flown-the-coop said:
Zona81 said:
flown-the-coop said:
I think it will be more than the IAEA inspectors sending a group WhatsApp message to the IRGC asking what they are up to on enrichment and then just taking whatever response as a completed "inspection".
Cute comeback. So China, Russia, UK, France, Germany and the EU all signers of the JCPOA were they all satisfied with these "WhatsApp" inspections?
Trump's big argument against the "Obama Deal" was money-related. Pallets of cash. Unfrozen assets. Sanction relief. (The White House official statement on withdrawing from the deal is interesting reading). Actually valid arguments. But did Trump follow up with a new and better deal to address the nuclear question? Did he mount the same international support for a such a deal? Nope. And President #46 didn't either.
So here we are. I'm predicting the nuke part of the agreement won't look much different than the deal Trump walked away from. And now that Iran has the Strait card, it could be worse. But as Trump likes to say, 'we'll see what happens'.
Trumps big argument on the JCPOA is that it did NOTHING to prevent the eventual development of a nuclear weapon by Iran.
Why the hell do we need input and support from countries that can no longer even defend themselves and their interests?
And the current status is already light years better than day one of the JCPOA, better than when Trump ended the JCPOA and not even comparable to what would be occurring should the JCPOA have been left to run its course.
JCPOA let Iran retain their claim to the SOH and did nothing to address their funding of proxies.
Other than that you seem to have everything straight.
Was the SOH closed before 2026? Seems that Trump was surprised when Iran did close it on his watch when he posted this:
"Open the Fn' Strait, you crazy bas***, or you'll be living in Hell - JUST WATCH! Praise be to Allah. President DONALD J. TRUMP"
So, if the JCPOA let Iran control the Strait, Trump didn't fix the problem by canceling it.
And Trump agrees with you. Didn't he say 'Let the rest of the world deal with the Strait. We don't need it'. So why would we be signing a bi-lateral agreement with those crazy bast***?
Iran has been a scourge on the world for decades. Every country has a stake in a non-nuclear Iran.