Political fallout and arguments regarding the US-Israeli action against Iran 022824

595,758 Views | 6112 Replies | Last: 1 hr ago by OPAG
Phatbob
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
You tried too hard with that one. GL next time though
Keyno
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBetI'll go and try to find it when you admit you were wrong and simply eat crow on Trump's ground war that you are overtly ignoring for some reason. said:

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Why are you trying to change the subject? I am perfectly capable of using google to find the evidence for the claim you made, and there just doesn't seem to be any evidence. Hence why I am asking you.

I'm not. I've been asking you for a few days now and you simply refuse to acknowledge you were wrong on that claim. Why can't you simply acknowledge you were wrong about Trump's Ground War?

I'll try to find the earlier posts on Lebanon.

Thank you. As of this moment in time, I was wrong about the ground war. I made that claim a few months ago during a massive ground troop build up we were doing. It seems, at this moment in time, that a ground operation will not be happening, thank God. Delicious crow.

Now, I would really like evidence to support your claim that " Yes, as of this morning and you conveniently didn't reply until the President of Lebanon did a 180 on his position. Until today, they were working with Israel to help them purge Hez from Lebanon.'"

The official position of the Lebanese government is that they do not even recognize Israel as a state, have no diplomatic relations with them, and are technically at war with them. So your claim would be very interesting and groundbreaking, if true

And thank you.

Best I can do with my initial search:

Quote:

[From March] Lebanese President Joseph Aoun offered to hold direct negotiations with Israel for the first time since the 1982 Israeli invasion during Lebanon's civil war. Aoun also asked for a boost in funding for Lebanese troops and reaffirmed his commitment to disarm Hezbollah, a longstanding Israeli and U.S. demand.



That is definitely NOT evidence that "until today, they [the Lebanese government] were working with Israel to help them purge Hez from Lebanon"

These talks have a strictly limited agenda. They are focused on the immediate conflict between Lebanon and Israel. The stated goal is a "cessation of hostilities," the release of hostages, the full withdrawal of Israeli troops, and establishing security zones for the Lebanese Armed Forces.

Lebanese President Joseph Aoun and Prime Minister Nawaf Salam have explicitly emphasized that the talks DO NOT signal a normalization of relations with Israel. Lebanon actually still has a 1955 law on the books which PREVENTS Lebanese citizens and state officials from having any contact with Israelis; and these talks had to get explicit state authorization to occur.

So yeah, I often see the claim that "the Lebanese government wants Israel's help, or is working with Israel, to take out Hezbollah" thrown around erroneously on this board. It is not based in reality or backed by any evidence. Lebanon has technically been at war with Israel since 1948.
Ag with kids
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BlackGold said:

Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

AGHouston11 said:

Does anyone really believe Bibi is not going to sabotage this anyway possible?
It's been the same pattern the whole time.


Right... dealing with Hezbolah, a terrorist organization lobbying bombs at civilian targets, is the problem...

There's no reason for that to ever be allowed to be part of the discussion. It's a complete win for Iran to try to legitimize and cement their terror proxies when they are being ripped out.

Israel is currently invading and occupying territory in Lebanon and is bombing civilian targets in Beirut.

They are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah. We all know where you get your propaganda from, so we can forego the "Israel targets civilians" garbage.

Propoganda? Both Trump and Vance have criticized Israel for bombing civilian targets in the last 48 hours.

So what? Trump and Vance don't get to tell Israel how best to defend themselves. This is 100% on Iran and their proxy in Hezbolla. They were given the orders by the Islamic regime to attack Israel to provoke a response to give them cover to break the memorandum. They will never deal in good faith.

And it's propaganda.


Why would the US not tell Israel what to do? We literally pay for their entire military and give them all of their weapons. If we didn't subsidize their entire country, then I would agree we shouldn't tell them how to manage their business.

You do realize that the entire Iron Dome and the Arrow missiles are 100% Israeli developed, right?

So, not all their weapons...
You can turn off signatures, btw
BlackGold
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

AGHouston11 said:

Does anyone really believe Bibi is not going to sabotage this anyway possible?
It's been the same pattern the whole time.


Right... dealing with Hezbolah, a terrorist organization lobbying bombs at civilian targets, is the problem...

There's no reason for that to ever be allowed to be part of the discussion. It's a complete win for Iran to try to legitimize and cement their terror proxies when they are being ripped out.

Israel is currently invading and occupying territory in Lebanon and is bombing civilian targets in Beirut.

They are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah. We all know where you get your propaganda from, so we can forego the "Israel targets civilians" garbage.

Propoganda? Both Trump and Vance have criticized Israel for bombing civilian targets in the last 48 hours.

