With all due respect Mr. Thermos. YOU don't know what she "thought". You don't know her deep rooted intentions. But any terrorist or sympathizer has zero intention of using free speech for a positive Pro-American purpose.
She gets a one way ticket home.

Actual Talking Thermos said:

---

LMCane said:

---

Pretty easy to see who the leftists and the marxists and the Hamas terrorists are now. If you support illegal aliens staying in the United States- you are not a patriotic American.

---

She wasn't an "illegal alien" she was a Fulbright scholar studying childhood development, who thought she had come to a country where a vigorous exchange of ideas could take place. She was made "illegal" without notice and practically black bag renditioned because of her writing. No doubt she took part in protests too, but so do a zillion other students for a zillion other causes. It was obviously the anti-Israel nature of her opinions that got her singled out and made an example of when she openly and zealously advocated for those opinions. Opinions are permissible only so long as they don't offend the regime.

---

If she is a foreigner and a student in the US and takes part in activism, then off she goes.
We are under no obligation to let her study here. She can fight in her home country (she knows they will stone her if she dares to)

Simple. FAFO

SHE DID

Actual Talking Thermos said:

---

But just because the government has the power doesn't mean this isn't a misuse, an abuse of that power.

---

All it means is that you disagree with it.

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Step 1: Designate the NRA as a terrorist group
Step 2: Arrest all NRA-supporters for funding and furthering the cause of a terrorist group
Step 3: Rinse and repeat until you have no opposition
Step 4: Never lose an election again


Unfortunately not shocking at all that some of you don't see how this can be further abused and misused by the democrats if they ever manage to stumble their way back into power. "But but but they did it to me first" is not the correct answer in these situations.

---

Apples to oranges. They revoked her privilege to be here. She is a non citizen and removed her.

You cannot remove citizens from the US.

And you actually think Hamas is not a terrorist organization? And that the NRA is one? One of these is demonstrably not like the other.

Try harder.

---

According to the OP she was arrested for her op-ed, which had nothing to do with Hamas and everything to do with a useless student senate at a diploma mill university doing things that student senates do.

You don't get to spend four years whining and crying about the lack of due process for January 6 victims and then turn around and encourage the same behavior against people you disagree with.

---

She is a non-immigrant. She can be removed. The end.

Edit: I'll give an example. When I was ICE is Dallas, a non immigrant from Holland slept with a married man she should not have and the wife complained to her Senator. Bing bang boom, it ended up on my desk, and I arrested her the next day at the Las Colinas Equestrian Center where she was riding and she was on the plane back to Holland the following week.

---

Tom, you work with ICE?
Cool!

Actual Talking Thermos said:

---

LMCane said:

---

Pretty easy to see who the leftists and the marxists and the Hamas terrorists are now. If you support illegal aliens staying in the United States- you are not a patriotic American.

---

She wasn't an "illegal alien" she was a Fulbright scholar studying childhood development, who thought she had come to a country where a vigorous exchange of ideas could take place. She was made "illegal" without notice and practically black bag renditioned because of her writing. No doubt she took part in protests too, but so do a zillion other students for a zillion other causes. It was obviously the anti-Israel nature of her opinions that got her singled out and made an example of when she openly and zealously advocated for those opinions. Opinions are permissible only so long as they don't offend the regime.

---

So being a Fulbright scholar is a green light to be an ******* as a guest here? What kind of logic is this? maybe she should stay in Turkey and get educated there.

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Step 1: Designate the NRA as a terrorist group
Step 2: Arrest all NRA-supporters for funding and furthering the cause of a terrorist group
Step 3: Rinse and repeat until you have no opposition
Step 4: Never lose an election again


Unfortunately not shocking at all that some of you don't see how this can be further abused and misused by the democrats if they ever manage to stumble their way back into power. "But but but they did it to me first" is not the correct answer in these situations.

---

Apples to oranges. They revoked her privilege to be here. She is a non citizen and removed her.

You cannot remove citizens from the US.

And you actually think Hamas is not a terrorist organization? And that the NRA is one? One of these is demonstrably not like the other.

Try harder.

---

According to the OP she was arrested for her op-ed, which had nothing to do with Hamas and everything to do with a useless student senate at a diploma mill university doing things that student senates do.

