Silent For Too Long said:
Derm, didn't you know? Origen was just **** posting for lulz.
I laughed.
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
Silent For Too Long said:
Derm, didn't you know? Origen was just **** posting for lulz.
light_bulb said:dermdoc said:light_bulb said:
Affirm that there is reasonable possibility of ECT hell. That those you evangelize should know it is a possibility and what that means.
Common Dermdoc. Affirm it. Otherwise, don't consider yourself a "hopeful" universalist, that which you actually just think is hard universalism
I will evangelize like Paul and the apostles did in Acts. Never mentioned ECT hell.
But you said you couldn't have ever had kids if Gods perfect justice did imply eternal hell. I'm sure you have reconciled that?
Silent For Too Long said:
Derm, didn't you know? Origen was just **** posting for lulz.
Angry Jonathan Zaludek said:
dermdoc said:Angry Jonathan Zaludek said:
I believe the worms that don't die are in dead bodies and Jesus was talking about the bodies tossed in Gehenna after the destruction of Jerusalem and the Temple in 70 ad.
This was prophesied in the OT also. And it never says the people wil be punished. Just die. I do not think this is about eternal judgement. No mention of heaven, hell, or eternal punishment.
dermdoc said:
Fair enough. I disagree. And I am not saying there is not a hell or punishment, just do not believe in eternal punishment.
I could easily be talked into annihilationism and there is more Scriptural support for that in my opinion than ultimate reconciliation. And I believe ECT hell has the least Scriptural support.
If you are interested read the link I provided on the four views of hell. Very well done in my opinion. And they address all of these verses. Different interpretations of course.
And I want to repeat I am not trying to change anyone's mind. I never knew there were well established different views of hell since early Christianity. And they were respected by even folks like Augustine.
one MEEN Ag said:dermdoc said:
Fair enough. I disagree. And I am not saying there is not a hell or punishment, just do not believe in eternal punishment.
I could easily be talked into annihilationism and there is more Scriptural support for that in my opinion than ultimate reconciliation. And I believe ECT hell has the least Scriptural support.
If you are interested read the link I provided on the four views of hell. Very well done in my opinion. And they address all of these verses. Different interpretations of course.
And I want to repeat I am not trying to change anyone's mind. I never knew there were well established different views of hell since early Christianity. And they were respected by even folks like Augustine.
I think this is the crux here. Whether or not I get talked into annihilation-ism has no bearing on whether or not its true or is something God desires.
Derm, the root here is you just don't like the idea of people suffering eternally and so it can't possibly be an option. But that is not how God has to operate.
And at the end of the day there is either A) A lack of trust in your own salvation or B) a lack of trust that God is the perfect, sovereign judge that will be able to be both justice and mercy to everyone. The saints have repeatedly been shown that the devil has ensnared this world with infinite traps and that it is impossible for man on his own to overcome them, but that with God all things are possible.
Saint Siluan had similar concerns about the state of man before God and God directly answered him, 'Keep your mind in hell and despair not.' God didn't say, "Don't worry there won't be any eternal punishment." God, even in revelation to assuage the saint, still only gave him enough to work out his salvation.
And thats all we can do in this life. Prayer, fasting, almsgiving, confession, forgiveness, humility, communion. Work on our theosis. A hugely central point of Orthodoxy is that we can only overcome the sins of this world with humility. The rest we have to pray for peace and for God's will to be done and trust that God is perfectly sovereign here.
Zobel said:
"God torturing people" isn't what he's saying, as far as I can tell.
dermdoc said:Zobel said:
"God torturing people" isn't what he's saying, as far as I can tell.
He may not be but there are a lot of pastors, especially of the Calvinist bent, who preach that. Jonathan Edwards was the model for that.
AginKS said:dermdoc said:Zobel said:
"God torturing people" isn't what he's saying, as far as I can tell.
He may not be but there are a lot of pastors, especially of the Calvinist bent, who preach that. Jonathan Edwards was the model for that.
Wrong. Jonathan Edwards understood what hell is: eternal separation from God.
I'm a Calvinist and understand Romans 1:18-31 to say hell where the souls of those who are/were self-decieved and decievwd others being stubbornly unrepentant for their sins go.. since God also clearly states, "vengeance is Mine." Also " Matthew 25:46, "These shall go away into everlasting punishment."
Hell is everyone's default destination if not for the grace of God by sending His Son, His work on the cross and saving us from that eternal separation from Himself.
dermdoc said:AginKS said:dermdoc said:Zobel said:
"God torturing people" isn't what he's saying, as far as I can tell.