So what? Trump and Vance don't get to tell Israel how best to defend themselves. This is 100% on Iran and their proxy in Hezbolla. They were given the orders by the Islamic regime to attack Israel to provoke a response to give them cover to break the memorandum. They will never deal in good faith.

And it's propaganda.


Why would the US not tell Israel what to do? We literally pay for their entire military and give them all of their weapons. If we didn't subsidize their entire country, then I would agree we shouldn't tell them how to manage their business.

You do realize that the entire Iron Dome and the Arrow missiles are 100% Israeli developed, right?

So, not all their weapons...


Developed using whose tax dollars? I believe that would be the American taxpayer's.
UTExan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BlackGold said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

AGHouston11 said:

Does anyone really believe Bibi is not going to sabotage this anyway possible?
It's been the same pattern the whole time.


Right... dealing with Hezbolah, a terrorist organization lobbying bombs at civilian targets, is the problem...

There's no reason for that to ever be allowed to be part of the discussion. It's a complete win for Iran to try to legitimize and cement their terror proxies when they are being ripped out.

Israel is currently invading and occupying territory in Lebanon and is bombing civilian targets in Beirut.

They are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah. We all know where you get your propaganda from, so we can forego the "Israel targets civilians" garbage.

Propoganda? Both Trump and Vance have criticized Israel for bombing civilian targets in the last 48 hours.

So what? Trump and Vance don't get to tell Israel how best to defend themselves. This is 100% on Iran and their proxy in Hezbolla. They were given the orders by the Islamic regime to attack Israel to provoke a response to give them cover to break the memorandum. They will never deal in good faith.

And it's propaganda.


Why would the US not tell Israel what to do? We literally pay for their entire military and give them all of their weapons. If we didn't subsidize their entire country, then I would agree we shouldn't tell them how to manage their business.

You do realize that the entire Iron Dome and the Arrow missiles are 100% Israeli developed, right?

So, not all their weapons...


Developed using whose tax dollars? I believe that would be the American taxpayer's.

Their real time experience helps us develop our weapons. Their intelligence is invaluable to us in the region. They provide bases and logistical infrastructure for us because they are a 1st world nation. I have problems with Israelis just taking over Palestinian owned land but that doesn't negate their value to us as an ally against Iran, Hezbollah and the cast of psychopaths extant in the Middle East.
“If you’re going to have crime it should at least be organized crime”
-Havelock Vetinari
AGHouston11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BlackGold said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

AGHouston11 said:

Does anyone really believe Bibi is not going to sabotage this anyway possible?
It's been the same pattern the whole time.


Right... dealing with Hezbolah, a terrorist organization lobbying bombs at civilian targets, is the problem...

There's no reason for that to ever be allowed to be part of the discussion. It's a complete win for Iran to try to legitimize and cement their terror proxies when they are being ripped out.

Israel is currently invading and occupying territory in Lebanon and is bombing civilian targets in Beirut.

They are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah. We all know where you get your propaganda from, so we can forego the "Israel targets civilians" garbage.

Propoganda? Both Trump and Vance have criticized Israel for bombing civilian targets in the last 48 hours.

So what? Trump and Vance don't get to tell Israel how best to defend themselves. This is 100% on Iran and their proxy in Hezbolla. They were given the orders by the Islamic regime to attack Israel to provoke a response to give them cover to break the memorandum. They will never deal in good faith.

And it's propaganda.


Why would the US not tell Israel what to do? We literally pay for their entire military and give them all of their weapons. If we didn't subsidize their entire country, then I would agree we shouldn't tell them how to manage their business.

You do realize that the entire Iron Dome and the Arrow missiles are 100% Israeli developed, right?

So, not all their weapons...


Developed using whose tax dollars? I believe that would be the American taxpayer's.


It was billions of US tax dollars BUT they also didn't develop it by themselves! The US also participated in the development.
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
for decades the USA has tried to strangle the Islamic Republic economically through sanctions, inflation, embargoes, shutting down their banking system

now we just have the Arabs give them 300 billion dollars

so they can pay the IRGC and their terrorist proxies around the world.

Ag87H2O
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Keyno said:

YouBetI'll go and try to find it when you admit you were wrong and simply eat crow on Trump's ground war that you are overtly ignoring for some reason. said:

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Why are you trying to change the subject? I am perfectly capable of using google to find the evidence for the claim you made, and there just doesn't seem to be any evidence. Hence why I am asking you.

I'm not. I've been asking you for a few days now and you simply refuse to acknowledge you were wrong on that claim. Why can't you simply acknowledge you were wrong about Trump's Ground War?

I'll try to find the earlier posts on Lebanon.

Thank you. As of this moment in time, I was wrong about the ground war. I made that claim a few months ago during a massive ground troop build up we were doing. It seems, at this moment in time, that a ground operation will not be happening, thank God. Delicious crow.

