RE Lee, A Biography. Volume IV of IV. By Douglass Southall Freeman. Audiobook narrated by charlton griffin
Robert E. Lee. Soldier. Citizen. Gentleman. Traitor. Hero. American.
I struggle to think of any other American historical figure which whips up as much frenzy as Lee. Whether it is worship of him as a hero, or condemnation of him as a traitor and bigoted monster.
The former, Lee would be extremely irritated if not outright angry and I'm sure would insist he was no hero, doing only his duty for his country. The latter, I think he would simply look at the speaker with pitied reproach.
In this 4 Volume, Pulitzer-Prize winning biography takes us through a journey which spans from the deserts of Mexico to the fields of Gettysburg. Freeman's treatment of Lee is essentially unheard of in modern times - which is to say, a critical but favorable analysis of the man. It is nearly impossible in contemporary times to encounter a critical or nuanced discussion of Lee, whether by his fans or detractors, but Freeman takes us there.
As I alluded to, Freeman clearly is an admirer of Lee's, but he doesn't shy away from criticizing him. A common motif is Lee's aloofness to the execution of orders by subordinates, ostensibly due to his excruciating courtesy and worrying of hurting others. This indecisiveness caused several Confederate losses and Freeman explains them in meticulous detail.
If you want to see the real Robert E. Lee, without the dukes of hazard theme song playing, or images of rabid vandals tearing down his statues front of your mind, do like Freeman did and invited me, and invites you to do.
Sit at Lee's campfire for awhile, and I dare you to walk away unchanged.
Notes about the audio recording specifically:
I cannot recommend the company Audio Connoisseur enough. The narrator is always Charlton Griffin who, along with Scott Brick, I think are the two best narrators around.
AC has around 300 titles available now on Audible and Apple. Many of which are older, somewhat forgotten books that are either out of print or in the public domain. However, AC's most popular book is a narration of the complete Sherlock Holmes books so there's classic fiction in there too, including many epic poems including Homer.
I really appreciate what they did with this Lee book. The physical edition of this book is not readily available and can only be bought on eBay or Amazon by rare or collectible book dealers. An abridged, one volume version was released in the early 2000s which to be fair is available on Amazon via paperback.
In line with this, I'm now listening to AC's production of "Reconstruction, Political and Economic, 1865-1877" by William A. Dunning. Released in 1903, this book is more or less banned these days and harder to find than the Lee biography. I had no idea this was such a controversial book but give it a search.
CNN is an enemy of the state and should be treated as such.