My thoughts from the other thread:
SPOILERS
I'd give it about a 7/10 up until Bryan Cranston died, at which point it promptly dove to about a 3/10 for the rest of the movie, at best. Poor writing, poor acting, poor pacing, pretty much poor everything save for Cranston, who was outstanding as usual in his limited role.
So the Japanese and U.S. governments were hiding a massive monster a half mile off of mainland Japan, flying all kinds of personnel in and out, while lying about a massive fake radioactive zone...and nobody figured it out for 15 years? Come on.
Then when it breaks out 15 years later...it starts calling to its mate...who is out in the Nevada desert (wtf?)...and they mate...and make a nest in the middle of a city...which apparently can be destroyed by blowing up a few gallons of gasoline even though it's the size of a skyscraper.......what.the.hell.
And all this time, Godzilla is....oh yeah, he's lollydicking around in the Pacific Ocean, being a fatass, wasting time swimming at snail speed so they can make the run time over 2 hours...what do they call that again? "Hunting" and "returning the balance to nature"? (seriously that Japanese doctor is the most garbage character I've ever seen, with his useless female sidekick being a close second).
Furthermore...what happened with the bomb? It was on the boat right under the Golden Gate Bridge WITH LESS THAN 5 MINUTES KEFT. HOW IN THE HELL DID IT NOT BLOW UP THE ENTIRE STATE OF CALIFORNIA???
Speaking of the nuclear bomb...OF COURSE the highly trained explosive ordnance experts arm it IN THE MIDDLE OF THE CITY before they get it out to sea. Gee...WHAT COULD GO WRONG???
I'm not even going to address how the "protagonist" (does he have a name? Eh, who cares) was about as charismatic as a brick.
Also, where the hell were the leaders responsible for deciding to contain these monsters for 15 years instead of killing them? Where was the U.S. President or whoever authorized that boneheaded move? It cost thousands of lives. Why wasn't that ever discussed, and why didn't anybody ever have to answer for it? Instead all we get is gray-haired General Overact-Every-Scene and his upstanding African-American underling handing out meaningless orders from an aircraft carrier the entire movie.
It was just terrible. If you consider yourself any kind of intelligent or critical movie-goer, I don't see how you could possibly enjoy this movie.