Now, I would really like evidence to support your claim that " Yes, as of this morning and you conveniently didn't reply until the President of Lebanon did a 180 on his position. Until today, they were working with Israel to help them purge Hez from Lebanon.'"

The official position of the Lebanese government is that they do not even recognize Israel as a state, have no diplomatic relations with them, and are technically at war with them. So your claim would be very interesting and groundbreaking, if true

And thank you.

Best I can do with my initial search:

Quote:

[From March] Lebanese President Joseph Aoun offered to hold direct negotiations with Israel for the first time since the 1982 Israeli invasion during Lebanon's civil war. Aoun also asked for a boost in funding for Lebanese troops and reaffirmed his commitment to disarm Hezbollah, a longstanding Israeli and U.S. demand.




These talks have a strictly limited agenda. They are focused on the immediate conflict between Lebanon and Israel. The stated goal is a "cessation of hostilities," the release of hostages, the full withdrawal of Israeli troops, and establishing security zones for the Lebanese Armed Forces.

And this is where the Israelis are rightly dubious. The Lebanese government hasn't been in control of jack squat in Southern Lebanon in decades - Hezbolla has been, at least until the Israelis went in and started taking them out. They have fired thousands of missiles into northern Israel at Israeli citizens until Israel said enough. Until the Lebanese government shows it actually has control and can provide security and maintain the deal, the Israelis are right to be wary of giving up control.
Keyno
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

YouBetI'll go and try to find it when you admit you were wrong and simply eat crow on Trump's ground war that you are overtly ignoring for some reason. said:

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Why are you trying to change the subject? I am perfectly capable of using google to find the evidence for the claim you made, and there just doesn't seem to be any evidence. Hence why I am asking you.

I'm not. I've been asking you for a few days now and you simply refuse to acknowledge you were wrong on that claim. Why can't you simply acknowledge you were wrong about Trump's Ground War?

I'll try to find the earlier posts on Lebanon.

Thank you. As of this moment in time, I was wrong about the ground war. I made that claim a few months ago during a massive ground troop build up we were doing. It seems, at this moment in time, that a ground operation will not be happening, thank God. Delicious crow.

Now, I would really like evidence to support your claim that " Yes, as of this morning and you conveniently didn't reply until the President of Lebanon did a 180 on his position. Until today, they were working with Israel to help them purge Hez from Lebanon.'"

The official position of the Lebanese government is that they do not even recognize Israel as a state, have no diplomatic relations with them, and are technically at war with them. So your claim would be very interesting and groundbreaking, if true

And thank you.

Best I can do with my initial search:

Quote:

[From March] Lebanese President Joseph Aoun offered to hold direct negotiations with Israel for the first time since the 1982 Israeli invasion during Lebanon's civil war. Aoun also asked for a boost in funding for Lebanese troops and reaffirmed his commitment to disarm Hezbollah, a longstanding Israeli and U.S. demand.




These talks have a strictly limited agenda. They are focused on the immediate conflict between Lebanon and Israel. The stated goal is a "cessation of hostilities," the release of hostages, the full withdrawal of Israeli troops, and establishing security zones for the Lebanese Armed Forces.

And this is where the Israelis are rightly dubious. The Lebanese government hasn't been in control of jack squat in Southern Lebanon in decades - Hezbolla has been, at least until the Israelis went in and started taking them out. They have fired thousands of missiles into northern Israel at Israeli citizens until Israel said enough. Until the Lebanese government shows it actually has control and can provide security and maintain the deal, the Israelis are right to be wary of giving up control.

OK? I was not having a discussion about WHY Israel was invading and occupying Lebanon. I was having a discussion with YouBet about whether Lebanon WANTS them there (they don't). Or whether Israel is working with Lebanon to take out Hezbollah (they aren't).

YouBet made these claims:
"What about Lebanon wanting Israel there to purge Hez?"
"Until today, they [the Lebanese government] were working with Israel to help them purge Hez from Lebanon."

Phatbob also made this erroneous claim:
"They [Israel] are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah."

The only evidence that YouBet could provide for his claims was some ceasefire talks between Lebanon and Israel which began back in April and had nothing to do with Hezbollah.
Science Denier
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
LMCane said:

for decades the USA has tried to strangle the Islamic Republic economically through sanctions, inflation, embargoes, shutting down their banking system

now we just have the Arabs give them 300 billion dollars

so they can pay the IRGC and their terrorist proxies around the world.




No, that was Obama's plan. This is the guy that destroyed all intelligence on Muslim terrorists. Obama wants the US to be destroyed.