You don't get to spend four years whining and crying about the lack of due process for January 6 victims and then turn around and encourage the same behavior against people you disagree with.

---

She is a non-immigrant. She can be removed. The end.

Edit: I'll give an example. When I was ICE is Dallas, a non immigrant from Holland slept with a married man she should not have and the wife complained to her Senator. Bing bang boom, it ended up on my desk, and I arrested her the next day at the Las Colinas Equestrian Center where she was riding and she was on the plane back to Holland the following week.

---

This Danish chic literally FAFO!!

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Step 1: Designate the NRA as a terrorist group
Step 2: Arrest all NRA-supporters for funding and furthering the cause of a terrorist group
Step 3: Rinse and repeat until you have no opposition
Step 4: Never lose an election again


Unfortunately not shocking at all that some of you don't see how this can be further abused and misused by the democrats if they ever manage to stumble their way back into power. "But but but they did it to me first" is not the correct answer in these situations.

---

Apples to oranges. They revoked her privilege to be here. She is a non citizen and removed her.

You cannot remove citizens from the US.

And you actually think Hamas is not a terrorist organization? And that the NRA is one? One of these is demonstrably not like the other.

Try harder.

---

According to the OP she was arrested for her op-ed, which had nothing to do with Hamas and everything to do with a useless student senate at a diploma mill university doing things that student senates do.

You don't get to spend four years whining and crying about the lack of due process for January 6 victims and then turn around and encourage the same behavior against people you disagree with.

---

The OP cites the WaPo, which has been known to exaggerate, propagandize, editorialize and be highly selective in the "facts" that they report. And yet you are willing to accept these "facts" as gospel.

There is a reason many appeal to the 48 hour rule, especially when discussing articles from biased sources with a clear agenda.

If the facts remain after a suitable period that this grad student did nothing more than post opinions supporting a terrorist organization, then revoking her visa remains entirely correct but hauling her off in handcuffs may have been excessive though lawful. If facts yet to be disclosed reveal that she might have been a danger to anyone, or that her actions were more than just exercising her free speech, then the "masked agents" and handcuffs were justified. But I'll bet the WaPo is not going to be the one to expose those aggravating factors, will it?

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Here is what she wrote that led to this arrest. Let's not take the media's words for it, just read it yourself. Hardly a controversial article.

https://www.tuftsdaily.com/article/2024/03/4ftk27sm6jkj

---

I guarantee there is more to this than just that article

agracer said:

---

Actual Talking Thermos said:

---

Pizza said:

---

The last 4 years were a constant assault on free speech by progressive leftists, who targeted conservatives. Quit acting like you care about free speech.

---

" As I would not be a slave, so I would not be a master. This expresses my idea of democracy. Whatever differs from this, to the extent of the difference, is no democracy." - Abraham Lincoln

---

Didn't Lincoln throw journalists in jail and tease over/shut down some newspapers?

I'll hang up and listen.

---

Over 14,000 political dissenters were thrown in prison without habeas corpus and over 300 Northern newspapers were shut down by Honest Abe. Oh, and he started a war that killed over 900,000 Americans. Nothing Constitutional or lawful, but he has some cool quotes.

infinity ag said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Step 1: Designate the NRA as a terrorist group
Step 2: Arrest all NRA-supporters for funding and furthering the cause of a terrorist group
Step 3: Rinse and repeat until you have no opposition
Step 4: Never lose an election again


Unfortunately not shocking at all that some of you don't see how this can be further abused and misused by the democrats if they ever manage to stumble their way back into power. "But but but they did it to me first" is not the correct answer in these situations.

---

Apples to oranges. They revoked her privilege to be here. She is a non citizen and removed her.

You cannot remove citizens from the US.

And you actually think Hamas is not a terrorist organization? And that the NRA is one? One of these is demonstrably not like the other.

Try harder.

---

According to the OP she was arrested for her op-ed, which had nothing to do with Hamas and everything to do with a useless student senate at a diploma mill university doing things that student senates do.

You don't get to spend four years whining and crying about the lack of due process for January 6 victims and then turn around and encourage the same behavior against people you disagree with.

---

She is a non-immigrant. She can be removed. The end.