He may not be but there are a lot of pastors, especially of the Calvinist bent, who preach that. Jonathan Edwards was the model for that.
Wrong. Jonathan Edwards understood what hell is: eternal separation from God.
I'm a Calvinist and understand Romans 1:18-31 to say hell where the souls of those who are/were self-decieved and decievwd others being stubbornly unrepentant for their sins go.. since God also clearly states, "vengeance is Mine." Also " Matthew 25:46, "These shall go away into everlasting punishment."
Hell is everyone's default destination if not for the grace of God by sending His Son, His work on the cross and saving us from that eternal separation from Himself.
Have you read Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God? Do you believe a loving God who created every person would hold them like a spider over the forest of hell? Have you read what Paul Washer, Steve Lawson, R C Sproul have said about God actively administering the punishment? Washer said that we believers and all of creation would applaud watching the damned go to ECT hell.
There is much more than eternal separation being preached by these guys. Who are all Calvinists.
10andBOUNCE said:
Sounds like you don't know much about Calvinism. Doesn't produce fruit? Joy? It's demonic. C'mon man. You are typically the "orthodox" poster I gravitate towards this most, but you're out of your swim lane here.
one MEEN Ag said:10andBOUNCE said:
Sounds like you don't know much about Calvinism. Doesn't produce fruit? Joy? It's demonic. C'mon man. You are typically the "orthodox" poster I gravitate towards this most, but you're out of your swim lane here.
You've never seen the depths of calvinism then. Those who take its convictions to their logical conclusions. That:
A) God has directly and purposefully damned people to hell. They were created for destruction, will not be redeemed, all through no fault of their own.
B) You cannot make any first step towards God. God does. You have no free will in the manner.
C) You cannot do anything to work on your salvation. Your fruits are worthless.
This leads to two groups:
-People staying awake at night, going am I going to heaven? What if God didn't chose me? He is angry and will damn anyone he chooses to hell regardless of how good of a life they live or don't-because nobody actually lives a good life. There's nothing I can do to assure myself of salvation, or any fruit I can rely on as evidence of the holy spirit regenerating me.
-People proud that God chose them. Their pride blinds them. Others be damned, they are elect. You can be elect if choose us. But you can't choose us, God chooses if you're in or out and we will use shallow human politics to make it feel like you are in or out of this church.
All heresies are demon driven. To confuse about the nature of God is a ploy of the devil. Are these people as damned as they say they are? No, because God isn't actually a Calvinist. Probably one of the most non-apophatic statements of God you can take to the bank. But this does cause all sorts of issues for the soul, body and congregation on this side of life. Anything the bolsters pride in oneself is putting themselves at increased risk here. Humility is the only way to overcome the snares of this life.
So when I say that Calvinism is demon driven - duh. Guess what is also driving the spirit of protestant splintering in every direction.
dermdoc said:AginKS said:dermdoc said:Zobel said:
"God torturing people" isn't what he's saying, as far as I can tell.
He may not be but there are a lot of pastors, especially of the Calvinist bent, who preach that. Jonathan Edwards was the model for that.
Wrong. Jonathan Edwards understood what hell is: eternal separation from God.
I'm a Calvinist and understand Romans 1:18-31 to say hell where the souls of those who are/were self-decieved and decievwd others being stubbornly unrepentant for their sins go.. since God also clearly states, "vengeance is Mine." Also " Matthew 25:46, "These shall go away into everlasting punishment."
Hell is everyone's default destination if not for the grace of God by sending His Son, His work on the cross and saving us from that eternal separation from Himself.
Have you read Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God? Do you believe a loving God who created every person would hold them like a spider over the forest of hell? Have you read what Paul Washer, Steve Lawson, R C Sproul have said about God actively administering the punishment? Washer said that we believers and all of creation would applaud watching the damned go to ECT hell.
There is much more than eternal separation being preached by these guys. Who are all Calvinists.
AginKS said:dermdoc said:AginKS said:dermdoc said:Zobel said:
"God torturing people" isn't what he's saying, as far as I can tell.
He may not be but there are a lot of pastors, especially of the Calvinist bent, who preach that. Jonathan Edwards was the model for that.
Wrong. Jonathan Edwards understood what hell is: eternal separation from God.
I'm a Calvinist and understand Romans 1:18-31 to say hell where the souls of those who are/were self-decieved and decievwd others being stubbornly unrepentant for their sins go.. since God also clearly states, "vengeance is Mine." Also " Matthew 25:46, "These shall go away into everlasting punishment."