The money now will only be PAID to contractors building stuff. And, it's in loans. Can't be spent on just anything like Nuclear weapons.
LOL OLD
Beef Cheek
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
More like Reality Denier!
bigtruckguy3500
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Has anyone noticed that almost all of our "intel" and assessments on Iran have been wrong? At least based on what we've been told/leaks. I am not sure how much of it was a psyop (either against Iran, or against the American public), but just think about it.

-The regime is ready to fall -> it wasn't
-The Kurds are going to act as ground forces -> they seemed pretty content sitting this out
-The Iranian people are ready to rise up -> they clearly aren't willing or able
-The government killed 40k/60k/90k (pick a number) - there is no evidence of this
-Take out the supreme leader and other leaders and their command and control will collapse -> they decentralized everything
-We've destroyed 80%, then 90% of their drones/missiles/launchers -> latest estimates claim they still have up to 70% of missile stockpiles and launchers
-We have complete air dominance - we didn't
-Iran can't survive a blockade for more than a week -> they can
-Iran will run out of room to store their oil -> they didn't
-Probably more I can't think of off the top of my head

I've heard that the CIA isn't as well positioned in Iran as it is in other countries. But this isn't really to point out that our intel services were wrong, so much to point out that we shouldn't trust the propaganda we are being fed.
Beef Cheek
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
bigtruckguy3500 said:

Has anyone noticed that almost all of our "intel" and assessments on Iran have been wrong? At least based on what we've been told/leaks. I am not sure how much of it was a psyop (either against Iran, or against the American public), but just think about it.

-The regime is ready to fall -> it wasn't
-The Kurds are going to act as ground forces -> they seemed pretty content sitting this out
-The Iranian people are ready to rise up -> they clearly aren't willing or able
-The government killed 40k/60k/90k (pick a number) - there is no evidence of this
-Take out the supreme leader and other leaders and their command and control will collapse -> they decentralized everything
-We've destroyed 80%, then 90% of their drones/missiles/launchers -> latest estimates claim they still have up to 70% of missile stockpiles and launchers
-We have complete air dominance - we didn't
-Iran can't survive a blockade for more than a week -> they can
-Iran will run out of room to store their oil -> they didn't
-Probably more I can't think of off the top of my head

I've heard that the CIA isn't as well positioned in Iran as it is in other countries. But this isn't really to point out that our intel services were wrong, so much to point out that we shouldn't trust the propaganda we are being fed.


It's almost like the administration has been lying
mjschiller
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Israel needs to obliterate Hezbollah who are an arm of Iran.
Marvin J. Schiller
Ag with kids
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BlackGold said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

AGHouston11 said:

Does anyone really believe Bibi is not going to sabotage this anyway possible?
It's been the same pattern the whole time.


Right... dealing with Hezbolah, a terrorist organization lobbying bombs at civilian targets, is the problem...

There's no reason for that to ever be allowed to be part of the discussion. It's a complete win for Iran to try to legitimize and cement their terror proxies when they are being ripped out.

Israel is currently invading and occupying territory in Lebanon and is bombing civilian targets in Beirut.

They are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah. We all know where you get your propaganda from, so we can forego the "Israel targets civilians" garbage.

Propoganda? Both Trump and Vance have criticized Israel for bombing civilian targets in the last 48 hours.

So what? Trump and Vance don't get to tell Israel how best to defend themselves. This is 100% on Iran and their proxy in Hezbolla. They were given the orders by the Islamic regime to attack Israel to provoke a response to give them cover to break the memorandum. They will never deal in good faith.

And it's propaganda.


Why would the US not tell Israel what to do? We literally pay for their entire military and give them all of their weapons. If we didn't subsidize their entire country, then I would agree we shouldn't tell them how to manage their business.

You do realize that the entire Iron Dome and the Arrow missiles are 100% Israeli developed, right?

So, not all their weapons...


Developed using whose tax dollars? I believe that would be the American taxpayer's.

The vast majority of the money that Israel gets from us is spent DIRECTLY on US military equipment, not any of their stuff.


We all get it. You don't like Israel.
You can turn off signatures, btw
AggieCVQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Can I have a million dollars? I promise Ill spend it at your next estate sale.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
LMCane said:

for decades the USA has tried to strangle the Islamic Republic economically through sanctions, inflation, embargoes, shutting down their banking system

now we just have the Arabs give them 300 billion dollars

so they can pay the IRGC and their terrorist proxies around the world.

I suspect the ME3 arab nations haven't sent a dime to the IRGC at this point. Arabs just are not quick to be parted with their money. Incentivizing good behavior over time I don't have an issue with, even though I am skeptical it will work for these ass hats.

The major/most serious question to my mind is whether their ICBM/space/nuclear/cruise missile programs (including KH-101 derivatives sourced via Kiev arms dealers of course per link below) are destroyed or not. Of course the IRGC claims they are 'on track' still.

