I liked it.

The nemoidians were really slick, and just as squirmy 100 years before tpm.

Thought the first two episodes were alright. The characters grew on me over the two episodes. Especially like Dafne Keen's character. Carrie-Anne Moss was all the Jedi. Squid Game is really good as a Jedi master.

I look forward to seeing how it plays out.

Madmarttigan said:

---

Thought it was ok, interested to see where it goes.

I felt like the opposite of previous posters, some scenes just have a very cheaply shot aesthetic to me and still think it looks meh overall.

---

Some shots looked off and some of the framing/shot construction was off, it was in my third negative. But there were some amazing shots as well. The vista of the sunset on Courscant as the ship was leaving was gorgeous to me. During the prison break on the ship the chaotic visuals really enhanced the story. Followed by a really odd choice of her buckling in into the seat that looked cheap.

To me some shots challenged for some of the greatest visuals and others felt like some of the worst.

Here are my quibbles:

Indara wasn't strong enough in the force to stop one knife while maintaining focus on the assassin? Whatever, move the plot along, I guess

Green Jedi - is/was she the classic stubborn, won't listen to anyone type in the books/comics? I expect her having to reluctantly admit she was wrong about something at some point.

Meditating Jedi - not much faith in the Jedi way if you just drink the poison. Actually not being able to let go of the guilt after all those years is pretty interesting. In the end just gives up. How does that help Mae, assuming that, as a Jedi, he should still want to do?

Just-made-knight Jedi - I hope he gets some actual character growth and doesn't just end up dead after we all point and laugh every time the Padawan show him up.

Yes, I consider these as nit-picky. I do think the Master on Olega was a really interesting take.

Ok, this next one is not really a complaint (from a certain point of view?). The show has slightly set it up as the Jedi being the authoritarian "bad guy," and I don't know how I feel about that. I guess it can be open to interpretation, but if you're not using the Dark Side and trying to hurt others for your own gain, I'm not sure why the Jedi would care if you use the Force. I imagine it to be similar to different sects of Christianity or whatever. We might disagree about some stuff, but we both think the Force is a way to help people and maintain peaceful existence. Then again, "peace is a lie"

Short lived mystery about who is killing Jedi, but I guess that is just the appetizer for the hunt to find the master behind Mae's plot. I'm in for that.

Finally, to wrap this all up. Sol's character is great. He is what I imagine a wise Jedi Master to be. Patient, self reflecting, optimistic. What a contrast to the master on Olega. Secluded and doing nothing for years, and then just give up.

The martial arts fights have been good. I especially love the way it showed the Jedi as completely unbothered by the action.

The Porkchop Express said:

---

Hot damn there was a Selkath from KOTOR in the first episode!

---

I remember them!

Yep, Sol is my favorite so far.

Tommen killing himself in two series now is both funny and kinda odd. Did not like that choice.

This show is obviously not on the level of Andor but like I said in another thread Andor and Rogue One are exceptions not the rule in the Star Wars universe. There are plenty of things to like about it so far, most has already been discussed.

The fights are pretty damn good. Really like the Jedi's methods/techniques.

The lead actress has been great, in fact most of the actors have been at least good. Still looking for more depth out of the Yord character. But really like Sol.

The "look" of the show has been great. Definitely feels like Star Wars, and not "cheap".

Storyline is moving at an ok pace.

He is paying for the feature, might as well as use it.

Been meaning to get stars again for football season and plan on using it more judiciously on this forum

Quote:

---

Seeing as there's apparently no way to make them not sound like boring, overly proper, stoic, stuck-up stiffs, I think I've finally decided that I simply don't like listening to prequel-era (and prior) Jedi talk. In fact, I don't think I like prequel-era (and prior) Jedi at all, and maybe/hopefully that's partly the point? Either way, beyond the dialogue, they're just not very sympathetic characters, which obviously makes them hard to root for. Though, I do like Sol's vibe more than most.

---

You could be correct that the show is intentionally making the Jedi seem wooden and boring. It lines up with the idea that some in the galaxy see them as the bad guys. Especially considering the contrast Sol brings to it. Maybe he's just a better actor, maybe he's better written. I think it's possible that writers don't know how to write Jedi. At least not for tv. They fall into cliche character typing, and frankly probably don't have the time in the story to polish them into anything else.

Yord will be the test for this show, imo. Will he be the over zealous, hammer that only sees nails all series?

I thought the show was fine. It was entertaining and didn't have any real negatives. The biggest compliment I can give, as has already been said, is that it looks and feels like Star Wars. That can cover up a lot of minor disappointments.