Hell is everyone's default destination if not for the grace of God by sending His Son, His work on the cross and saving us from that eternal separation from Himself.
Have you read Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God? Do you believe a loving God who created every person would hold them like a spider over the forest of hell? Have you read what Paul Washer, Steve Lawson, R C Sproul have said about God actively administering the punishment? Washer said that we believers and all of creation would applaud watching the damned go to ECT hell.
There is much more than eternal separation being preached by these guys. Who are all Calvinists.
First, no they aren't all Calvinsts; simply slander to say it is.
Secondly, apparently you don't understand what true separation from God really is or haven't thought about it too deeply. If you think the world is bad currently (or has been historically - think of the hedonism of S&G or Rome): those are/were picnics compared to what man can sink to if unrestrained by God. Therefore, separation from Him is ECT hell.
And yes, I have read "Sinners in the Hands Of An Angry God" as part of my studies. Modern ears cringe at the idea that God is sovereign, righteous, just and holy and; as such, is 100% morally, ethically, and just to be wrathful towards sin and those steadfastly refuse to repent and ask forgiveness.
To those who say Calvinism is demonic, I'd say Arminianism is since it seeks to indebt God to each person for making their (correct) decision - while simultaneously they are dead (spiritually) in their trespasses of sin. Arminians won't admit this, but this decision/work is exactly what it logically works out to be.
It also makes man the determining factor of who is saved which is in direct opposition to Ephesians 1:3-6, "3 Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ, 4 just as He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before Him in love, 5 having predestined us to adoption as sons by Jesus Christ to Himself, according to the good pleasure of His will, 6 to the praise of the glory of His grace, by which He made us accepted in the Beloved."
As can be seen, God adopts us - not the other way around - and He did so before the world was created.
dermdoc said:AginKS said:dermdoc said:AginKS said:dermdoc said:Zobel said:
"God torturing people" isn't what he's saying, as far as I can tell.
He may not be but there are a lot of pastors, especially of the Calvinist bent, who preach that. Jonathan Edwards was the model for that.
Wrong. Jonathan Edwards understood what hell is: eternal separation from God.
I'm a Calvinist and understand Romans 1:18-31 to say hell where the souls of those who are/were self-decieved and decievwd others being stubbornly unrepentant for their sins go.. since God also clearly states, "vengeance is Mine." Also " Matthew 25:46, "These shall go away into everlasting punishment."
Hell is everyone's default destination if not for the grace of God by sending His Son, His work on the cross and saving us from that eternal separation from Himself.
Have you read Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God? Do you believe a loving God who created every person would hold them like a spider over the forest of hell? Have you read what Paul Washer, Steve Lawson, R C Sproul have said about God actively administering the punishment? Washer said that we believers and all of creation would applaud watching the damned go to ECT hell.
There is much more than eternal separation being preached by these guys. Who are all Calvinists.
First, no they aren't all Calvinsts; simply slander to say it is.
Secondly, apparently you don't understand what true separation from God really is or haven't thought about it too deeply. If you think the world is bad currently (or has been historically - think of the hedonism of S&G or Rome): those are/were picnics compared to what man can sink to if unrestrained by God. Therefore, separation from Him is ECT hell.
And yes, I have read "Sinners in the Hands Of An Angry God" as part of my studies. Modern ears cringe at the idea that God is sovereign, righteous, just and holy and; as such, is 100% morally, ethically, and just to be wrathful towards sin and those steadfastly refuse to repent and ask forgiveness.
To those who say Calvinism is demonic, I'd say Arminianism is since it seeks to indebt God to each person for making their (correct) decision - while simultaneously they are dead (spiritually) in their trespasses of sin. Arminians won't admit this, but this decision/work is exactly what it logically works out to be.
It also makes man the determining factor of who is saved which is in direct opposition to Ephesians 1:3-6, "3 Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ, 4 just as He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before Him in love, 5 having predestined us to adoption as sons by Jesus Christ to Himself, according to the good pleasure of His will, 6 to the praise of the glory of His grace, by which He made us accepted in the Beloved."
As can be seen, God adopts us - not the other way around - and He did so before the world was created.
Google every pastor I mentioned. They are very prominent Calvinist preachers. And how do you interpret this?
https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/etas/54/#:~:text=The%20God%20that%20holds%20you,you%2C%20and%20is%20dreadfully%20provoked
Do you know what double predestination is? That is the theology you embrace.