I have yet to see a real thorough breakdown of the destruction of their 'missile cities' but Iran International has this excellent piece on them. It would be nice if the pentagon (or Israeli's, or anyone else) would provide a systematic briefing about these sites.

Missile leadership, at least, has 'changed' significantly:

Quote:

Front row, from right: Majid Khademi (later killed in the second war while serving as head of the IRGC Intelligence Organization); Mohammad-Reza Shirazi (later killed in the second war while serving as head of Khamenei's military office); Hossein Salami (later killed in the 12-day war while serving as IRGC commander-in-chief); Ali Khamenei; Mohammad Bagheri (later killed in the 12-day war while serving as chief of staff of Iran's Armed Forces); Abdolrahim Mousavi (later killed in the second war after succeeding Bagheri as Armed Forces chief of staff); and Mohammad-Reza Gharaei Ashtiani (then defense minister).

TxAG#2011
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

AGHouston11 said:

Does anyone really believe Bibi is not going to sabotage this anyway possible?
It's been the same pattern the whole time.


Right... dealing with Hezbolah, a terrorist organization lobbying bombs at civilian targets, is the problem...

There's no reason for that to ever be allowed to be part of the discussion. It's a complete win for Iran to try to legitimize and cement their terror proxies when they are being ripped out.

Israel is currently invading and occupying territory in Lebanon and is bombing civilian targets in Beirut.

They are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah. We all know where you get your propaganda from, so we can forego the "Israel targets civilians" garbage.

Propoganda? Both Trump and Vance have criticized Israel for bombing civilian targets in the last 48 hours.

So what? Trump and Vance don't get to tell Israel how best to defend themselves. This is 100% on Iran and their proxy in Hezbolla. They were given the orders by the Islamic regime to attack Israel to provoke a response to give them cover to break the memorandum. They will never deal in good faith.

And it's propaganda.


Why would the US not tell Israel what to do? We literally pay for their entire military and give them all of their weapons. If we didn't subsidize their entire country, then I would agree we shouldn't tell them how to manage their business.

You do realize that the entire Iron Dome and the Arrow missiles are 100% Israeli developed, right?

So, not all their weapons...


Developed using whose tax dollars? I believe that would be the American taxpayer's.

The vast majority of the money that Israel gets from us is spent DIRECTLY on US military equipment, not any of their stuff.


We all get it. You don't like Israel.


Have to admire just how effective AIPAC is when I read delusion like this.

"Yes they are spending our taxes, but it comes back to us. Trust me bro."
DeepETX_Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TxAG#2011 said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

AGHouston11 said:

Does anyone really believe Bibi is not going to sabotage this anyway possible?
It's been the same pattern the whole time.


Right... dealing with Hezbolah, a terrorist organization lobbying bombs at civilian targets, is the problem...

There's no reason for that to ever be allowed to be part of the discussion. It's a complete win for Iran to try to legitimize and cement their terror proxies when they are being ripped out.

Israel is currently invading and occupying territory in Lebanon and is bombing civilian targets in Beirut.

They are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah. We all know where you get your propaganda from, so we can forego the "Israel targets civilians" garbage.

Propoganda? Both Trump and Vance have criticized Israel for bombing civilian targets in the last 48 hours.

So what? Trump and Vance don't get to tell Israel how best to defend themselves. This is 100% on Iran and their proxy in Hezbolla. They were given the orders by the Islamic regime to attack Israel to provoke a response to give them cover to break the memorandum. They will never deal in good faith.

And it's propaganda.


Why would the US not tell Israel what to do? We literally pay for their entire military and give them all of their weapons. If we didn't subsidize their entire country, then I would agree we shouldn't tell them how to manage their business.

You do realize that the entire Iron Dome and the Arrow missiles are 100% Israeli developed, right?

So, not all their weapons...


Developed using whose tax dollars? I believe that would be the American taxpayer's.

The vast majority of the money that Israel gets from us is spent DIRECTLY on US military equipment, not any of their stuff.


We all get it. You don't like Israel.


Have to admire just how effective AIPAC is when I read delusion like this.

"Yes they are spending our taxes, but it comes back to us. Trust me bro."
AggieCVQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Nobody ever gives me the mil for the estate sale either.
74OA
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sorry, couldn't resist......

Queso1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This has got to be some variant on the broken window fallacy. I also particularly like the muh you don't like Israel bit, like that has any sway anymore..it did for a few weeks though.
DeschutesAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

AGHouston11 said:

Does anyone really believe Bibi is not going to sabotage this anyway possible?
It's been the same pattern the whole time.


Right... dealing with Hezbolah, a terrorist organization lobbying bombs at civilian targets, is the problem...

There's no reason for that to ever be allowed to be part of the discussion. It's a complete win for Iran to try to legitimize and cement their terror proxies when they are being ripped out.

