political race has to be this Ultimate Good vs Embodiment of Evil showdown.
Gigem314
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
1981 Monte Carlo said:

One who says we need to take in unvetted third world bangers because the Bible is against borders and Jesus wouldn't have turned anyone away, or some such completely made up nonsense.

Ah, yes. The "He Gets Us" commercial mindset. Unless we have no laws and let people do whatever they want, then we're not being compassionate or helpful enough and should feel bad about it.

The grifters know what kind of language to use for trying to emotionally guilt others into supporting them.
1981 Monte Carlo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quad Dog said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

M.C. Swag said:

1981 Monte Carlo said:

Talarico is awful. A complete snake. People are too easily fooled by his "aw shucks-y" howdy doody face and demeanor. He has a bright future, unfortunately.

lol based on what? Was he caught on a hot mic bragging about assaulting a woman? Was he found civilly liable for misappropriating charity funds? Or you just don't like his opinions so you think that makes him a snake?

He is constantly lying and using twisted Christian doctrine to support things like erasing our borders...and paint anyone who believes in borders and an actual legal immigration process as bigoted and "unchristian". If you start to pick up on his lies, you can see that his pious act is just an act. He's brilliant and cunning though, and has a very bright future...I genuinely think he may be the face of the democrat party within the next 10 years.

He is marketing himself as a moderate and as a civil person who "loves everyone from both sides". It's brilliant and it will work. Fully expect him to be president in my lifetime. Congrats on that, even though I detest him and everything he truly stands for.

"erasing borders" is a pretty big mischaracterization of his opinions on immigration.
https://jamestalarico.com/issue/immigration-border-security/

Yeah ok...I mean obviously no one is going to run on literally erasing all borders. Listen to his podcast with Rogan. He advocates for very very open borders. Cloaked in "what would Jesus do" compassion as the prime motivator.

He knows that liberals aren't hardly breeding at all, and that many are taking themselves out of the gene pool altogether with their lifestyles...that the ONLY way for the democrat party to survive is to hammer people while young in the education system, but also flood the country with poor immigrants and get them hooked on the government teet in hopes of making them generational democrats. This is the playbook. He is just way better at not revealing his hand, while the screaming AOC's and Ilhan Omar's of the world are so obvious and loud, they scare many more reasonable people away.

Anyways, Talarico is a rising star and will be POTUS someday and congrats. I'm out.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.