Edit: I'll give an example. When I was ICE is Dallas, a non immigrant from Holland slept with a married man she should not have and the wife complained to her Senator. Bing bang boom, it ended up on my desk, and I arrested her the next day at the Las Colinas Equestrian Center where she was riding and she was on the plane back to Holland the following week.

---

Tom, you work with ICE?
Cool!

---

Not anymore. I was a Special Agent from 1997-2003. I'm an attorney now.

Beware the slippery slope to Gestapo.

Freedom of speech is not granted by the government.

Non-citizens in America have freedom of speech. pic.twitter.com/77hm4ICgMf

— Ron Paul (@RonPaul) March 27, 2025

Gig em G said:

---

Beware the slippery slope to Gestapo.

Freedom of speech is not granted by the government.

Non-citizens in America have freedom of speech. pic.twitter.com/77hm4ICgMf

— Ron Paul (@RonPaul) March 27, 2025

---

I'm glad Ron spoke up

BSS123456 said:

---

Gig em G said:

---

Beware the slippery slope to Gestapo.

Freedom of speech is not granted by the government.

Non-citizens in America have freedom of speech. pic.twitter.com/77hm4ICgMf

— Ron Paul (@RonPaul) March 27, 2025

---

I'm glad Ron spoke up

---

I don't disagree with Ron here.

But, as has been stated multiple times on this thread, just because she has the right to speak freely does not mean that she has the right for her visa to not be revoked.

I'm not sure about the legality on this whole situation, I think it's a bad look regardless. It says she's pro Palestinian protestor and that's the reasoning behind this. I think it sets a bad precedent …

So, it's a bad look for us to expel folks shouting "Death to Israel! Death to America!" Folks that are not citizens, folks who are foreign nationals on a visa?

Yeah, that worked out real well with the guys that were here learning to fly a plane (but skipped landing classes)

Why were the officers plain clothes/in masks?

I don't.

Now, putting her in cuffs like that might have been overkill, but I have no problem with her having her visa revoked and get sent packing.

swimmerbabe11 said:

---

Why were the officers plain clothes/in masks?

---

So they don't get doxxed and have their houses burned down.

Hornbeck said:

---

swimmerbabe11 said:

---

Why were the officers plain clothes/in masks?

---

So they don't get doxxed and have their houses burned down.

---

I don't think that's a good enough reason.

Those guys weren't protesting for starters, also did she say death to America? I couldn't care less about Israel, I wish they would stop dragging America into their BS.

Also I support all free speech, I support neo Nazis going out and protesting as much as I support pro Hamas to go out and protest. I believe in the first amendment

And you are well within your rights as a citizen to have that opinion.

Silly me, I thought you were asking an honest question, not just fishing for an answer to shoot down and feel smug about.

swimmerbabe11 said:

---

Why were the officers plain clothes/in masks?

---

Hamas supporters are crawling all over the US. You don't want them to kidnap the kids of the cops.

swimmerbabe11 said:

---

Hornbeck said:

---

swimmerbabe11 said:

---

Why were the officers plain clothes/in masks?

---

So they don't get doxxed and have their houses burned down.

---

I don't think that's a good enough reason.

---

Tell me when it is your kid getting kidnapped or your house burned down.

swimmerbabe11 said:

---

Hornbeck said:

---

swimmerbabe11 said:

---

Why were the officers plain clothes/in masks?

---

So they don't get doxxed and have their houses burned down.

---

I don't think that's a good enough reason.

---

Lol you don't think its a good reason?? Police quite often work in plain clothes all across the country.

She officially FAFO'd.

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Step 1: Designate the NRA as a terrorist group
Step 2: Arrest all NRA-supporters for funding and furthering the cause of a terrorist group
Step 3: Rinse and repeat until you have no opposition
Step 4: Never lose an election again


Unfortunately not shocking at all that some of you don't see how this can be further abused and misused by the democrats if they ever manage to stumble their way back into power. "But but but they did it to me first" is not the correct answer in these situations.

---

Apples to oranges. They revoked her privilege to be here. She is a non citizen and removed her.

You cannot remove citizens from the US.

And you actually think Hamas is not a terrorist organization? And that the NRA is one? One of these is demonstrably not like the other.