Israel is currently invading and occupying territory in Lebanon and is bombing civilian targets in Beirut.

They are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah. We all know where you get your propaganda from, so we can forego the "Israel targets civilians" garbage.

Propoganda? Both Trump and Vance have criticized Israel for bombing civilian targets in the last 48 hours.

So what? Trump and Vance don't get to tell Israel how best to defend themselves. This is 100% on Iran and their proxy in Hezbolla. They were given the orders by the Islamic regime to attack Israel to provoke a response to give them cover to break the memorandum. They will never deal in good faith.

And it's propaganda.


Why would the US not tell Israel what to do? We literally pay for their entire military and give them all of their weapons. If we didn't subsidize their entire country, then I would agree we shouldn't tell them how to manage their business.

You do realize that the entire Iron Dome and the Arrow missiles are 100% Israeli developed, right?

So, not all their weapons...


Developed using whose tax dollars? I believe that would be the American taxpayer's.

The vast majority of the money that Israel gets from us is spent DIRECTLY on US military equipment, not any of their stuff.


We all get it. You don't like Israel.
Actually you don't get it. It isn't Israel we dislike. It is the Israel government's actions we don't like.

What you fail to understand is most Americans don't like evil and don't like liars.

Most Americans don't like traitors, even ones like Jonathon Pollard, no matter who they spy for.

We don't like what AIPAC has done to our political system. Can you understand why most Americans feel that way?

Most Americans don't approve of terrorism, genocide, or the intentional unnecessary murder of innocent people, regardless which nation commits it.

Do you know who Susan Wareham was? Or Ahmed Bouchikhi? What kind of government does such things?

Most Americans disagree with the lies and propaganda and other false claims Mark Levin and other Israel First fanatics spread.

When people falsely label objective fact-based and evidence-based criticisms of Netanyahu and his hardliner Israel government's actions as "antisemitism" and "hatred for Israel", they're gaslighting a lie. Most Americans see through that lying.

Most Americans are opposed to giving any more money to Israel. Political fallout here in the USA is happening.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
As all rational observers (which categorically excludes Democrats) know, Iran was definitely working to complete a nuclear weapon, which is also why they only wanted to suspend this program 5 years, and had their own military 'satellite' (the same size as a small nuclear warhead, on a missile capable as serving as an ICBM) program (to be launched on 'Fars-2 rockets) named after chief terrorist 'martyr Soleimani.'
Quote:

Mahmoud Reza Aghamiri, the president of Iran's Shahid Beheshti University and one of the Islamic Republic's prominent nuclear scientists, offered a rare glimpse into Tehran's calculus behind weaponization.

During an October 16 interview, he stated that the regime "has the capability and capacity to build a nuclear bomb" and added that Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei's religious declaration [against nuclear weapons] can change." When asked whether Iranian officials and nuclear scientists had ever considered building a nuclear weapon, he replied, "Certainly," explaining that the idea had crossed the minds of all scientists.

Aghamiri also said that if the Islamic Republic were ever to pursue a nuclear bomb, "it could do so in the best possible way," emphasizing that "the most important part of this process is enrichment." The issue of uranium enrichment and centrifuge capacity has indeed been the central impasse in the five rounds of TehranWashington negotiations in May, with both sides defining it as the ultimate red line.

Designated by the European Union, the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and Switzerland for nuclear proliferation, Shahid Beheshti University has researched optimal centrifuge-cascade parameters, electrodialysis for extracting uranium from wastewater, criticality calculations for explosive compression of uranium spheres, and neutron generation, measurement, and transport modeling.

comments echo those of other regime officials from the past week, including Ali Shamkhani, the former head of Iran's Ministry of Defence and Armed Forces Logistics. Reflecting on his 1990s tenure as defense minister, Shamkhani said in an October 12 interview that if he could go back in time, he would build a nuclear bomb.

Thankfully Trump stepped up to prevent that from coming to fruition.
Phatbob
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
There's issues with every government. But for *some reason* there are a group of people who take particular offense to Israel for it either due to gullibility to conspiracy theories or being religiously predisposed to it by replacement theology. On this board it's almost entirely replacement theology that brings out this... special attention to one particular country's human faults
Texaguser17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Because they get the most of our foreign aid…. So that comes with greater scrutiny. They also are the largest foreign donors into our political system.
Queso1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yet it's ok to question any government other than that government.

I object to my tax dollars supporting genocide and the murder of civilians. I've been to Israel and the people are wonderful.

