MaxPower said:
Semien had a higher WAR than Altuve last year.
Garcia, Jung and Heim have a track record of being good offensive players. It seems foolhardy to expect all 3 to continue to be that bad. Carter was only 22 this year and was hurt. He is more talented than any OF we have (no Yordan does not count as an OF).
Maybe our strategy is to hope the Rangers players fell off a cliff rather than just had bad years. Personally I think we should take them seriously and actually address glaring holes in the OF.
Offensively Altuve is trending down and still ran circles around Semien.
Heim had one slightly above avg offensively year in his career. 2024 is what he is.
Jung had a good rookie year and took a step back in his sophomore year. Where have we seen that before. He might be good, he might be avg.
Garcia will probably bounce back but let's not act like he's special.
You seem to take the rose colored view on their players but don't share the same view when it comes to guys like Chas or Pena.
Their offense was below avg / bottom 1/3 of the league last year. They need Burger and Joc plus a bunch of bounce back years to catch up offensively.