Try harder.

---

According to the OP she was arrested for her op-ed, which had nothing to do with Hamas and everything to do with a useless student senate at a diploma mill university doing things that student senates do.

You don't get to spend four years whining and crying about the lack of due process for January 6 victims and then turn around and encourage the same behavior against people you disagree with.

---

This is not correct.

The OP does not say that...

Please provide proof that she was arrested for her op-ed. Not speculation...

Actual Talking Thermos said:

---

LMCane said:

---

Pretty easy to see who the leftists and the marxists and the Hamas terrorists are now. If you support illegal aliens staying in the United States- you are not a patriotic American.

---

She wasn't an "illegal alien" she was a Fulbright scholar studying childhood development, who thought she had come to a country where a vigorous exchange of ideas could take place. She was made "illegal" without notice and practically black bag renditioned because of her writing. No doubt she took part in protests too, but so do a zillion other students for a zillion other causes. It was obviously the anti-Israel nature of her opinions that got her singled out and made an example of when she openly and zealously advocated for those opinions. Opinions are permissible only so long as they don't offend the regime.

---

Show me one link that the adminstration has said this is because of her writing.

AGpops1923 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Step 1: Designate the NRA as a terrorist group
Step 2: Arrest all NRA-supporters for funding and furthering the cause of a terrorist group
Step 3: Rinse and repeat until you have no opposition
Step 4: Never lose an election again


Unfortunately not shocking at all that some of you don't see how this can be further abused and misused by the democrats if they ever manage to stumble their way back into power. "But but but they did it to me first" is not the correct answer in these situations.

---

Apples to oranges. They revoked her privilege to be here. She is a non citizen and removed her.

You cannot remove citizens from the US.

And you actually think Hamas is not a terrorist organization? And that the NRA is one? One of these is demonstrably not like the other.

Try harder.

---

According to the OP she was arrested for her op-ed, which had nothing to do with Hamas and everything to do with a useless student senate at a diploma mill university doing things that student senates do.

You don't get to spend four years whining and crying about the lack of due process for January 6 victims and then turn around and encourage the same behavior against people you disagree with.

---

She is a non-immigrant. She can be removed. The end.

Edit: I'll give an example. When I was ICE is Dallas, a non immigrant from Holland slept with a married man she should not have and the wife complained to her Senator. Bing bang boom, it ended up on my desk, and I arrested her the next day at the Las Colinas Equestrian Center where she was riding and she was on the plane back to Holland the following week.

---

This Danish chic literally FAFO!!

---

Denmark != Holland

hth

ts5641 said:

---

She officially FAFO'd.

---

The way Muslims operate is they go to Kafir (non Muslim) countries and make pests of themselves. Protest abotu Gaza, Pray on the streets, prayers on loudspeaker etc. Kafir people put up with it because they are by nature civilized and tolerant. Until it gets to be too much. That is when the Muslim person gets arrested and kicked out or jailed. The next step is that Muslims dog-whistle and try to get other Muslims and leftist orgs to raise a ruckus. That is a downside with democracies is that you will find someone who wants to partner with Muslim extremist groups for electoral benefit. Dems in US, Congress Party in India, Liberal Party in UK and Canada. They are all the same and Muslims know this. They then paint the host Government as "fascist" and try to escalate.

This has happened over and over again.

Ag with kids said:

---

AGpops1923 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Step 1: Designate the NRA as a terrorist group
Step 2: Arrest all NRA-supporters for funding and furthering the cause of a terrorist group
Step 3: Rinse and repeat until you have no opposition
Step 4: Never lose an election again


Unfortunately not shocking at all that some of you don't see how this can be further abused and misused by the democrats if they ever manage to stumble their way back into power. "But but but they did it to me first" is not the correct answer in these situations.

---

Apples to oranges. They revoked her privilege to be here. She is a non citizen and removed her.

You cannot remove citizens from the US.

And you actually think Hamas is not a terrorist organization? And that the NRA is one? One of these is demonstrably not like the other.

Try harder.

---

According to the OP she was arrested for her op-ed, which had nothing to do with Hamas and everything to do with a useless student senate at a diploma mill university doing things that student senates do.