The gravy train is just about over and will dry up completely once the Fox News boomers die out.
DeschutesAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Phatbob said:

There's issues with every government. But for *some reason* there are a group of people who take particular offense to Israel for it either due to gullibility to conspiracy theories or being religiously predisposed to it by replacement theology. On this board it's almost entirely replacement theology that brings out this... special attention to one particular country's human faults
Your post is filled with ridiculous lies.
Queso1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'd like to know what conspiracy theories they're referencing.
PaulsBunions
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

AGHouston11 said:

Does anyone really believe Bibi is not going to sabotage this anyway possible?
It's been the same pattern the whole time.


Right... dealing with Hezbolah, a terrorist organization lobbying bombs at civilian targets, is the problem...

There's no reason for that to ever be allowed to be part of the discussion. It's a complete win for Iran to try to legitimize and cement their terror proxies when they are being ripped out.

Israel is currently invading and occupying territory in Lebanon and is bombing civilian targets in Beirut.

They are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah. We all know where you get your propaganda from, so we can forego the "Israel targets civilians" garbage.

Propoganda? Both Trump and Vance have criticized Israel for bombing civilian targets in the last 48 hours.

So what? Trump and Vance don't get to tell Israel how best to defend themselves. This is 100% on Iran and their proxy in Hezbolla. They were given the orders by the Islamic regime to attack Israel to provoke a response to give them cover to break the memorandum. They will never deal in good faith.

And it's propaganda.


Why would the US not tell Israel what to do? We literally pay for their entire military and give them all of their weapons. If we didn't subsidize their entire country, then I would agree we shouldn't tell them how to manage their business.

You do realize that the entire Iron Dome and the Arrow missiles are 100% Israeli developed, right?

So, not all their weapons...


Developed using whose tax dollars? I believe that would be the American taxpayer's.

The vast majority of the money that Israel gets from us is spent DIRECTLY on US military equipment, not any of their stuff.


We all get it. You don't like Israel.


Lol simping for the US Military Industrial Complex just so you can defend a foreign nation is crazy
RangerRick9211
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TxAG#2011 said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

AGHouston11 said:

Does anyone really believe Bibi is not going to sabotage this anyway possible?
It's been the same pattern the whole time.


Right... dealing with Hezbolah, a terrorist organization lobbying bombs at civilian targets, is the problem...

There's no reason for that to ever be allowed to be part of the discussion. It's a complete win for Iran to try to legitimize and cement their terror proxies when they are being ripped out.

Israel is currently invading and occupying territory in Lebanon and is bombing civilian targets in Beirut.

They are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah. We all know where you get your propaganda from, so we can forego the "Israel targets civilians" garbage.

Propoganda? Both Trump and Vance have criticized Israel for bombing civilian targets in the last 48 hours.

So what? Trump and Vance don't get to tell Israel how best to defend themselves. This is 100% on Iran and their proxy in Hezbolla. They were given the orders by the Islamic regime to attack Israel to provoke a response to give them cover to break the memorandum. They will never deal in good faith.

And it's propaganda.


Why would the US not tell Israel what to do? We literally pay for their entire military and give them all of their weapons. If we didn't subsidize their entire country, then I would agree we shouldn't tell them how to manage their business.

You do realize that the entire Iron Dome and the Arrow missiles are 100% Israeli developed, right?

So, not all their weapons...


Developed using whose tax dollars? I believe that would be the American taxpayer's.

The vast majority of the money that Israel gets from us is spent DIRECTLY on US military equipment, not any of their stuff.


We all get it. You don't like Israel.


Have to admire just how effective AIPAC is when I read delusion like this.

"Yes they are spending our taxes, but it comes back to us. Trust me bro."


No dog in this fight. Just genuinely looking for information, but I though nearly all of our aide to Israel was Foreign Military Financing (FMF) grants with US suppliers strings attached. I could be wrong, but it's pretty formal and not a "trust me bro."

Even the Iron Dome, they R&D the system/build it, but Raytheon makes the interceptors.
K2-HMFIC
How long do you want to ignore this user?
RangerRick9211 said:

TxAG#2011 said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

AGHouston11 said:

Does anyone really believe Bibi is not going to sabotage this anyway possible?
It's been the same pattern the whole time.


Right... dealing with Hezbolah, a terrorist organization lobbying bombs at civilian targets, is the problem...

There's no reason for that to ever be allowed to be part of the discussion. It's a complete win for Iran to try to legitimize and cement their terror proxies when they are being ripped out.

Israel is currently invading and occupying territory in Lebanon and is bombing civilian targets in Beirut.

They are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah. We all know where you get your propaganda from, so we can forego the "Israel targets civilians" garbage.

Propoganda? Both Trump and Vance have criticized Israel for bombing civilian targets in the last 48 hours.

So what? Trump and Vance don't get to tell Israel how best to defend themselves. This is 100% on Iran and their proxy in Hezbolla. They were given the orders by the Islamic regime to attack Israel to provoke a response to give them cover to break the memorandum. They will never deal in good faith.