Positives:

• Master Sol has been the best character for sure.
• The kung-fu style fight choreography is awesome and makes it feel a lot different from prior SW. I think Mae had a line at some point about how Jedi don't pull a weapon unless they are ready to kill. Having their hand-to-hand fighting skills much more refined and elegant than the prequel era and beyond really reinforces that point.
• I liked Manny Jacinto's character. I thought he did well.

Negatives:

• Amandla Stenberg is pretty bad. Mae especially is not a good character.
• Jedi overall were a mixed bag. Indara's death was cheap. A Jedi master should be able to stop two knives at once. It's even worse if the reasoning is that she didn't know the second knife existed. Mae was completely overmatched by Sol and Torbin, so what was the deal with Indara?

Things I'm keeping an eye on:

• Yord being shown up by the padawan was ok, but it's going to get tiresome if it happens with that much frequency every episode.
• We are going to need a more compelling villain pretty soon.
• Looking forward to seeing who the next white Jedi to get killed is

Overall I would give this like a 3 to 3.5 out of 5 stars. Pretty good.

Keep tweets discussing future episode plot points off the thread please.

Re: the two mothers, I guess I missed that dialogue...

So according to Wookieepedia, Darth Plagueis was born between 147 and 120 BBY.

The setting of this show is 100 years before TPM (32 BBY), making it roughly 132 BBY. (Plagueis would be at max, 15 years old.)

What are the chances either Mae or her master ends up being either Plagueis' master? Honestly I just hope it's not Mae, cause I don't know if I'll buy that.

I'd be ok with a twist that a teen Plagueis is actually behind the mask though.

It will be interesting to keep learning more about this fire that killed their parents.
Osha seems to think Mae set the fire and killed their family, but also died in the fire (which is what Sol and the jedi told her)

Mae seemed surprised to find out Osha was alive, and has likely been lied to by whoever her master is. Which is probably related to her task to kill the 4 jedi that were present. So now she finds out the truth that Osha is alive, I imagine there will be some conflict over her path forward)

Sol seemed to imply that he had a choice, and that Osha could be saved but not Mae..but did he actually think she died?

He flat out says he saw Mae dead. Osha also said "we saw her..." implying she also saw Mae dead. Some trick of whoever this master is? Maybe this group of witches or whatever is in the show? Idk

I don't think Mae will end up as a Sith Master. We already see the cracks in her when she learned about Osha being alive. I suspect we get a similar path as the inquisitor chick in the Obi-Wan show. Oh yeah, and the inquisitor who killed Barriss in Tales of the Empire. It's a pattern that Disney can't resist.

Brian Earl Spilner said:

---

So according to Wookieepedia, Darth Plagueis was born between 147 and 120 BBY.

The setting of this show is 100 years before TPM (32 BBY), making it roughly 132 BBY. (Plagueis would be at max, 15 years old.)

What are the chances either Mae or her master ends up being either Plagueis' master? Honestly I just hope it's not Mae, cause I don't know if I'll buy that.

I'd be ok with a twist that a teen Plagueis is actually behind the mask though.

---

species age differently

I"m calling it now. Sol is the bad guy.

redline248 said:

---

He flat out says he saw Mae dead. Osha also said "we saw her..." implying she also saw Mae dead. Some trick of whoever this master is? Maybe this group of witches or whatever is in the show? Idk

I don't think Mae will end up as a Sith Master. We already see the cracks in her when she learned about Osha being alive. I suspect we get a similar path as the inquisitor chick in the Obi-Wan show. Oh yeah, and the inquisitor who killed Barriss in Tales of the Empire. It's a pattern that Disney can't resist.

---

Could be as simple as he saw her run back into the fire, or something like that, and just assumed she died.
They love to have Jedi dialogue leave room for interpretation in their statements.
I hope they have the guts to not just do another redemption story, need some more complexity in star wars.

Watched ep 1 last night and enjoyed it. Overall look and production design is solid, action is great, and the concept is intriguing.

Agreed with others that they seemed to give away the twin thing rather early so hoping there's something else to pursue there. Looking forward to ep 2.

Brian Earl Spilner said:

---

MoreCushing4thePushing said:

---

I"m calling it now. Sol is the bad guy.

---

"Good is a point of view, Anakin."

---

Speaking of Anakin, there is another example of someone who didn't have a father. No two mom theory, but more of the immaculate conception route.

fig96 said:

---

Watched ep 1 last night and enjoyed it. Overall look and production design is solid, action is great, and the concept is intriguing.

Agreed with others that they seemed to give away the twin thing rather early so hoping there's something else to pursue there. Looking forward to ep 2.

---

My split personality theory isn't looking too good after episode 2, but that said, I'm not gonna write it off completely until we see both twins interact with people simultaneously.