You don't get to spend four years whining and crying about the lack of due process for January 6 victims and then turn around and encourage the same behavior against people you disagree with.

---

She is a non-immigrant. She can be removed. The end.

Edit: I'll give an example. When I was ICE is Dallas, a non immigrant from Holland slept with a married man she should not have and the wife complained to her Senator. Bing bang boom, it ended up on my desk, and I arrested her the next day at the Las Colinas Equestrian Center where she was riding and she was on the plane back to Holland the following week.

---

This Danish chic literally FAFO!!

---

Denmark != Holland

hth

---

I see that you are a programmer.
Hopefully not an H1B

infinity ag said:

---

Ag with kids said:

---

AGpops1923 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Step 1: Designate the NRA as a terrorist group
Step 2: Arrest all NRA-supporters for funding and furthering the cause of a terrorist group
Step 3: Rinse and repeat until you have no opposition
Step 4: Never lose an election again


Unfortunately not shocking at all that some of you don't see how this can be further abused and misused by the democrats if they ever manage to stumble their way back into power. "But but but they did it to me first" is not the correct answer in these situations.

---

Apples to oranges. They revoked her privilege to be here. She is a non citizen and removed her.

You cannot remove citizens from the US.

And you actually think Hamas is not a terrorist organization? And that the NRA is one? One of these is demonstrably not like the other.

Try harder.

---

According to the OP she was arrested for her op-ed, which had nothing to do with Hamas and everything to do with a useless student senate at a diploma mill university doing things that student senates do.

You don't get to spend four years whining and crying about the lack of due process for January 6 victims and then turn around and encourage the same behavior against people you disagree with.

---

She is a non-immigrant. She can be removed. The end.

Edit: I'll give an example. When I was ICE is Dallas, a non immigrant from Holland slept with a married man she should not have and the wife complained to her Senator. Bing bang boom, it ended up on my desk, and I arrested her the next day at the Las Colinas Equestrian Center where she was riding and she was on the plane back to Holland the following week.

---

This Danish chic literally FAFO!!

---

Denmark != Holland

hth

---

I see that you are a programmer.
Hopefully not an H1B

---

No. US citizen.

But, I WAS born in Japan...

Ag with kids said:

---

infinity ag said:

---

Ag with kids said:

---

AGpops1923 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Tom Fox said:

---

WaltonAg18 said:

---

Step 1: Designate the NRA as a terrorist group
Step 2: Arrest all NRA-supporters for funding and furthering the cause of a terrorist group
Step 3: Rinse and repeat until you have no opposition
Step 4: Never lose an election again


Unfortunately not shocking at all that some of you don't see how this can be further abused and misused by the democrats if they ever manage to stumble their way back into power. "But but but they did it to me first" is not the correct answer in these situations.

---

Apples to oranges. They revoked her privilege to be here. She is a non citizen and removed her.

You cannot remove citizens from the US.

And you actually think Hamas is not a terrorist organization? And that the NRA is one? One of these is demonstrably not like the other.

Try harder.

---

According to the OP she was arrested for her op-ed, which had nothing to do with Hamas and everything to do with a useless student senate at a diploma mill university doing things that student senates do.

You don't get to spend four years whining and crying about the lack of due process for January 6 victims and then turn around and encourage the same behavior against people you disagree with.

---

She is a non-immigrant. She can be removed. The end.

Edit: I'll give an example. When I was ICE is Dallas, a non immigrant from Holland slept with a married man she should not have and the wife complained to her Senator. Bing bang boom, it ended up on my desk, and I arrested her the next day at the Las Colinas Equestrian Center where she was riding and she was on the plane back to Holland the following week.

---

This Danish chic literally FAFO!!

---

Denmark != Holland

hth

---

I see that you are a programmer.
Hopefully not an H1B

---

No. US citizen.

But, I WAS born in Japan...

---

"born"

Naturalized citizens will be the next phase of this. These same arguments can be applied to any naturalized citizen. We gave them citizenship based on them taking certain oaths. Protesting America's allies can be deemed a violation of those oaths. And off you go.

Maybe we should be having a debate about the true definition of citizenship and what one must do to retain it. Why should our country grant citizenship to anyone who is not loyal to it?