And it's propaganda.


Why would the US not tell Israel what to do? We literally pay for their entire military and give them all of their weapons. If we didn't subsidize their entire country, then I would agree we shouldn't tell them how to manage their business.

You do realize that the entire Iron Dome and the Arrow missiles are 100% Israeli developed, right?

So, not all their weapons...


Developed using whose tax dollars? I believe that would be the American taxpayer's.

The vast majority of the money that Israel gets from us is spent DIRECTLY on US military equipment, not any of their stuff.


We all get it. You don't like Israel.


Have to admire just how effective AIPAC is when I read delusion like this.

"Yes they are spending our taxes, but it comes back to us. Trust me bro."


No dog in this fight. Just genuinely looking for information, but I though nearly all of our aide to Israel was Foreign Military Financing (FMF) grants with US suppliers strings attached. I could be wrong, but it's pretty formal and not a "trust me bro."

Even the Iron Dome, they R&D the system/build it, but Raytheon makes the interceptors.



FMF does low interest loans with the requirement they buy US made equipment and then pay us back.
Geminiv
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Beef Cheek said:

bigtruckguy3500 said:

Has anyone noticed that almost all of our "intel" and assessments on Iran have been wrong? At least based on what we've been told/leaks. I am not sure how much of it was a psyop (either against Iran, or against the American public), but just think about it.

-The regime is ready to fall -> it wasn't
-The Kurds are going to act as ground forces -> they seemed pretty content sitting this out
-The Iranian people are ready to rise up -> they clearly aren't willing or able
-The government killed 40k/60k/90k (pick a number) - there is no evidence of this
-Take out the supreme leader and other leaders and their command and control will collapse -> they decentralized everything
-We've destroyed 80%, then 90% of their drones/missiles/launchers -> latest estimates claim they still have up to 70% of missile stockpiles and launchers
-We have complete air dominance - we didn't
-Iran can't survive a blockade for more than a week -> they can
-Iran will run out of room to store their oil -> they didn't
-Probably more I can't think of off the top of my head

I've heard that the CIA isn't as well positioned in Iran as it is in other countries. But this isn't really to point out that our intel services were wrong, so much to point out that we shouldn't trust the propaganda we are being fed.


It's almost like the administration has been lying


The Trump administration lying ? That happens a with this current group. However this go around there's a high level of incompetence involved as well.
Keyno
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AGHouston11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
K2-HMFIC said:

RangerRick9211 said:

TxAG#2011 said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag with kids said:

BlackGold said:

Ag87H2O said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

Keyno said:

Phatbob said:

AGHouston11 said:

Does anyone really believe Bibi is not going to sabotage this anyway possible?
It's been the same pattern the whole time.


Right... dealing with Hezbolah, a terrorist organization lobbying bombs at civilian targets, is the problem...

There's no reason for that to ever be allowed to be part of the discussion. It's a complete win for Iran to try to legitimize and cement their terror proxies when they are being ripped out.

Israel is currently invading and occupying territory in Lebanon and is bombing civilian targets in Beirut.

They are literally working with the Lebanese government to get rid of Hezbollah. We all know where you get your propaganda from, so we can forego the "Israel targets civilians" garbage.

Propoganda? Both Trump and Vance have criticized Israel for bombing civilian targets in the last 48 hours.

So what? Trump and Vance don't get to tell Israel how best to defend themselves. This is 100% on Iran and their proxy in Hezbolla. They were given the orders by the Islamic regime to attack Israel to provoke a response to give them cover to break the memorandum. They will never deal in good faith.

And it's propaganda.


Why would the US not tell Israel what to do? We literally pay for their entire military and give them all of their weapons. If we didn't subsidize their entire country, then I would agree we shouldn't tell them how to manage their business.

You do realize that the entire Iron Dome and the Arrow missiles are 100% Israeli developed, right?

So, not all their weapons...


Developed using whose tax dollars? I believe that would be the American taxpayer's.

The vast majority of the money that Israel gets from us is spent DIRECTLY on US military equipment, not any of their stuff.


We all get it. You don't like Israel.


Have to admire just how effective AIPAC is when I read delusion like this.

"Yes they are spending our taxes, but it comes back to us. Trust me bro."


No dog in this fight. Just genuinely looking for information, but I though nearly all of our aide to Israel was Foreign Military Financing (FMF) grants with US suppliers strings attached. I could be wrong, but it's pretty formal and not a "trust me bro."

Even the Iron Dome, they R&D the system/build it, but Raytheon makes the interceptors.



FMF does low interest loans with the requirement they buy US made equipment and then pay us back.


And when they need to resupply we pay for that too.

So if you are the MIC what's good for business?
First Page Last Page
Page 164 of 175
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.